24th December 1937, Page: 1213, Column: 1
Notes from the Coal Fields
The Midlands
[Local Correspondence.]
The Recorder of Smethwick (Mr. A. J. Long) recently gave his reserved
judgment in an assessment appeal which was heard at the last Quarter Sessions.
Guest, Keen and Nettlefolds, Ltd., appealed against the separate assessment by
the local rating authority and the assessment committee of a garage attached to
St. George's Works, London-street, Smethwick. The grounds of the appeal were
that the rating of the garage was illegal, unfair, incorrect and excessive. It
was contended by the appellants that the premises, which were contiguous to the
factory, were not capable of separate assessment, but should be assessed as
part of the factory, and accordingly be entitled to be de-rated. For the
respondents, it was held that the garage could not be treated as one industrial
hereditament with the factory. Giving judgment for the appellants, and ordering
the valuation list to be rectified accordingly, the recorder said he had come
to the conclusion that the respondents' contention that an industrial
hereditament could never comprise a place used by the occupier for the housing
or maintenance of road vehicles or stables, was unsound. The relevant facts at
the time of the hearing of the appeal were exactly as they were at the time of
the hearing of the appellants' proposal, and in his (the recorder's) view the
reasonable and proper course in such circumstances would have been to
constitute one single hereditament. His reasons were that the property
concerned was wholly within the appellants' occupation; the freehold of the
whole of it was vested in the appellants; the whole was occupied and used by
the appellants for the purpose of the one single business organisation and,
geographically, the whole of it formed one unbroken unit. As a result, he held
that the provisions of the Rating and Valuation (Apportionment) Act, 1928, did
not preclude St. George's Works and its appurtenances and the garage from being
constituted one hereditament, and upon the particular facts established he
found that they ought to be so constituted. The recorder ordered the rating
authority to pay the costs of the appeal and, in reply to Mr. N. Carr
(for the rating authority), he said he would be prepared to state a case if
necessary.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Carr, N. | | Solicitor | |
| Long, A. J. | | Recorder of Smethwick | |