26th February 1938, Page: 257, Column: 1
Flameproof Mining Electrical Apparatus
By H. Rainford, A.M.I.E.E., A.M.I.Min.E.
From a paper read at the February meeting of the Manchester
Geological and Mining Society. Mr. Rainford is Testing Officer,
Mines Department Testing Station, Buxton.
The safe use of mining electrical plant continues to command
attention from all branches of the industry. The annual report
of H.M. Electrical Inspector of Mines shows that there was an
increase of 77,092 horse-power of motors installed during 1936
and that for the period 1919 to 1936 inclusive the total horse-power
of motors, in round figures, increased from 587,000 to
1,109,000 below ground and from 442,000 to 978,000 above
ground. Accidents due to electricity, under its three sub-headings
of shock, fire and explosion, involved only 259 per cent. of the
number of persons killed during the period 1927-1936.
The use of electricity in coal mines is prohibited under Section
60 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, under certain conditions. Where
it is permitted, it is subject to General Regulations 117-137 which
include the requirement that, where there is a contingent risk of
explosion, the electrical apparatus must he designed and maintained
so as to preclude open sparking. This requirement applies
also under General Regulation (Lighting) 1934 to lighting from
the power mains in certain areas, in pits where safety-lamps are
required to he used, irrespective of the presence of gas. Open
sparking means sparking which would ignite inflammable gas
external to apparatus, falling adequate provision against such
an ignition. The keynote is, therefore, "adequate provision"
which can be applied by intrinsic safety or by flameproof enclosure.
Intrinsic safety means that sparking in a circuit is
limited to a degree which renders it incapable of igniting firedamp,
and the principle of intrinsic safety is applied to circuits of low
voltage and small power such as may be used for signalling bells
and telephones.
Design.
The object of flameproof enclosure is to confine such an ignition
of gas to the inside of the enclosure in a manner which can be
expressed by the definition: "A flameproof enclosure for electrical
apparatus is one which will withstand without injury any
explosion of inflammable gas that may occur within it under
practicable conditions of operation within the rating of the
apparatus (and recognised overloads, if any, associated therewith)
and will prevent the transmission of flame such as will ignite the
inflammable gas which may be present in the surrounding
atmosphere."
The main principles of constructional details are given in
Appendix 1 of Mines Department Testing Memorandum No. 4.
The details can he summarised as follows :—
(1) In general design, rating and electrical performance the
apparatus must comply with relevant British Standard Specifications.
(2) All joints in the structure must be opposed metal-to-metal
surfaces without the intervention of perishable jointing material,
except that inspection windows and cover glasses may be secured
by cement to their carrier rings or frames subject to approval
of the cement and relevant fixing details.
(3) The length of metal-to-metal path through or across any
joint surface, shaft gland or spindle bearing must not in general
be less than one inch, but a reduction of ¾" may be accepted for
very small enclosures. The presence of bolt holes may be ignored
in determining the breadth of a joint, provided the edge of the
hole is not less titan 3/8" from the inner edge of the joint surface
and subject to the qualification that the breadth of a joint should
automatically increase with an increase in the size of bolt.
(4) Associated with the minimum length of path under (3)
is the requirement that the width of any gap between opposed
joint surfaces and the diametral clearance for shafts and spindles
must not exceed 0.020 inch for apparatus normally filled with air
and 0.006 inch for apparatus normally filled with hydrocarbon
oil.
(5) Venting devices, for the relief of pressure, are generally
unnecessary, and they are only accepted in special circumstances
on proof of their necessity.
(6) Holes for removable bolts, studs or screws must not penetrate
through the wall of the enclosure and the heads of bolts
used to secure covers or inspection doors must be shrouded to
deter unauthorised persons from opening the enclosure.
(7) Cover interlocks are required on switch units, where
practicable, to prevent access while the interior parts are live,
and there should also be a screen over any live supply connections
to prevent accidental contact with such parts. Where a cover
interlock is not practicable, and preferably also in addition to
such an interlock, the cover should carry a warning notice to the
effect that the unit must be isolated from the supply before the
enclosure is opened.
(8) External circuit conductors must not pass direct into the
main flameproof enclosure, and the connections must be made
either by means of a terminal box completed by an additional
cable sealing box or by a cable connector supplied as a component
flameproof in itself.
(9) Plug components of cable connectors must be interlocked
with associated controls to prevent the cable plugs being used to
make or break load current. Electrical interlocking is essential
to prevent the cable plugs being left live when withdrawn from
their sockets.
(10) The choice of material, as between castings and welded
steel plates, rests to a great extent with the form of the individual
enclosure and with strength of structure in relation to size and
weight. As to strength of structure generally, it is required
that the makers' declaration for designed strength shall carry a
margin of 50 per cent. over the explosion pressure developed in
the routine test for flameproof enclosure.
With regard to (1), there is at present no general B.S.S. for
flameproof structures, but such a specification is in course of
preparation. Several specifications for individual classes of
apparatus are available as, for example, B.S.S. 741-1937 for
coal-cutter and conveyor motors.
Under (4), the reduced gap dimension of 0006" for oil-immersed
gear is necessitated by the fact that the internal explosive
atmosphere will comprise the gas "cracked" from the oil by
arcing at contacts, and flame from this gas is much more difficult
to control.
With regard to (5), the acceptance of a venting device in special
circumstances may be taken as applying in particular to motor
enclosures which may require some form of "breather" to meet
difficulties which, without such a device, would arise by reason
of breathing through the bearings. Such a "breather" can be
fairly simple in construction and it can be fitted so that maintenance
need not be a difficult matter.
Ancillary to the precautions against shock under (7), the
necessity for the isolation of apparatus to prevent open sparking
must not be overlooked and attention may be directed to Mines
Department Circular No. 92.
With regard to (8), care should be taken to ensure that adequate
fixings are used for the cable sealing boxes, and the associated
cable clamps in relation to the overhang and weight of the boxes
plus the cables. Guidance on the design of cable sealing boxes
and glands is to be found in B.S.S. 542, and it remains only to
emphasise the necessity for filling the boxes with sealing compound
as required under General Regulation 129 (f).
Another point which comes under both (8) and (9) is that the
use of free cable plugs implies or may imply that the associated
apparatus is to be served by flexible cable, and approval of such
a cable connection is conditional upon the qualification "where
flexible cable is permissible." A further incidental point is that
the use of plain unscreened trailing cables is unlikely to be tolerated
indefinitely, and it is interesting to be able to record the increasing
use of flexible cables provided with an earthed metallic internal
screen with a corresponding action on the part of manufacturers
in respect of providing clamping arrangements to suit such cables.
Details of screened trailing cables are included in B.S.S. 708 and
this note can conclude with a caveat as to the necessity for adequate
provision for clamping the screen and for excluding moisture from
the point where the screen leaves the rubber sheathing.
Under (10), it is difficult to draw a dividing line between cast
structures and fabricated (welded) structures. Castings introduce
rigidity which may he a decided advantage in many instances,
but it is not always easy to control uniform thickness in repetition
production and castings are susceptible to damage which may
impair the flameproof design. On the other hand, with fabricated
structures reliance has to be placed on individual weldings, and
for steel plate covers of comparatively large area it is often difficult
to choose between thickness for rigidity and a large number of
fixing bolts to ensure adequacy in respect of the flameproof joint
to the casing. Fixing bolts, studs and screws should be up to
the standard set by B.S.S. 190 and B.S.S. 191, and they should
preferably be rust-proofed by sherardising or an equivalent
process.
Maintenance.
The criterion for adequate maintenance of flameproof electrical
apparatus is knowledge of the means by which open sparking is
prevented, and attention is again directed to Mines Department
Circular No. 92, the second part of which stresses the necessity
for the electrician and any of his assistants, who are entrusted
with the duty of supervising, examining or adjusting the electrical
apparatus, to know how to maintain the apparatus in a flameproof
condition at all times.
Attention may be directed also to Mines Department Circular
No. 100 which deals with a contributory defect in a coal-cutting
machine to which an explosion was due, and gives suggestions
for the discovery and prevention of similar defects. The particular
issue is that of ensuring metal-to-metal contact at a cover
joint when one or more sides of the cover are not accessible for
visual examination or for checking the cover joint by feeler gauge.
Another important issue arises in connection with the care of
trailing cables associated with coal face machinery, with particular
reference to the distortion that is described as "corkscrewing."
H.M. Electrical Inspector's Reports for 1935 and 1936 indicate
the dangers which arise from such distortion.
Numerous maintenance points can be detailed but in the main
they are points which can be adequately covered by commonsense
and understanding. Certified flameproof enclosures are now
available for all classes of mining electrical apparatus for which
flameproofness is necessary, and the stage has been reached at
which "adequate provision" depends on the correct use of that
material. It should be an obvious absurdity to install certified
equipment and then to leave it to stand by itself in opposition
to both natural and unnatural forces.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Rainford, H. | | Testing Officer | |