|
26th November 1937, Page: 1020, Column: 2 Law IntelligenceCoal Delivery Under contractMr. Justice Goddard, in the King's Bench Division, on November 18, reversed an arbitrator's award concerning a coal contract between Bessler Waechter Glover and Co., Ltd., and South Derwent Coal Co , Ltd., both of Newcastle, and awarded Messrs. Bessler £4,194 damages. The arbitrator had decided against Messrs. Bessler, who claimed specific performance of the contract, and delivery of 27,966 tons outstanding. Alternatively, Messrs. Bessler claimed £8,348 damages. For South Derwent Coal Co., it was contended that they were entitled to repudiate the contract on the ground that Messrs. Bessler had not taken delivery within the time stipulated in the contract. His lordship said that the arbitration arose in connection with a contract for the sale of 70,000 tons of coal, deliveries of which, it was feared, would overlap those under a previous contract. Deliveries under the earlier contract had not been expedited as was hoped. Representatives of the two companies came to what the arbitrator described as a verbal agreement, by which deliveries under the second contract should not commence until those under the former contract had finished. That agreement appeared to have been for the convenience of both parties, because Messrs. Bessler were short of storage room and South Derwent Coal Co. contemplated closing one of their pits. In December 1936, when the second contract should have expired, the coal company wrote to Messrs. Bessler that, as they had not taken delivery in accordance with the terms of the contract, they declined to deliver any coal after December 31. The arbitrator had found that, as the verbal agreement reached to postpone deliveries was not put into writing, nothing was due to Messrs. Bessler by way of damages. The judge said that, if the parties agreed to rescind or vary the original contract, it had to be evidenced by writing. If, however, what happened was a mere voluntary forbearance to insist on delivery or acceptance according to the strict terms of the contract, the original contract remained unaffected. The obligation to deliver and accept the full contract quantity still continued. He thought that what happened in the present case was a forbearance, because neither party had thoughtthe arrangement sufficiently important to put it into writing.
|
|||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||