|
16th February 1938, Page: 9, Column: 3 No Switch To Stop Runaway TubsComments By Coroner At Ryhope InquestStatements that a switch intended to stop runaway tubs was only a short length of rail kept in position by an ordinary nail, was "no use at all," and had been missing for several weeks, were made at an inquest conducted by Coroner T. V. Devey at Ryhope Police Station last night on Edward Clark (16), of 14 Arthur Avenue, Ryhope Village, who was killed by a runaway tub in the Busty seam at Ryhope Colliery last Wednesday. The Jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death." David Hays, of 65 Railway Street, Ryhope, said he was employed as a haulage lad in the Busty seam. On Wednesday morning Alan Graham, a wagonwayman, Edward Clark, who was employed as a landing lad, and he were in the telephone hole at the Busty Drift bottom. Graham telephoned for the set of empty tubs to be brought in to the spare mark. They then left the telephone hole, and Clark went in the direction of the set to rap it in from the spare mark by means of a bell push. Hays, then heard Graham shout "Get out or the way, the set is amain," and as he ran he heard the tub run into the landing. When the tub stopped he asked where Clark was, and Graham told him that he had been caught by the tub. Shouted Warning Evidence by Graham revealed that normally when he asked by telephone for the set to be brought in it was hauled to the spare mark and stopped, and later was brought to the landing when a signal was given by means of a bell push which was attached to a prop. On this occasion he telephoned for the set to be brought in, and Clark went in the direction of the bell push, which was at the out-bye side of the telephone hole. They had just left the telephone hole when he heard the set coming in, and as he thought it was coming rather hard he shouted a warning to the others to run for safety. Clark ran in-bye to get clear, but was caught by a tub which had become released from the set. The remainder of the set was about 30 yards on the out-bye side of the telephone hole, and two tubs were off the rails. In reply to Mr. W. B. Brown, H.M. Mines Inspector, he agreed that Clark would have to stand in the track of the oncoming set to operate the bell push. Mr. Brown: Has the set ever come amain before? — Yes, some time ago. Mr. Brown: Where is the bell push now? — In the telephone hole. Mr. Brown: Is that a better position? — Yes. In reply to another question by Mr. Brown, Graham said there used to be a runaway switch near the landing points, but it had been missing for some weeks, and in reply to Coroner Devey said that he could not say how it came to be removed and not replaced. Mr. Brown: Did the switch ever stop runaway tubs? — No. Mr. Devey: Why not? — It was a flimsy affair and was kept in position by an ordinary nail. Mr. Brown: Was it any use? — No use at all. Coroner Devey observed that if there had been a good switch in position Clark would probably have not been killed, and Mr. Brown said that when Graham knew the switch was missing it was his duty to complain. In reply to Coroner Devey, Graham admitted he did not complain that the switch was missing, and when Mr. Thomas Emmerson, workmen's inspector, asked how many days it had been missing prior to the accident he replied "Four weeks." Mr. Emmerson: There would be officials passing the spot every day. Was it not their duty to report the fact that the switch was missing? — Yes. Coroner Devey: This man has direct responsibility. The moment we attempt to deprive men of responsibility we shall have more accidents. "A Strange Thing" Mr. Emmerson replied that Graham's job was to get coals away. He was not sufficiently experienced to be a wagonwayman, and he (Mr. Emmerson) believed that responsibility for the missing switch lay somewhere else. Mr. Brown observed that Graham was not receiving wagonwayman's wages. When Graham, in reply to Coroner Devey, said he did not know how the tub got away. Mr. Emmerson stated that some of the tubs on the set were off the rails and this might have caused a coupling bolt to be removed from its position, thus releasing the tub. He thought that if an adequate switch had been in position Clark's life might have been saved. In his summing-up Coroner Devey said it seemed a strange thing that no one seemed to bother when the runaway switch was taken away. Mr. Emmerson had suggested that the responsibility for reporting the fact rested on some higher official, but in his opinion the duty rested on Graham, as he was the man on the spot.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||