|
15th January 1938, Page: 218, Column: 1 Boys And Youths In MinesNeed for Training and SupervisionThese notes are based on the Mines Inspectors' Reports for 1936. The price of each Report is 1s. net. Copies are obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office. Inspector Disappointed with Results. A comparison of reportable accidents to boys (under 16) and youths (16-17 years) in Scotland in the last three years of working (1934-36) is regarded by Mr. E. H. Frazer, the Divisional Inspector, as disappointing after so much has been done to train boys in safer methods of working. He hopes they are at the turning point and that future years will justify, by accident reduction, all the thought and labour that have been expended. Figures that have been examined lend some colour to the view that youthful inexperience is a root cause of accidents. The details seem to show that by the time a young person has reached the age of 18 he is beginning to exercise more fully the faculty of watchfulness, which is so essential in mining work, and is becoming familiar with the dangers which beset him from the movement of tubs — the most common source of accidents to beginners. Emphasising the need for inexperience to be neutralised as far as practicable by training and supervision, Mr. Frazer says these are not always given, and he gives an account of an Ayrshire accident as evidence, thus :— A boy of nearly 15, who had worked 11 months in the screens at the picking tables, was set to attend to two tipplers on the pit bank. He had to control the flow of empty tubs from the tipplers but, within three hours of starting, he was caught between tubs and sustained a broken arm. He should have taken his position at the side of the tubs, not between the rails. The surface foreman admitted that the boy had been given no instructions and warned of no dangers because he thought he would be thoroughly conversant with the work through watching other boys. Accident Rates in Northern Division. So far as accidents to boys are concerned, in the ten-year period ended 1936 the rate per thousand in the Northern Division has varied from 7.20 in 1933 to 12.76 in 1928. There was a drop of 3.5 in the rate for 1936 when compared with 1935, but even so it was 7.40 compared with the general rate of 4.86 for persons of all ages in the division. Examination of the reports of the non-fatal accidents shows that all except eight of the accidents occurred in connection with underground haulage or with the handling of tubs on the surface. Ten were due to boys engaged in handling tubs being crushed by following tubs which were moving by gravity. In two cases the boys were walking backwards; in two others their hands were idly placed on stationary tubs; and in one other an attempt was being made to couple a tub before it had come to rest. Five of the accidents were caused by stumbling; four by derailments; four by runaways; and four occurred whilst riding on limbers or in tubs. The injuries comprised nineteen arm and leg fractures. Some Accidents Explained. Mr. T. Greenland Davies supplies particulars in his report of a number of accidents to boys, some of whom were safety trained. Two of the statements are quoted :— First, a safety trained shaft lad of 15 who, with the onsetter, was about to return to the shaft bottom after sending to bank all the available full tubs from an inset. When the empty tubs had been removed from the cage he approached the shaft on the side opposite the onsetter, and closed and fastened the shaft gate behind him so that he was standing in the three feet space between the gate and the edge of the shaft, ready to enter the cage when he received the onsetter's permission to do so. As he was thus waiting, the cage was suddenly and unexpectedly raised. This caused the lad to jump back so that he struck the fastened shaft gate and rebounded into the shaft. The raising of the cage was due to a confusion of signals, but, adds Mr. Davies, the practice of allowing the lad to enter the cage on the opposite side to the onsetter was wrong. The gate was also too far from the shaft. Second, a landing lad, aged 14 and the holder of a safety badge. As a full set was being hauled outbye, he was standing in front of the main rope drum of a 20 h.p. double-drum hauler to coil the incoming main rope, which was a few inches above floor level. He used an iron bar which he inserted into holes drilled in a wood block in the floor. He was pulled feet first on to the drum and part way round and died of his injuries some hours later. He stated that his trousers had been caught by the rope. The lower part of a post and rail fence between where the lad had been standing and the drums had apparently been broken some little time previously, but this had not been reported, a matter which formed the subject of legal proceedings by the company against the official responsible. There was no need for the lad to assist the coiling of this rope and he had not been instructed by any official to do so. The practice must, however, the Inspector says, have been within the knowledge of some of the officials. In the case of a hauler properly installed, the rope should coil on the drum without attention, except perhaps where sockets are wound on the drum. Where the rope or ropes will not coil without attention, there is a device which enables the engineman to perform the operation from a place of safety near his controls. There should be no need, the Inspector concludes, to stress the importance of secure fencing of haulage drums; such fencing is a statutory requirement. Ideal of Safety Training. The safety training movement continues to make progress and Mr. Davies gives a table comparing the work and results for three years. Recording his appreciation of the efforts of all interested parties, he says the main difficulty encountered is failure on the part of some of the boys employed to take advantage of the facilities afforded them. Interest can, however, be stimulated, and he appeals to all who have influence with any boy employed at a colliery, and particularly to representatives of the workmen, to exert that influence and so support a movement which has as its object the preservation of the safety not only of boys, but of all colliery workers. The ideal of safety training of boys will not be attained until every boy is trained in safety principles either before or immediately after commencing work at a colliery. It will be realised, he proceeds to say, that the object of the safety classes is not only to assist in the prevention of accidents to boys at the beginning of their working lives but to inculcate knowledge which will be of lasting benefit. A point which cannot be too strongly emphasised is that the safety classes must only be regarded as an introduction to, and not as a substitute for, the supervision and training of boys at the pits. Haulage Accidents Predominate. The Yorkshire figures relating to accidents to young boys, in the view of Mr. H. J. Humphrys, are too high and merit the anxious consideration of all in charge of the work and education of these young people. He says that underground haulage accidents predominate, and rather more than half the injured boys were run over or crushed by tubs. During 1935 more than half the injuries were to hands, whilst about one-seventh were to the leg and rather less to the arm. More than half the accidents disabled for a period of from two to six weeks, whilst the accidents disabling for less than two weeks were a little under one-third of the total. Attitude of Management Important. The attitude of Mr. Humphrys towards the Yorkshire scheme of instruction and the mines safety badge is very sympathetic. The value of the scheme is beyond question, but to obtain full value it must only be regarded as an adjunct to careful training and systematic oversight of the boys at the collieries, and he urges all managements to work out definite systems of training suited to their own particular needs. Too often, he says, it is left to subordinate officials to draft boys from one occupation to another. At one Yorkshire colliery all boys commencing work are trained under an experienced ex-deputy in a small quiet district and not passed on until he is satisfied as to the boys' competency and has furnished a report on them. This is the official's sole duty. There is a growing interest in the organised classes for boys in many areas of the Cardiff and Forest of Dean Division, and in his comment on this Mr. J. MacLeod Carey says much depends upon the lectures being made interesting. It is pleasing to him to note that the teachers are mainly colliery officials who willingly give up their leisure in order to instruct boys how to avoid accidents. Mr. E. Rowley of the Midland and Southern Division hopes that the enlightened outlook of some of the managements will spread throughout the coalfield. He refers to two or three of the accidents to boys in the following terms :— A boy of 14 who had worked in the mine for six weeks, was engaged in a level main and tail haulage road to open and close two separation doors for the passage of sets of tubs. On the outward journey the set was stopped short of the doors until the boy, who had to walk about 100 yards from the engine-house, opened them, returned to an airway and gave the signal to proceed. Then he went back to the doors, closed them and followed the set out to detach the tail rope. On the occasion of the accident, the engineman noticing that the tail rope had not been detached, went to look for the boy and found him some distance outbye of the doors so badly injured that he died shortly afterwards without being able to say how he had been injured. It is assumed that after signalling on the journey, he saw that one of the doors had closed, and in trying to open it without stopping the haulage, he was crushed against the door frame. The Inspector's comment is that a boy of 14 after only six weeks' work underground, should never be allowed to work except under the eye of some responsible person. Another lad of 14 who had worked underground for two months, was riding at the front end of a trolley on the man-haulage train, with his feet dangling. His right foot got caught under the trolley, and his leg was broken. Boys, in Mr. Rowley's opinion, should ride in company with men who can give them the benefit of their experience. A haulage hand aged 15 attempted to couple two moving tubs containing timber, when he slipped and fell between the buffers. This boy had not attended the safety classes held in connection with the colliery, and was disobeying instructions in attempting to couple moving tubs.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||