Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

26th February 1938, Page: 258, Column: 2

Ignition Of Firedamp By Explosives

By W. Payman and R. V. Wheeler.

Extracts from paper on "The Ignition of Firedamp by Coal Mining Explosives," presented on 2nd February at the annual meeting of the Institution of Mining Engineers.

The Testing of Permitted Explosives.

Since the introduction of sheathed explosives into this country in 1934, over 30 million shots have been fired with them without causing ignition of either firedamp or coal dust. This record is the more remarkable when it is remembered that the use of sheathed explosives (which has been entirely voluntary) has been for the most part in places where the risk of ignition of firedamp has been deemed to be greatest. This extensive, and extending, use of sheathed explosives may well account for the fact that during 1937, for the first time on record, not a single ignition of firedamp underground was caused by a permitted explosive.

Despite the satisfaction that mining engineers must feel at this result, it would obviously be wrong to conclude that in no circumstances need the ignition of firedamp by a permitted explosive be feared. Yet we believe that, in part by the development of the principle of sheathing explosives and in part by continued research on their compositions, freedom from such ignitions will eventually be assured. This belief is hosed mainly on the results of work carried out at the Safety in Mines Research Station at Buxton.

During the development of the modern permitted explosive its safety has been increased, up to a limit imposed by the need for (a) power and (b) sensitivity. For the most part the increased safety has been achieved by the incorporation in the explosive of "cooling salts," such as sodium chloride, intended to absorb some of the heat generated by the explosive ingredients.

The Buxton Test, since its inception in 1929. has allowed the production of a wide range of explosives sufficient to cover all reasonable requirements of the coal-mining industry, and at the same time has provided what can he considered a reasonable margin of safety. When the reports of accidents which have taken place underground are examined, in conjunction with the results of researches at Buxton, it is evident that when ignitions have been caused by explosives the conditions have been exceptional. To counter these exceptional conditions some auxiliary device such as the sheath is necessary. Tests for such devices must be supplementary to the usual gallery tests,. designed to simulate the exceptional circumstances in which ignitions occur in practice. Much research work has been carried out, and is still in progress, to define these exceptional circumstances and to devise methods of test which will reproduce the dangerous conditions that they present. Our general conclusion at present is that conditions are dangerous only when the cartridge of explosive is at some time during its detonation in direct contact with an inflammable firedamp-air mixture, or when its products of detonation, at the instant when detonation is complete, gain access to such a mixture.

Shot-holes in Rock.

When explosions have occurred in practice due to the use of permitted explosives it appears probable that either (1) the shot-hole was crossed by (Or was close to) a break, or (2) the shot-hole was overcharged. It has also been suggested that ignitions have occurred (3) because the shots were blown out. When it is remembered that in the gallery tests all shots are "blown out," and that in these tests comparatively little stemming is sufficient to prevent the ignition of firedamp, this last suggestion appears improbable.

It seems most probable that the cause of danger with a break is the same as with an overcharged shot, namely, that the detonating explosive in such circumstances comes into direct contact with the inflammable firedamp-air mixture, or the products of detonation do so immediately after detonation is complete. A series of experiments carried out in a limestone drift at Buxton, which could be filled with a mixture of firedamp and air, supports this suggestion.

The main conclusions to be drawn from work which is still in progress are: (1) The results confirm the conclusions drawn from tests at the steel galleries on the effect of the position of detonator, the length of the shot-hole, and the use of stemming. (2) Shots fired in rock or in coal are less liable to cause ignition than those fired in a steel cannon, from which it follows that a severe gallery test of an explosive would more than cover practical working conditions. (3) No evidence was obtained that compression effects are predominant in causing ignition in breaks, but such ignitions appeared, like those obtained with overloaded shots, to be due mainly to the products of detonation of the explosive coming immediately into contact with the firedamp-air mixture.

Causes of Ignition by Explosives.

When high explosives were substituted for black powder in coal mines, their increased safety in the presence of firedamp and coal dust was at first assumed to be due entirely to the fact that they gave less flame than did black powder. It was soon found, however, that flame could not be the sole cause of an ignition of firedamp by an explosive. Research work has shown that the causes of ignition may be several. These causes may be conveniently divided into four groups: (1) Flame; (2) Gaseous products of detonation; (3) Compression of the firedamp-air mixture ; (4) Hot solid particles.

One or more of three different types of flames may be produced when a cartridge of explosive is detonated. These are (a) the detonation-flame, (b) the luminous solid particles projected from the explosive, and (c) the secondary flame.

Some general considerations are: The detonation-flame is particularly dangerous if it is in direct contact with the firedamp-air mixture, mainly on account of its high temperature. The incendive effect of this flame may be offset by its short duration.

The hot solid particles may be grouped with the detonation flame as regards incendivity during the early period of their travel away from the explosive. Later, the products of combustion surround these particles and the ignition of firedamp by them is prevented, If such particles can pierce the layer of gaseous products whilst they are still hot, they may again become dangerous. Photographs with a stationary plate are of interest in this connection. Thus, it is found that with the same type of explosive fired freely suspended the detonation-flame is usually brighter with the explosives which are the more incendive. No relationship is found between the brightness or size of the luminous effect obtained when a cartridge is fired from a shot-hole and the danger of the explosive in the presence of firedamp, because of the number of factors which are involved. Thus, it is frequently found that if conditions are altered so as to increase the possibility of ignition of firedamp the amount of "flame" is less.

The secondary flame only appears to come into play as a possible source of ignition when there is a marked deficiency of oxygen in the explosive and its wrapper. The secondary flame is readily reduced by adding inert salts to the explosive, or by the action of inert dust used as stemming or produced by the action of the explosive.

One method of determining the ignition temperature of a gas mixture, such as one of methane and air, is to place it in a steel cylinder and compress it rapidly, thereby heating it, by means of a piston. This method, known as the "adiabatic compression" method, gives an ignition temperature of 450°C. for a 9 per cent. mixture of methane and air, it being necessary to compress the mixture to 1/13th of its original volume. Since the temperature of the gas mixture rises as it is compressed, the final pressure is 32 times the initial pressure.

It has often been assumed that when a shot fires into a break there is the same sequence of events as when a piston is driven along a steel cylinder, and that ignition in a break is due to compression of a similar type. But this is only correct in the unlikely event of a plug of solid material being forced along the break. Otherwise, the conditions of compression in a break are quite distinct from those that occur, for example, in a Diesel-engine cylinder, mainly on account of the considerably greater speed at which the gaseous products of the explosive move compared with that of the piston.

In addition to the luminous solid particles, records obtained by a special photographic method show that there is produced a distinct and separate mass of apparently non-luminous particles when the products of detonation of an explosive expand. The luminous particles are intimately associated with the gaseous products; the non-luminous particles travel mainly in advance of these gases and may penetrate, and even travel in advance of, the main shock-wave.

The distinction between these two groups of particles is important. It has been assumed that solid particles can ignite a firedamp-air mixture; it has even been assumed by some workers that, under certain conditions, they are the sole or the main cause of ignition by an explosive. We agree that the luminous solid particles can cause ignition, but we also believe that the main effect of the non-luminous particles is to extinguish flame and therefore to prevent the general inflammation of any surrounding firedamp-air mixture.

With respect to cannon shots, it would appear that the mechanical mode of admixture of the products of detonation with the surrounding atmosphere plays an important part in determining whether or not ignition will occur. It may readily be seen why inverse initiation is more dangerous than direct, for the portion of the explosive nearest the gas mixture is detonating more completely with inverse than with direct initiation. With intermediate positions of the detonator, inflammation of the gas mixture depends upon the distance of the detonator from the end of the charge nearest the mouth of the borehole.

The effect of firing a charge in the bore of a gun is complex and involves several factors. In comparison with a suspended charge, the effect of placing the charge just inside the mouth of the cannon is to increase slightly the incendivity of the explosive, possibly because the explosive detonates more efficiently even with such slight confinement. As the charge is pushed farther along the bore, so that what is termed the "free space" increases, the incendivity of the explosive begins to decrease, partly because the flame in the explosive itself is farther and farther from the main body of gas mixture, and partly because of cooling of the products of detonation as they pass along the bore.

Merits of Sheathed Explosives.

The particular merits of the sheath are as follows :—

(1) The value of inert matter or "cooling salts" in increasing the safety of an explosive has long been known. The sheath enables more inert matter to be used without affecting the sensitivity or the efficiency of the explosive.

(2) The sheath affords protection at the most dangerous part of the cartridge, that is to say, along the sides.

(3) This extra protection lies along the shot-hole and therefore protects portions of the shot-hole which may be crossed by, or may be in close proximity to, incipient breaks. If the material breaks up here the direct contact of detonating explosive and an explosive gas mixture is prevented by the sheathing material. If the hot gases and the shock-wave are projected into a break they will be similarly protected.

The immediate future development of research on explosives at Buxton will consist mainly of a consolidation of the ground so far gained. Attempts are being made to improve the sheathing materials and the methods of sheathing. One important matter to which it has not yet been possible to pay the attention it deserves is the choice of the sheathing material according to the type of explosive. Although sodium bicarbonate has been found to be the best material for a number of explosives it need not necessarily be the best for all, nor is it equally efficient with all. Special tests will in due course ensure the full adequacy of the sheathed explosives placed in the Permitted List, and will afford a basis for finding improved methods of sheathing or more effective materials. An important factor in this connection is the development which has been taking place during recent years in the manufacture of permitted explosives, whereby alteration in physical rather than in chemical composition has been found to have an important effect on safety.

One of the difficulties in the way of the promotion of these researches is the large number of explosives on the Permitted List. Not only does this make the task of increasing the safety of all permitted explosives more difficult, but it also makes the task of the mining engineer in choosing a suitable explosive for his purpose more confusing. This large choice of explosives we believe to be unnecessary and to serve little real purpose. Reduction in the number of explosives is long overdue, and would mark a distinct advance on account of the assistance it would afford to the mining engineer, the manufacturer, and the research worker.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Payman, W.      
Wheeler, Richard Vernon      Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print