28th January 1938, Page: 184, Column: 1
Law Intelligence
Workmen's Compensation — Medical Reference — "Exceptional Difficulty" Considered
In Hamilton Sheriff Court, Sheriff Norman M. L. Walker recently granted
an application made by John Watson, Ltd., owners of Earnock Colliery, near
Hamilton, to refer to a medical referee under s.s. (2) and (4) of s. 19 of the
Workmen's Compensation Act, 1925, certain medical questions in dispute between
them and Isaac Brownrigg, who was formerly a brusher in their
employment. The workman had his back injured in the colliery on June 8, 1931,
and was paid compensation under the Act. In November 1931 a medical referee
reported that the claimant was unfit for work and stated that there was
"lipping" of certain vertebrae, but that there was no sign of
fracture or collapse. He certified that, there was osteoarthritis which was
probably old and had been aggravated by the accident. On October 16 last the
employers served on the workman a copy of a report by a medical practitioner
who examined on their behalf, certifying that about 40 per cent. of the
disablement was due to disuse and the absence of effective effort, and on this
being disputed they made their application under s. 19 (4) and asked that the
question be remitted to the medical referee for decision. The workman objected
on the ground that the matter was one of exceptional difficulty and was most
suitable for determination by arbitration. The sheriff clerk (registrar), who
dealt with the objections in the first instance, repelled them and ordered the
reference to proceed. On an appeal by the workman, Sheriff Walker
affirmed the sheriff clerk's riding. In doing so his lordship said that the
minute for the employers, supplemented by their medical report, showed that
their contention was that the incapacity was partly due to disuse and absence
of effective effort. His lordship understood that to imply that use and
effective effort were possible. The claimant's medical certificate bore that
the unfitness was due to the injuries. That appeared to his lordship to be a
purely medical question and the length of time since the accident and the
progressive nature of the disease did not in his opinion introduce exceptional
difficulty or provide any other sufficient reason for refusing the reference.
His lordship said that his difficulty was that he felt that there might be some
question of unreasonable conduct involved. The minute of application itself
gave the claimant no proper opportunity to raise that question, but the
employers' medical certificate did and he had not raised it.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Brownrigg, Isaac | | Brusher | |
| Walker, Norman M. L. | | Sheriff | |