|
4th February 1938, Page: 233, Column: 2 Notes from the Coal FieldsYorkshire[Local correspondence.] The question of the price of coal supplied to fishing trawlers at Hull was raised at Sheffield last Friday, when the Midland (Amalgamated) District Committee of Investigation inquired into a complaint made by Hull Fishing Vessel Owners' Association, Ltd., against the Executive Board of the Midland (Amalgamated) District (Coal Mines) Scheme, 1930. It was the first public inquiry to be held by the committee, who have hitherto heard complaints in private. The tribunal consisted of Mr. W. B. Woodhouse (chairman), Mr. Herbert Smith, and Capt. P. C. Cooper-Parry. Mr. Norman Harper appeared for the complainants, and Mr. Jacques Abady, K.C., and Mr. Geoffrey Veale for the executive board, the respondents. Mr. Harper said the complaint was that the price charged for bunker coal was unfair, inequitable, and contrary to the public interests. The particular contracts in regard to which complaint was made were two, and they related to Hellyer Bros., Ltd., and to Pickering and Haldane's Steam Trawling Co., Ltd., both members of the Hull Fishing Vessel Owners' Association. The actual prices complained of related to contracts for the year 1938. The quantities of coal in question were, in the case of Hellyer Bros., 115,000 tons of washed steams and 9,000 tons of hards, and in the case of Pickering and Haldane, 70,000 tons of washed steams. The price of washed steams last year was 17s. 4d. per ton for the first nine months and 17s. 6d. for the last three months, and the proposed price was 21s. 6d. In the case of hards, last year's price was 19s. 1d. and 19s. 3d., and the suggested price was 22s. For many years the two companies had dealt with the Frickley Colliery and had never questioned the prices. That did not mean, however, that prices paid in the past were necessarily proper prices. The Hull fishing industry was a very good customer of the South Yorkshire district. The two firms shipped between them over 400,000 tons in 1921 ; by 1928 the quantity had risen to 589,000 tons ; and it had risen steadily since with one setback until in 1937 over 800,000 tons were taken from the South Yorkshire district. Mr. Harper, after pointing out that prices had steadily risen in the last few years, said that if Hellyer Bros, had to pay 21s. 6d. for washed steams they would have to pay £24,237 more than they paid last year, while Pickering and Haldane would have to pay an increase of £14,000. The position of the trawling industry in Hull, as a whole, good customer as it was to the Midland regional coal field, was that at the present time on the basis of the 1937 prices it could not for the main part pay those prices and make a profit. It might mean the laying up of some trawlers and custom to the coal trade reduced. The whole industry was already failing to pay a profit on 1937 prices. They knew wages had risen, and were still rising, but they did not know they were going to rise sufficiently to justify the increase of 22 per cent. What they desired to do, continued Mr. Harper, if the Executive Board was agreeable, was to decide what price should be paid for six months. When that time was about to expire they would come again and both sides produce evidence and show how that coal price had worked, whether in favour of the board or in favour of the consumer. They undertook to produce a balance sheet covering the whole of the fishing industry and show this complaint was a fact and not bluff. Mr. Owen S. Hellyer, governing director of Hellyer Bros., said the association had members who were owners of 265 trawlers operating from Hull. The industry was not in a position to bear the proposed increased cost of coal. Cross-examined by Mr. Abady, witness said the coal owners and the miners had a right to a fair reward, but if the price as the result of such reward was that the consumer was unable to pay it, it became an unfair price in that particular instance. The trawling industry was not normal, but definitely subnormal and losing money. If there had been no board he ventured to say that the colliery from which they bought coal would, in the wisdom of not wanting to lose their custom and putting the industry out of action, have given them special considerations. In answer to the chairman. Mr. Hellyer said they expected special consideration in 1938 in the belief that in 1939 they would have established the industry in a stronger position that at present. The hearing was adjourned until the next day, when it was further adjourned, after evidence had been taken in private. No date was fixed for the resumption of the inquiry. The case for the complainants had not been completed, and it is understood that the hearing was adjourned so that they could furnish more evidence. Speaking at the ordinary general meeting of Benzol and By-Products, Ltd., in London on January 28, Sir A. Henry McMahon, G.C.M.G., G.G.V.O., chairman of the company, said that under the Midland (Amalgamated) District Coal Mines Scheme, 1930, as amended by the district scheme approved under the provisions of Part I of the Coal Mines Act, 1930, the annual output standard tonnage of all the non-special mines in any section as then determined were referred for revision to an independent arbitrator appointed in accordance with the scheme. Their company's colliery was grouped in the West Yorkshire area. The arbitrator had the task of awarding the revised output standard tonnage to each of the special mines in the section, and in so doing was under obligation to have regard to the special circumstances of every such mine. The annual output standard tonnage of the section remitted to the arbitrator for division was 18,952,048 tons, being a reduction of 150,000 tons from the standard tonnage available to the section when the Standard Tonnage Committee made their revision, which was operative as from May 1, 1937. The annual output standard tonnage of their mine as at May 1, 1937, was 275,787 tons. It was the duty of the arbitrator in awarding the revised output standard tonnage to have in mind the special circumstances of any coal mine, the extent to which it had been developed or was being developed for economical working and the extent to which its output had been increasing or decreasing. It would be understood that one of the important considerations in working a coal mine was the distribution of the working costs, and the larger the available output standard tonnage of a mine economically and efficiently worked in the absence of abnormal conditions of working enabled an undertaking to distribute its overheads and so, assuming facilities for transport and removal of the coal to be sufficient, a colliery with the largest standard output consistent with its powers of winding coal was in a more favourable position than its competitors who were restricted in their output. The whole of the standard tonnage of the West Yorkshire group was in the melting pot. Their board were informed of active steps taken by other undertakings in the district to maintain or increase their output standard tonnages, and, having regard to the reduction of quota available for the district, all collieries were at hazard that their permitted tonnages might be reduced. The board came to the conclusion that it was essential to take every reasonable step possible to protect the company in the arbitration proceedings. As a consequence the company was involved at short notice in substantial expenditure. Such expenditure, where a colliery was a member of a group under existing schemes, was practically compulsory if the colliery wished to maintain its position in the group. With competing and conflicting claims to tonnage this position would be readily understood and the more so as under the selling scheme, conditions in the industry had improved and there was a greater demand for coal which each undertaking was anxious to share in by obtaining from the arbitrator an award of further standard tonnage. The board decided that the company should be represented at the arbitration by leading and junior counsel and to call in the services of Mr. Edward Otto Forster Brown, the company's consulting mining engineer, in order that the company's position should be properly placed before the arbitrator. At the hearing, although 24 out of the 51 undertakings appearing before the arbitrator had their standard tonnages decreased, not only was their company's annual standard tonnage maintained, but a small addition to it was obtained. The national importance of the undertaking in connection with its output of by-products was made clear to the arbitrator, and if the company's undertaking was maintained efficiently and economically he hoped that its standard tonnage position in the future would be improved. The chairman referred next to the Government's Coal Bill, 1937, limiting his remarks to the provisions of Part I and Part II of the proposed Bill. Part I of the Bill, he said, dealt with the unification of coal mining royalties. The company's officials and expert advisers were at present engaged in getting together the necessary material to protect the company's interests in connection with mining royalties payable by the company under its leases and in connection with royalties attributable to the freehold minerals of the company. Unless the Coal Bill were amended serious difficulties might arise from severance of ownership of the minerals from that of underground land and the surface. It was hoped that practical amendments to this part of the Bill would be sympathetically considered by the Government. Part II of the Bill, if it received the sanction of Parliament in its present form, raised important and difficult problems. Their company in 1934 opposed a compulsory amalgamation scheme which was presented by the Coal Mines Reorganisation Commission to the Railway and Canal Commission for compulsory amalgamation of the collieries, including their colliery in the West Yorkshire area. The Railway and Canal Commission were not satisfied that the proposed scheme in its operation might not be injurious to some of the undertakings concerned, and they were not satisfied that in its working it would be fair and equitable to all persons affected, and so approval of the scheme was refused. Under the new Bill, the Coal Mines Reorganisation Commission was to be abolished. Its place was to be taken by the Coal Commission to whom all its powers under Part II of the Act of 1930 were to be transferred. Persons directly connected with the coal mining industry would not be eligible for appointment to the Commission — in other words, as he understood it, the reorganisation of the coal fields of Great Britain was to be entrusted to a body perhaps without practical experience of the business in hand. One of the functions of this body, if the Bill passed into law as it stood, would be to consider whether in any area, including the West Yorkshire area, the number of coal mining undertakings was so great as to be detrimental to the economical and efficient working, treating and disposal of coal. If in the case of any area they came to that conclusion, then it would be their duty to endeavour to effect a reduction of the number of such undertakings. The powers of review of the Railway and Canal Commission would be substantially narrowed if the Coal Bill passed through in its present form. Their board were not opposed to amalgamation in principle. They took the view that in each individual case the question whether amalgamation would be beneficial or not must be judged entirely on the particular circumstances of the case. They regarded opposition to amalgamations in principle as unreasonable, but a belief in the efficacy of amalgamations as an end in itself appeared to them to be untenable. The board believed that Part II of the Bill, as drafted, would act prejudicially to the industry, and particularly as no undertaking would be certain as to when an amalgamation scheme would be proposed and what would be the result of that amalgamation scheme. The problematical consequences of compulsory amalgamations made it difficult to decide as to expenditure of capital in development and expenditure to procure more efficient and economical working of mines — one of the main objects for which the 1930 Act was passed. Whatever the objections might be to the selling schemes, they were adopted by colliery undertakings, including their undertaking, at the request, of the Secretary for Mines, in the hope that the result of them would be to bring peace and goodwill into the industry, and, while considering the question of amalgamations and efficiency, it had to be borne in mind that the efficiency and economical working of an undertaking were considered (as they had all been recently considered by those who were responsible for fixing the standard tonnage of mines) and the inefficient mines were properly restricted in their output. This should lead economically to the result which the Bill desired to effect by compulsory amalgamations, namely, the closing down of the weaker undertakings. The board considered that the Bill would cause widespread unrest, difficulty and expense. A resolution of protest against Part II of the Coal Mines Bill, which refers to compulsory amalgamation, was passed unanimously at the annual meeting of the Sheffield and District Coal Merchants' Association. The president, Mr. J. C. Wood, referred to the committee's activities during the year, particularly with regard to the changes brought about by the central selling schemes. He also informed the members of the position regarding the new rates assessments on the depots, casual labour, registration, and other matters. Speaking to members of Huddersfield Rotary Club on Monday, January 24, Mr. T. C. S. Lodge, Northern Area Organiser of the Coal Utilisation Council, stressed the national importance of the coal industry and the vital part it was playing and would increasingly play in relation to the country's rearmament programme. At the same time, Mr. Lodge added that in connection with the production of oil from coal, too much must not be expected too soon. The speaker emphasised the desirability of publicising the merits and advantages of solid fuel from a health, from an economy, and from a national point of view. Mr. A. Hayes, agent to J. and G. Wells, Ltd., Eckington Collieries, presiding at the annual tea and distribution of the St. John Ambulance Brigade awards and air-raid precautions certificates, illustrated the value of first aid by an incident which occurred during a roof fall in one of the company's collieries. He said that one man who was buried for four hours had first aid knowledge which enabled him to assist himself while being extricated and treated. Mr. H. Kendall (manager) appealed to all the miners to take a personal interest in first aid and air raid precautions work. In the air raid precautions three officers and 14 members gained certificates.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||