28th January 1938, Page: 184, Column: 1
Law Intelligence
Dermatitis Claim
The Court of Appeal (Master of the Rolls and Lords Justices Romer and
Mackinnon) on November 11 allowed the appeal of Rex Burgin, from
the award of Deputy Judge Bramley, at Rotherham County Court,
terminating the workmen's compensation payable to him by his employers,
Earl FitzWilliam's Collieries Co., New Stubbin Colliery, Rawmarsh.
Burgin, it was stated, contracted dermatitis produced by dust or liquid
in September 1934, and was paid compensation. But, on the employer's request
for a review in July last, it was held that Burgin was no longer
suffering from that industrial disease. The Master of the Rolls said that the
judge accepted a specialist's evidence, and treated it as being established
that Burgin no longer had the disease. That evidence was vitiated by the
fact that it was in contradiction to the medical referee's certificate.
Therefore there was before the county court judge no evidence on which he could
reach his finding. The appeal was allowed with costs, the award was set aside,
and a formal award was made for an agreed rate of compensation to be paid to
Burgin.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bramley, — | | Deputy Judge | |
| Burgin, Rex | | Miner | |
| FitzWilliam, Earl | | Mine Owner | |
| Mackinnon, —, Lord | | Justice | |
| Romer, —, Lord | | Justice | |