11th February 1938, Page: 278, Column: 1
The Coal Bill
During the last week many additional opinions on the alleged weaknesses of the
Coal Bill have been expressed. Most of them relate to the selling schemes and
appear to have been answered by the assurances which Mr. O. Stanley was
able to give in the House of Commons on Monday.
In the Times on Monday a letter from Sir Arthur Salter was
published in which, referring to amalgamations, he maintained that not only
would Select Committee procedure bring each scheme back into political
controversy; but with this addition the compulsory provisions would again be
unworkable, as they had been during all the seven years period of the
Reorganisation Commission's existence. The gravity of this position could only
be realised by looking at the general structure of the coal legislation and its
previous history. The 1930 Bill already included the two essential and
complementary principles. The State was by legislation to help the industry as
to prices; in return there was to be provision to secure efficiency, in the
last resort by compulsion. The first was immediately operative and is being
continued. The second was made completely inoperative in the 1930 Act by the
Lords' amendments — and is apparently to remain inoperative.
In 1936, he continued, the Reorganisation Commission reported that voluntary
amalgamations had made an insignificant contribution to the problem of
resistant minorities, which remained urgent; and that its powers had not
enabled, and would not enable, it to discharge its functions. The Government
then introduced a Bill calculated to make the scheme workable — in
particular, omitting the reference to the Railway and Canal Commission. Under
pressure from the Mining Association the Government withdrew the Bill and
promised concessions, among others the postponement of the date of operation
till July, 1938. After a year's interval a new Bill has recently been
introduced, including even further concessions beyond those promised in the
1936 surrender — the date being postponed to January, 1940 (10 years
after the introduction of the price system), and the Railway and Canal
Commission being brought back into the procedure. Under these provisions it
would have been almost, though not quite, as impossible for schemes to have
been pushed through to a conclusion as under the 1930 Act. Even this, however,
was not enough; under further pressure a new stage is now to be added which
will, in Sir Arthur's view, mean that the new Coal Commission will, in
respect of this part of its functions, be reduced to almost as complete
futility as the Reorganisation Commission has been throughout its existence.
We are, he pointed out, by successive Acts, with regard to agriculture,
electricity, and other industries, building up a completely new economic system
in this country. The State gives special assistance to private enterprise and
attempts to give corresponding protection to the public. Personally, he would
prefer such a system to a complete State Socialism which would exclude private
enterprise from all our great industries — if it could be justly devised
and enforced. It is, however, an essential condition that the Government should
govern — and that the State which is thus associated with private
enterprise should be the servant of the public as a whole (with the industry
occupying its due place as a part of the public but no more), and not the
servant of organised sectional interests. In case after case it is not being so
applied. The workers' interests are ignored; the public safeguards are made
nugatory. The State is captured by sectional interests and made their
instrument.
If Governments cannot govern, he continues, a mixed system of State assistance
and supervision — the alternative to the replacement of private
enterprise by State Socialism — becomes indefensible. This new concession
has therefore struck a heavy blow at private enterprise itself. There are very
many who, if forced to choose between an obviously unjust semi-State system
imposed by a State which has been captured by sectional interests, and a more
complete State system, from which private enterprise has been eliminated,
would, reluctantly but without hesitation, choose the latter.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Salter, Arthur, Sir | | | |
| Stanley, O. | | M.P. | |