28th January 1938, Page: 188, Column: 1
Notes from the Coal Fields
Cumberland
[Local Correspondence.]
The Railway and Canal Commission, sitting in the High Court on Monday, January
24, and consisting of Mr. Justice Finlay, Sir Francis Taylor,
K.C., and Sir Francis Bunnell, granted the application by the Beckermet
Mining Co., Ltd., of Beckermet, Cumberland, for the right to work 1,200 acres
of land for iron ore at Beckermet. The area is situated between Whitehaven and
Workington. There are a number of objectors to the application, chiefly on the
ground that surface owners should be given adequate compensation for the
"letting down" of the surface of their land by the mining company.
Mr. W. Brindle Wood, an objector, who appeared in person, said he was
the owner of Sheepfields Farm, which came within the area the company desired
to work. There was iron ore under the farm. Two years ago he endeavoured to
sell the farm, but, on account of the threat of mining operations, was unable
to do so. He maintained that the compensation should be double the agricultural
value of the land. The ore under the farm was at a depth of 1,400 ft., and if
it were mined there would be a danger of subsidence. Giving the decision of the
Commission, Mr. Justice Finlay said that the Commission had come to the
conclusion that it was expedient in the national interest that the ore should
be worked, and, further, the Beckermet Mining Co. were the only people likely
to undertake the work. That really decided the main point before the
Commission. With regard to compensation for damages and boreholes, a sum to be
awarded in respect of this was suggested by the company, and the Commission
desired to say that no reason was apparent why that sum was not a reasonable
one. It was also argued, with regard to the surface owners, continued his
lordship, that they should receive compensation, as was usually the case, when
damage was done by the letting down of land. It was also said they should
receive compensation in respect of what might be called "the apprehension
that their land may be let down." Never in the history of the Commission
had an award of compensation on that principle been approved, and the
difficulties which would arise, if it was, were obvious. It was agreed that in
some parts of the land there was practically no ore. There was no legal right
to claim for damage unless and until damage arose, and the Commission could not
give effect to the suggestion that compensation ought to be allowed before the
damage had been done. It was sufficient to say that this was a completely novel
claim, and could not be sustained. The company's application was granted.
A series of lectures was given in West Cumberland last week by Mr. H. Henshaw,
Sheffield, from the Safety in Mines Research Department. On
Tuesday he lectured at Whitehaven, on Wednesday at Lowca, on Thursday at Flimby
and on Saturday at Workington. The main purpose was to describe the results of
certain roof control investigations carried out by the Safety in Mines Research
Board investigators with the object of reducing the number of accidents from
falls of ground, and promoting safer working conditions.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bunnell, Francis, Sir | | Commissioner | |
| Finlay, Justice | | Commissioner | |
| Henshaw, H. | | S.M.R.B. | |
| Taylor, Francis, Sir | | Commissioner | |
| Wood, W. Brindle | | | |