12th March 1938, Page: 284, Column: 1
Value Of Carbonisation
Gas Expert's Views
A lecture on "Coal Carbonisation and Its Importance in the
Life of the Nation" was delivered on the 2nd March by Mr. E. V. Evans,
O.B.E., F.I.C., general manager of the South Metropolitan
Gas Co., before the Royal Society of Arts. He said the coal and
oil deposits exploited for our use to-day are the accumulation by
nature over millions of years. It is only some 150 years since we really
started dipping into the treasure hoard of coal and some 70 years
since the oil deposits Were first tapped, yet already the winning
of coal and oil is becoming noticeably less easy. As to the possible
life of the world coal and oil resources, the existence of the world's
oil could be expressed in decades as against the life of coal which
is to be reckoned in centuries. However fictitious all time
estimates may be, it is indisputable that the rate at which we are
using coal and oil is immeasurably greater than the rate at which
they were formed. He thinks it is of international importance
that those nations such as ours who find themselves in control
of great fuel resources must regard themselves as trustees whose
duty it is to ensure that these resources are utilised to the best
possible advantage. The lecturer proceeded to say it is a fact
that in every practical use to which coal is put a proportion,
sometimes a large proportion, of the available heat is not utilised.
Coal used in the open fireplace puts into the room which it is
desired to warm about 20 per cent. of the potential heat of the
coal. NOW one of the causes of this low efficiency is that in the
same appliance we are attempting to burn gaseous, liquid, and
solid fuels simultaneously, and a further complication arises from
the fact that the three phases are changing continuously.
The end that is achieved by the carbonising process is the
separation of these three phases before combustion in order that
they shall be utilised in apparatus and under such conditions
that their individual properties are developed to the best advantage.
The most widely accepted practice in the gas industry to-day is
to distribute the thermal energy of the original coal into coke,
gas and tar in the proportion of 70, 25, 5. Now of the 70 units of
coke, 23 are used in the process of carbonisation and thus for
every 100 heat units in the original coal 47 are recovered as coke,
25 as gas and 5 as tar, a total of 77, and this figure of 77 is accepted
as the thermal efficiency of the carbonising process. The final
question that We have to ask ourselves is whether the enhanced
efficiency of these separated products is so much greater than
when the raw coal is used that it more than pays for the loss of
23 per cent. of the heat of the coal, together with the cost of the
carbonising process. In the large number of processes and
operations in Which coke or gas is used at present the answer is
definitely affirmative.
Knowing that the thermal efficiency of the process is of the
order of 77 per cent. it might, at first sight, appear that coal has
not been saved, but We must remember the fact that carbonisation
is carried out in order that the products obtained shall lend them.
selves to a greater efficiency in use. When gas and coke are used
for domestic purposes (and some 80 per cent. of the gas manufactured
in the country is used for domestic purposes), it may be
accepted that in effective efficiency 1 cwt. of coal is equivalent
to 5 therms of gas or 0.89 cwt. of coke, and calculation would
show that we have obtained the equivalent of some 400 therms
in place of the 300 therms with which we started and which is the
approximate heating value of 1 ton of coal. In addition to this,
10 gallons of tar and a quantity of sulphate of ammonia have also
been obtained. It must not be forgotten that besides this enhanced
thermal economy a great social benefit has been simultaneously
obtained. Had the raw coal been burnt directly, not only would
one-third as much again have been required, but a considerable
proportion of the tar, and all the sulphur recovered in the form
of sulphate of ammonia, would have been discharged into the
atmosphere.
The extent to which carbonisation of coal is carried out for the
purpose of separating its constituents into more readily usable
forms may be gauged by the fact that the gas industry of Great
Britain carbonised in 1936, 18,334,000 tons of coal, producing
12,286,000 tons of coke, about 310,000,000,000 cubic feet of gas
together with over 200,000,000 gallons of tar and some 86,000
tons of sulphate of ammonia. These figures taken by themselves
are not really entertaining; perhaps their magnitude will be
better conceived by saying that the coke produced was alone
equal in its thermal value to the whole of the coal used by the
railways of Great Britain, and the amount of sulphate of ammonia
produced was sufficient to fertilise a cornfield the size of Lincolnshire.
It must be remembered that the gas industry is not the only
industry which makes use of the process of coal carbonisation,
for an equal quantity of coal to that treated by the gas industry
is carbonised in the coke ovens which form an essential part of
the iron and steel industry. Part of the gas produced is used for
heating the ovens themselves and a considerable proportion of
the remainder is used for the many heating operations required
in the iron and steel Works to which the coke is supplied, while a
proportion of the gas (some 11 per cent.) is supplied to gas undertakings
for resale to their domestic and industrial consumers.
Thus, taking the two carbonising industries together, there is a
total of over 39,000,000 tons of coal treated annually by this
process of carbonisation and this quantity represents 22.2 per
cent, of the total quantity of coal available for home consumption
in 1936.
In a general reference to work that is being done in constructing
in Germany a national fuel policy by which the whole requirements
of solid, gaseous, and liquid fuels will be derived, Mr. Evans
said: "Germany is not well provided with rich coal, for a
considerable proportion of her coal deposits is of the geologically
young variety known as lignite. While this material is easily
mined it contains as much as half its weight of Water and has a
calorific value of just over one-third of that of our English coal.
Despite this, Germany expects by 1940 to be self-supporting in
the matter of liquid fuel. As an example of what is being done,
I would cite one district in Germany where two fuel processing
plants have been erected adjacent to lignite deposits. One lignite
is more suitable for carbonisation than the other and low temperature
carbonisation is practised. The tar from this is hydrogenated
to liquid fuel. The solid residue is used partly in electricity
generating stations and partly for the production of hydrogen
for the treatment of tar. In the treatment of the other lignite,
which is poorer in quality, some is used for the generation of
electricity and some is briquetted and provides solid fuel for
use in homes and on railways. Another portion of this poorer
lignite, less suitable for briquetting, is completely gasified by a
recently developed process employing oxygen and steam under
a pressure of 25 atmospheres and the gas so made is supplied to
local gas undertakings. This is only a bare outline, but even
although the procedure adopted in this district would not necessarily
be applicable elsewhere, a detailed description of what is
being done would be of great interest, for it illustrates what may
be done when a serious attempt is made to deal in a scientific
manner with the fuel resources available."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Evans, E. V. | | General Manager | |