|
12th March 1938, Page: 273, Column: 1 Notes On Surveyors' ExaminationCentral Examiner's ReportAt the examination for mine surveyors' certificates held in November last 51 candidates presented themselves, and 19 (37.2 per cent.) qualified in the written examination. In the practical examination the passes numbered 15, representing a percentage of 29.4 qualifying for the certificate. As the report says the number of candidates who came forward for examination was almost identical with that of a year ago, and it is gratifying to the Examiners to be able to report that the record percentage of candidates who qualified on that occasion has again been virtually equalled by the results of the examination under review. The answers to the morning paper did not give promise of such attainment, as with few exceptions they fell considerably short of the expected standard. Fortunately, however, the work done in the afternoon showed definite improvement, and as a result many candidates were enabled to make good their shortcomings of the morning. So much for the satisfactory details of the examination. As against that, it falls to be stated that practically 60 per cent, of the candidates received less than half the maximum marks for their work. Put yet in another way, an analysis of the mark sheets shows that the average marks earned in the written examination by those candidates who failed to qualify amounted to only 35 per cent, of the possible. From these facts it is clear that while the percentage of qualifying candidates is not unsatisfactory, the work performed by the majority was, as a general rule, considerably short of the standard aimed at by the Board. It has been previously stated that candidates generally show little aptitude in tackling questions which do not arise from their everyday duties. That criticism still holds, says the Central Examiner. There is also a tendency to depend on memorised formulae — the details of which have only been imperfectly assimilated — in instances where the adoption of direct or simple methods of solution render the use of such formulae unnecessary. Reports from the Practical Examiners generally indicate fairly satisfactory work in the various instrumental and other tests which comprised the oral and practical part of the examination. In the underground test with the theodolite, the instrumental work as a rule Was fair, but almost every examiner adversely criticises the work in handling and setting the instrument, which in certain instances is described as being weak. In the surface test, candidates usually maintained their reputation for satisfactory work with the level and, as a general rule, theodolite work was good. Adverse criticism is, however, made by certain examiners on slipshod methods of measuring and off-setting, as well as careless booking. In the office test, it is further stated, draughtsmanship was not always up to the expected standard and, as has frequently been noted on previous occasions, a large proportion of candidates showed only indifferent knowledge of Geological and Ordnance Survey Maps. Following the inability of any candidate from the Cardiff Centre to qualify for a certificate, one of the practical examiners at that centre states that in comparison with pupils from other centres, the South Wales candidates showed conclusively their lack of training. Below we give the text of the questions set at the examination, each question being followed by the comment of the Examiner on the general work of the candidates. The comments are in italics. Plans are not reproduced. The official pamphlet containing the Question Papers (2s. net) is obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office. Morning Session. (1) Compulsory Question. — The plan . . . shows part of a colliery leasehold which contains at comparatively shallow depth two seams situated 60 ft. vertically apart in the strata. An area of workings in each seam is shown, together with levels therein and on part of the surface ahead of the working faces. Show on the plan to the extent made possible by the surface levels, and in the same manner as it would be indicated on a geological survey map, the approximate position of the outcrop of the lower seam. Assume a uniform thickness of 30 ft. of alluvium overlying the rockhead, and that the direction and displacement of the fault indicated on the plan is maintained. (14) About one-third of the answers were good, the remainder exceedingly moderate. Many candidates obviously wasted much time to neither end nor purpose by sketching in contour lines over the whole area covered by the spot levels — a proceeding which a little forethought ought to have shown to be unnecessary. Others obtained the required solution by drawing sections showing the relative positions of the coal seams and the surface — generally with satisfactory results. Only one or two candidates gave evidence of having appreciated the fact that in the lower seam the barren area due to the fault was approximately 60 feet in breadth, and that on a geological map the position of the fault joining the outcrop lines would have been indicated by a single line. (2) A pond at a colliery is constructed in the form of an ellipse with major and minor axes measuring 100 ft. and 70 ft. respectively. Draw a plan of the pond to scale 1 in. = 100 ft., and thereafter calculate its capacity in gallons. Assume the sides to be vertical and 10 ft. in depth. (12) The small scale stipulated for this question was deliberately chosen for the purpose of testing the neatness and accuracy of such candidates as attempted a solution. The results somewhat surprisingly indicated that less than 10 per cent, of the candidates who attempted the question were aware of any accurate method of constructing an ellipse. In only a few instances was the draughtsmanship what might reasonably have been anticipated. (3) It is proposed to construct a branch railway to serve a colliery on ground which slopes transversely to the direction of the railway at a gradient varying from approximately 1 in 6 to 1 in 8. Reproduce in your answer book a page of a levelling book, and enter therein such assumed staff readings as you would take with a dumpy level at three successive pegs, each 50 ft. apart, defining the centre line of the railway, for the purpose of enabling you to determine the necessary cutting or filling. Thereafter reduce your staff readings to an assumed datum, and plot a cross-section at the third peg to scale of ½ in. 10 ft., assuming the formation level to be 20 ft. above the level of that peg. Take the width at formation level as 20 ft., and the angle of repose of the material as 1 vertical to 1½ horizontal. (10) This question was attempted by almost every candidate. Answers were not so good as they ought to have been, and in many instances the assumed readings bore no resemblance whatever to the conditions of surface gradient stated in the question. (4) State what you know with regard to the apparent relationship between the time of revolution of the sun on its axis and the recurrence of magnetic storms which affect the needle of a mining compass. From knowledge of such relationship would it be possible to make a reasonably accurate forecast in selecting a day which would ha magnetically quiet for precise magnetic work? During what hours would you expect magnetic disturbance to be at the minimum? (8) Surprisingly few candidates attempted this question, and still fewer gave evidence of having any real knowledge of the facts asked for. (5) Undernoted are the details of a chain survey alongside part of the boundary of an enclosure. The unit is the Gunter link. Calculate, without plotting, the area contained between the chain line and the boundary, and thereafter determine the position of a straight line which, starting from the end of an ordinate of 25 links at abscissa 0, will equalise the areas. (8)
This question was one which it was assumed that practically every candidate would readily find possible to answer correctly. In fact, however, only five candidates obtained a correct or approximately correct solution. The computation of area was rarely correctly worked out, while the latter part of the question proved too much for the great majority of candidates. Afternoon Session. (1) Compulsory Question. — The notes of a short underground traverse made with the theodolite are as follows :—
It is proposed to drive a cross-measures drift from the station A in the direction N52°30'E, so as to intersect the line EF at a predetermined point X. Calculate the distance EX, and the gradient of the cross-measures drift AX. (14) Answers generally were very satisfactory, and showed a distinct improvement on results obtained to a question embodying somewhat similar principles which was set several years ago. (2) Undernoted are the total rectangular co-ordinates of a five-sided enclosure, A being point of origin. It is proposed to utilise the enclosure for colliery housing purposes, and a sum of £1,770 has been agreed upon as the purchase price. Calculate without plotting the equivalent rate per acre represented hy that sum. (12)
Disappointing answers were obtained to this question — less than one-third being correct, or even approximately so. To get the required area almost every candidate adopted the method of multiplying the total latitude of each point by the algebraic summation of the departures of the two lines adjacent to the point, and invariably got befogged in the working out process. A rough sketch would have enabled the area to be simply determined from rectangle and triangle measurements, but only one candidate adopted this method. (3) The plan . . . is that of a heap of coal, large and small, which has been deposited on the surface as it came from the mine. Levels taken along the base thereof, and on the top of the slopes are also shown. Transfer the plan, without the shading, to your answer hook, and thereafter calculate the tonnage of coal contained in the heap, using therefore such data for weight as are customary in your district. (12) Answers were only moderately good. Few candidates adopted the method of dividing the plan of the heap into triangles, and taking the area of each triangle by the mean of the depth at three angles, which is probably the simplest and most accurate method. (4) In the sketch the figures indicated arc the co-ordinates of station B calculated from a geographical meridian through station A, which is the point of origin. The grid co-ordinates of B calculated from a prime meridian, which lies to the west of A, are as follows: N, 2003.0, E. 92080.6 The convergence between grid and geographical north in the vicinity of A and B is 17 ft. Calculate the grid co-ordinates of A. (10) Only a comparatively few candidates attempted this question, but generally they gave fair answers. (5) Certain workings in a mine are advancing towards the leasehold boundary beyond which, it is rumoured, old workings containing a dangerous accumulation of water exist. Extensive investigation made locally has been unsuccessful in locating any plans from which the position and extent of the old workings may be determined. As chief surveyor at the mine, what further inquiries would you make, and in view of the circumstances what measures would you recommend for adoption to ensure the safety of the workmen? (8) Answers on the whole were fair, although in many instances no reference was made to the catalogue of Abandonment Plans in which details are given, not only of plans deposited at the Mines Department, but of old plans in private ownership. (6) A roadway being driven direct to the dip on a seam, at an inclination of 6 inches to the yard, encounters a downthrow fault which hades at 2 vertical to 1 horizontal. The vertical displacement of the fault — which bears at right angles to the roadway — is 30 yards. Calculate the length of a cross-measures drift dipping 12 inches to the yard on the line of the roadway to win the seam at a point 60 feet (plan measurement) from the low side of the fault, and the distance from the rise side of the fault at which the drift must he set away. Assume the measures to dip uniformly on each side of the fault. (8) Less than one-half of the answers to this simple question were entirely correct. As is usual in questions of this type there was on unnecessary use of trigonometry, it being possible to obtain an accurate solution by direct and simple methods.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||