|
18th February 1938, Page: 327, Column: 2 Law IntelligenceMines (Working Facilities and Support): Wayleave RentOn January 19 the Railway and Canal Commission Court delivered judgment in the action of Consett Iron Co., Ltd., v. Clavering Estates (Durham), Ltd., and Others. This was an application by the company, the owners of the Chopwell and Garesfield Collieries, in the counties of Durham and Northumberland, for the right of wayleave for a period of 99 years from January 1, 1937, at a fixed annual rent of £10 an acre, over certain strips of land between Garesfield Colliery and Derwenthaugh in the possession of the defendants, Mr. William Waymouth Gibson, Mr. Noel Warren Napier Clavering, and the Clavering Estates (Durham), Ltd., as trustees of the will of the late Sir William Clavering. The applicants had previously had a tonnage wayleave over the land in question under a lease dated August 15, 1890, which expired on December 31, 1931, but in the terms of which the applicants continued in possession from year to year until December 31, 1936, when they determined the lease and made the present application under the Mines (Working Facilities and Support) Act, 1923. In their application they stated, inter alia, that during the period of 47 years or thereabouts during which the applicants enjoyed the right to use the railway, they paid for the right to use the Clavering strips £79,869, or £6,700 for each acre used. The applicants lodged an application before the lease had expired under s. 13 (2) of the Mining Industry Act, 1926, for the grant of the right of wayleave over the Clavering strips freed from the tentale and other fixed rents. The Railway and Canal Commission granted the wayleave rights so applied for at an inclusive annual rent of £10 an acre for the land used and occupied. That grant, however, was set aside by the Court of Appeal on the ground that s. 13 (2) gave the Railway and Canal Commission no jurisdiction to vary the financial terms of existing leases. With a view to obtaining the rights required on more reasonable terms, by their failure or inability to obtain the rights required for the above reasons the proper and efficient working of their minerals and the carriage of such minerals were unduly hampered. The applicants claimed that it was in the national interest that they should enjoy the rights applied for. In their answer and objections to the application the respondents denied that the rents and conditions subject to which the applicants had enjoyed their wayleave had at any time in the past been unreasonable, or that the same would be unreasonable now or at any time in the future. It was not a matter of national interest that the application should be granted. Mr. Justice Finlay, in the course of his judgment, said in the former case the Court of Appeal were not unanimous. Lord Justice Slesser and Lord Justice Roche took one view, and Lord Justice Greer dissented. The ground on which the majority decided was that the word "impeding" in the section had reference to physical impeding only and did not apply to financial terms and conditions. After recapitulating the circumstances and the correspondence between the parties, his lordship said it was not contended that there was a holding over on the terms of the lease. This being so, it seemed to be of little importance whether the true view was that there was a tenancy on sufferance (as it was called, perhaps not very accurately), or a tenancy at will, if it were necessary to express an opinion about that, he should have thought that it was a tenancy at will, because the essence of a tenancy on sufferance was that there was no consent of the landlord to the position created. It was important to notice that the present application was under a statute different from that which was before the court earlier. The former application was under s. 13 of the Mining Industry Act, 1926, and it was on the construction of s.s. (2) of that section that the Court of Appeal held that this court had no jurisdiction in the circumstances of the case. The present application was made under the Mines (Working Facilities and Support) Act, 1923. He adopted the view of the facts which was taken by Mr. Justice MacKinnon and by the Commissioners who were now sitting with him, and he was satisfied that there had been no material change in the facts since those judgments were delivered. The only fact which appeared to have altered to any extent was this. At the time when the judgments were delivered the period of depression had certainly not come to an end. Happily, since those judgments were delivered there had been a marked improvement in the coal industry generally and in the position of the Consett Iron Co. particularly. But he was satisfied that there was nothing in that fortunate circumstance which affected the validity of the findings which were arrived at. After reading extensive extracts from Mr. Justice MacKinnon's judgment, his lordship said it must be hampering to any business of this sort to have no security of tenure. It seemed to be obvious that the applicants, carrying on this business of getting coal, must be in a position not merely to take their coal away to-day, but to know that they would be able to take it away to-morrow. It must be hampering to them if they were in a position that they could not, except on unreasonable terms, obtain that security of tenure which was essential. There was direct evidence to support that view. As to national interest, one might look at it from more than one point of view. One point of view is that it is important in the national interest that a number of people should get employment at proper wages, and therefore that it must be considered in the national interest — not merely in the interests of individuals, but in the general interest — that reasonable facilities for sending away the coal should exist. There was some discussion with regard to the Lands Clauses Acts, and attention had been called to one or two cases under those Acts. He doubted whether there was any real analogy at all to be drawn between the sum to be paid by way of compensation for a mineral wayleave and the sum to be paid on the compulsory purchase of land under the Lands Clauses Acts. The problem was solved by looking at the actual section under which they were proceeding, and applying it. The conclusion at which Sir Walter Monckton asked them to arrive could not, in his opinion, be right. Put shortly, that conclusion was that in arriving at value the basis of calculation must be the rent or annual payments which have been paid. Those were the very things which had been held to be wrong and unreasonable. It seemed to him at once apparent that that conclusion could not possibly be right. If applied to its full extent it would really involve that one was to stereotype and fix for ever as a basis the basis which we have held to be wrong and unreasonable. His conclusion therefore was that this application succeeded, and that the applicants were entitled to the order for which they asked. Sir Francis Taylor said he agreed. The precarious user which the applicants now had was not, in his view, a right within the meaning of s. 3. As they had not the right to pass over the respondents' land to carry away the output of their collieries he thought that they required such a right for that purpose and for the proper and convenient working of the minerals. Also, in his opinion, the proper and efficient working of the minerals was unduly hampered by their failure to obtain the right. It does not appear to be a sufficient answer to this application that the applicants could obtain the right by complying with the terms demanded. Nor was it a sufficient answer that they were at present parsing over these lands and carrying away their output at will, or on sufferance. The evidence of Mr. George satisfied him that without the right the position of the applicants was uncertain and insecure. The business of these collieries could not be conducted on such a basis. Colliery owners must have certainty that they can execute contracts and that they can carry away the coal continuously and on reasonable terms over a period of years. It was in the power of the respondents to stop the transit at any moment. Such a proceeding might be improbable. These lands or strips of land, however, might be sold to purchasers with different, views. If, on the facts of this case, the conclusion that a proper and efficient working of the minerals was unduly hampered by failure or inability to obtain the right is erroneous, it would seem that, on the one hand, the grantee of a way-leave could not be relieved from oppressive terms, and, on the other, that a user on sufferance must submit to exaction if he desired to obtain a right, unless and until the exaction became so onerous that working at a profit became impossible. The respondents had, in his opinion, made an unreasonable demand. It had to be shown to be expedient in the national interest that the mineral resources of the country should be utilised. They could not be utilised unless they could be properly and conveniently worked, which included carrying them away not on sufferance but by right. National interest must in this case, by the provisions of s. 6, be considered in relation to the right required. Lord Justice Roche's observations on the question of national interest on the hearing of the appeal on the first application were directed to the consideration of national interest in relation to the modification of financial terms of an existing lease. He did not think that they implicitly conflicted with the view that the right required was expedient in the national interest. National interest was also properly to be regarded in relation to the employment of large numbers of workers. It was not expedient in the national interest that the working of coal should be burdened by anv oppressive exactions. Such exactions fell on individuals, but they concerned the nation and were not expedient in the working of the national coal resources. The only evidence they had about value, and what was fair and reasonable, was the agricultural value. It was said that they should have regard to the rent paid in past years. It would seem illogical to have regard to that which they had decided to be unreasonable as an element or basis in arriving at what was fair and reasonable. They had no evidence of conditions or terms of mining leases in the district. Sir Francis Dunnell expressed entire agreement with the above judgments.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||