|
15th January 1938, Page: 214, Column: 1 Haulage Drawgear FailuresThe Safety in Mines Research Board have been investigating the question of haulage accidents underground, many of which are due to runaways. One aspect of the problem is concerned with the quality and the condition of the materials used for colliery haulage drawgear, and in this investigation over 250 samples of broken or defective gear (chains, drawbars, shackles and couplings) have been considered, the results being embodied in S.M.R.B. Paper No. 100 on "The Metallurgical Examination of Colliery Haulage Drawgear" by J. H. Andrew, R. Jeffrey, and W. A. Johnson (Price 1s. 6d. net, H.M. Stationery Office). The purpose of this Paper is to make available to colliery officials the latest findings; ropes are not dealt with. There are 51 illustrations in the Paper, and the following is a summary of the work :— It is shown that drawgear failures are associated with (1) the quality of the materials used, (2) the manner of their fabrication and (3) the circumstances of their use. The practical points emerging are :— 1. That material of standard quality only should be used. Where welding is not involved the use of mild steel containing 15 per cent. of manganese is recommended. 2. (a) That the welding in drawgear should be reduced to a minimum. By the use of shackles and pins and weldless couplings, welds can, for instance, be entirely eliminated. (b) Great care is necessary in welding to avoid welds of subnormal strength due to the inclusion of slag or voids in the scarf. (c) The side welding of links over inch in diameter is desirable; whilst not so easy as end welding it produces stronger links if correctly carried out. (d) The plane of the piling in wrought-iron gear should be correctly related to the direction of loading. (e) After any forging operations all drawgear should be annealed or normalised. 3. (a) Because of the surface hardness which develops as a result of service and which, in the case of wrought-iron, may cause brittleness, all such material should be heat-treated at frequent practicable intervals. In the case of mild steel drawgear heat-treatment on this account is not necessary. (b) To remove the effects of over-strain (deformation) both wrought-iron and mild steel drawgear should be heat-treated. (c) The best temperatures for heat-treatments are :—
and the use of correct temperatures is important. The temperature and conditions are best controlled by using special furnaces fitted with pyrometers, and in such circumstances normalising heat treatment is preferable. Apart from its good mechanical properties emphasis is placed upon the use of 1.5 per cent. manganese mild steel because after heavy over-strain it retains an unusually high resistance to impact which renders any heat treatment virtually unnecessary, whilst heat treatment over a wide range of temperature produces equally satisfactory results. These investigations generally draw attention to the necessity for material of high quality for haulage drawgear: this together with good design, would go far to eliminate many failures. Heat Treatment. In the presentation of the results of investigations the authors of Paper No. 100 observe that, whilst investigations have shown that the quality of the materials used is a matter of prime importance in service, the greatest number of material failures. having been associated with or promoted by the use of initially deficient material, the practical application of heat treatment as a remedial measure against the effect of cold work appears in a number of instances to have been detrimental rather than beneficial. It has, for instance, been sometimes found that the effect of heat treatment has produced, in mild steel and wrought-iron, regions of coarse ferrite crystals and boundary cementite (carbide of iron). Such a structure is brittle and this boundary migration is due to unsuitable methods or temperatures employed in this process. From the standpoint of tensile strength the structural condition of mild steel and wrought-iron in the work-hardened, annealed or normalised conditions is generally only reflected in less or greater ductility and this only slightly affects the yield point and breaking strength. But the notched-bar impact test, which gives a measure of impact strength, is invaluable for determining whether a material has received correct heat treatment. A material which is quite tough when submitted to uniform stress may exhibit brittleness when the stress is intensified locally by change of section or due to the presence of a hard surface or intergranular constituent. The Izod-impact test has therefore been used as a criterion in these considerations. The simplest forms of heat treatment are as follows : (a) Low temperature annealing or "annealing" This involves heating to a suitable temperature-at which the material is soaked — followed by a slow cooling. The temperatures frequently employed for this treatment are 650°C. and 700°C. for mild steel and wrought-iron respectively. (b) Normalising: This consists of heating the material to the requisite temperature, soaking and allowing it to cool in still air. A temperature of about 930°C. is suitable for both wrought-iron and mild steel. Colliery heat treatment is usually carried out in one of three ways: (i) In the blacksmith's fire; (ii) In a wood fire built around and over the material; (iii) In specially constructed furnaces heated by gas, oil, coal or coke. Ideally, material should be heated uniformly to the correct temperature, out of contact with free air or the fuel, and cooled uniformly. Clearly this condition can only be met in a specially constructed furnace, the temperature being controlled by means of pyrometers. Tests with pyrometers of the annealing temperatures obtained in a number of wood fires of the kind frequently employed at collieries for the heat treatment of chains and other gear have shown wide variations of the maximum temperature attained in different parts of the fire. These maxima varied in one case from 600° to 1,000 °C. and in several others over a range of 300°C. The general effect of such variations is to produce in the material regions which may have a deficient structure. On scientific grounds normalising is preferable to annealing, but the use of the higher temperature necessitates that it should be more carefully conducted: a special furnace to minimise scaling and to avoid burning is particularly desirable. For these reasons low-temperature annealing is more commonly practised.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||