|
31st December 1937, Page: 1256, Column: 2 Notes from the Coal FieldsNorth Wales[Local Correspondence.] Sir Thomas Artemus Jones, at Wrexham County Court, on November 23, delivered judgment in the case of Davies against the Llay Main Colliery Co. Applicant, Gilbert Davies, aged 22, who is in a mental institution, sued through his father, George Davies, as next friend. In the course of 12 months, from 1933 to 1934, he met with three accidents while employed at Llay Main Colliery, as a result of which, it was contended, he lost his reason, and consequently his wage-earning capacity. The second injury, which he received in June 1933, was regarded as the worst. He was knocked down by a journey of loaded tubs, and pushed along the ground, receiving injuries to the head, back, leg and arms. Some time after this accident he began to suffer from what were described as "night horrors," suddenly waking up and screaming to his parents that someone was at the foot of the bed. The respondent company contested the claim on the ground that Davies's incapacity was not due to the accidents, but attributable to constitutional or other causes. Doctors on their behalf declared that he was feebleminded before 1933, and denied that his present condition had been aggravated or accelerated by fright from the injuries. Evidence of eccentricity was given by the youth's fellow workmen. His honour, in his considered judgment, said he was satisfied, and found as a fact, that the case was one of "dementia precox," as had been contended by the doctors for the applicant. Dr. Thompson and Dr. Gifford had declared that the interval of time which elapsed between the date of the second accident and the manifestation of the mental disequilibrium in 1937 was too long to admit of any nexus between the two. On the other hand, Dr. Fraser, Dr. Collier and Dr. Frank Jones declared that there was no definite limitation known to science, and Dr. Frank Jones affirmed positively that the period was known to fluctuate between a few-months and a few years. Dementia precox might lie dormant in some families for generations without its existence being suspected, and emotional stress or nervous shock might bring out a latent trouble. It was not an unreasonable inference, his honour continued, to draw from the evidence that a timorous lad of 18, as he was then, caught by a journey of tubs in the way described, suffered a severe fright and nervous shock. Was this sufficient to stir the seeds of instability which were said by the respondents to be latent in his mind? Dr. Fraser, who was the youth's panel doctor, had stated that Davies was just the type that would be particularly affected by an accident of this kind. The language of the statute did not restrict its benefits to cases of physical injury, nor to cases of insanity brought about only by severe injuries to the head. The sequence of events which followed the second accident had left no reasonable doubt in his mind that the relationship of cause and effect existed here. He was satisfied, and found as a fact that the moral stress and nervous shock caused to Davies as he was being pushed along by the loaded tubs accelerated the onset of the mental disease from which he was still suffering. An award was accordingly made in favour of the applicant, with costs on scale B.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||