Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

6th November 1937, Page: 138, Column: 1

Explosions In Coal Mines

French and British Comparison

The Mines Department has issued a Report by Major H. M. Hudspeth, D.S.O., M.C., on "Explosions in Mines: a Comparison between Great Britain and France" (Cmd. 5566, H.M. Stationery Office, 6d. net). It is the outcome of an investigation in the Pas-de-Calais, Nord, and Sarre et Moselle Coalfields, made with a view to determining why, in recent years, the French record in regard to explosions in coal mines is proportionately so much better than that of Great Britain. Taking the ten-year period 1925-34 the average death-rates per thousand persons employed below ground were 0.03 and 0.10 respectively. It will be seen that the French rate from explosions was less than one-third that of Great Britain. This difference was due largely to two facts (a) there were in France no explosions involving death during the four years 1931-4, and (b) the death-rate from explosions in British mines for the same period was exceptionally high.

In the 10-year period the explosion death-rates by causes per thousand persons underground in the two countries were :—

Mining Conditions.

Indicating that the mining conditions in the several coalfields in France vary widely the Report shows that most of the output — 63 per cent. in 1934 — is obtained from the Northern basin, which includes the Pas-de-Calais and Nord coalfields. These important coal deposits, and some others in France, have been subjected to such geological disturbances that the measures are generally highly inclined and very faulted — conditions unsuitable for the extensive application of coal-face machinery as practised in this country. Moreover, where the seams are steeply inclined the need for power-driven conveyors is less. On the other hand, compressed air-driven mechanical picks are extensively used in France; in 1935 some 70 per cent, of the total output was so obtained.

The general method of exploitation in France, as distinct from that in this country where the roads are usually all driven in the seam, is to drive from the shafts at different levels, often as much as 100 yards apart, straight and slightly rising main roads in the stone from which the inclined seams are entered and worked in relatively small sections. The advantages of having the main roads and in some instances the subsidiary roads in stone, where they are not subject directly to the subsidence experienced in the seam. Major Hudspeth points out, are great, as well from the standpoint of ventilation — leakage is at a minimum and a large proportion of the air entering the mine reaches the working faces — as from those of falls of ground and haulage. Moreover, the system is appropriate to working in descending stages and the adoption of ascensional ventilation, two principal legal requirements applicable to fiery mines in France the advantages of which in general cannot be disputed. Working in descending stages precludes the possibility of gas draining from lower and older into higher and existing workings, and ascensional ventilation of inclined faces — the natural direction — provides the best means of ensuring control over inflammable gas. The difficulty — and the danger — of attempting to course air downhill along coal faces has been evidenced in this country on more than one occasion.

The average thickness of the seams in the Northern coalfields of France is from 2 to 3 feet and in Moseile 5½ feet, as compared with some 4 feet in Great Britain; the average depths are 475 yards and 350 yards respectively. For the most part, the Report says, the conditions in the other districts in France are too irregular for average figures to be given.

Classification of Mines.

In France, the mines are classified by the District Inspectors from two points of view: (a) danger from firedamp, and (b) danger from coal dust. The classification may be different for independent districts in a mine.

Under (a) the classification is based generally upon the extent to which firedamp is found to occur. There are three classes Definitely fiery mines in which firedamp is regularly present; Slightly fiery mines in which the presence of firedamp has, even if only once, been established; Non-fiery mines in which the presence of firedamp has never been established.

Under (b) there is no absolute basis for classification; the whole of the factors affecting danger from, coal dust, e.g., the volatile matter content of the coal, the fineness of the dust, and the presence or otherwise of firedamp in the mine, are taken into consideration. The mines are divided into three categories : First category mines are those which appear to be the most dangerous from the standpoint of coal dust; Second category mines are intermediate in character; Third category mines are those not considered dangerous from the coal dust standpoint.

There are thus at least nine different classes of mines; a non-fiery mine may, for example, be in any of the three dust categories. Definitely fiery mines in the first dust category are the most dangerous.

The regulations affecting ventilation, the use of lamps, electricity and explosives, and the various measures to be taken against danger from gas and coal dust depend upon the classification, the requirements being the more stringent for the more dangerous mines. In a non-fiery mine, for instance, the use of safety-lamps is obligatory only if it is in the first category as regards dust. Again, air measurements need only be made at three-monthly intervals in non-fiery mines, in others monthly.

Ventilation Standards.

Ventilation is of fundamental importance from the standpoint of explosion risk, and in France, whore the inclination is 3 in 100 or more, or unless exemption is allowed by the Inspector, ascensional ventilation of roads and working faces in fiery mines is obligatory. Supplementing the references under the heading "Mining Conditions," it will be gathered from the Report that, in France, in addition to measuring the air at times and places comparable with British practice, the firedamp content of the main and the district return airways of definitely fiery mines must be ascertained daily — in slightly fiery mines weekly — by means of approved detectors which give an immediate indication of the percentage of firedamp present. These tests must be checked at least once a month by sampling and analysis. All the results must be recorded in registers.

Though, as in this country, the quantity of air per worker is not prescribed, in any working in a French mine where it is less than 106 cubic feet per minute per man, when the number of men at work is a maximum, the latter must have the special attention of the Inspector in charge of the district.

Standards. — (a) Withdrawal of workmen: A firedamp content of more than 2 per cent, in an air-current is considered to be dangerous; the parallel figure in Great Britain is 2½ per cent. or upwards.

(b) Electricity: The limiting standards of ventilation as regards firedamp for the use of electricity in France and Great Britain are 0.5 per cent. and 1¼ per cent., respectively.

(c) Return Airways: In France, no return airway from any development working must contain more than 1½ per cent, of firedamp; for all other returns 1 per cent, is the maximum allowed. There is no such requirement in this country. The 1 per cent. firedamp limit is a determining factor in development; it controls, for example, the length of coal face on any one split of air.

Whilst not in a position to make a full comparison between mines in France and Great Britain as regards either the liability to gas, or the standards of ventilation in practice as judged by the percentage of firedamp in the returns, Major Hudspeth is satisfied (a) that there are mines in France where the liability to gas is high — as high as at some of the more gassy mines in this country; and (b) that while at the large majority of the mines in Great Britain the ventilation is up to, or better than, a 1 per cent, return standard, at some (and not all of them with exceptionally high rates of gas emission) it is not.

In the absence of more detailed information the evidence is not, and perhaps cannot be, conclusive, but it would appear that the comparative freedom from explosion in France is not unconnected with the high statutory standards of ventilation. It is appreciated that the firedamp content of a return is not a complete measure of the standard of ventilation throughout a mine.

Coal Dust.

The French general regulations in regard to coal dust are on broad lines, the three cardinal principles involved being (a) the prevention of accumulations of coal dust, (b) the prevention of an inflammation of coal dust, and (c) the limitation of the extent of a coal dust explosion. Of these, (a) and (b) call for little comment, the practice being similar to that in this country. Dust-tight tubs are only necessary in dusty mines of the first category. But under (c) arrangements must be made against the possibility of an explosion being propagated from one district to another. This is effected generally by the provision of "arrets-barrages" — in practice, stone dust barriers of special construction — and/or stone-dusted zones. Where required, the roads are stone-dusted as in this country, though the proportion of incombustible dust demanded by the special regulations is higher than the 50 per cent. in Great Britain, not unusual figures being 60 and 70 per cent.

That the coal dust in some French mines is highly inflammable — on the basis of volatile matter content — is indicated by the fact that 40 per cent, of the output in the Pas-de-Calais coalfield in 1935 was from seams of a volatile matter content of 32 per cent. or more.

Another requirement for dusty mines — as for ventilation purposes in fiery mines-is the limitation of the number of persons in a district; the maximum formerly fixed — 150 — has been considered to be too high and it is left to the Inspectors to reduce this as far as is practicable. These districts are usually isolated by stone dust barriers.

Causes of Explosions.

Naked Lights. — Comparison of the figures under the naked lights heading is striking. As stated in the Report three classes of lamps are used in French mines: safety-lamps, which must be of approved types; flame-protected lamps (in which the flame is so protected by glass and metallic gauze as to eliminate in practice the risk of fire); naked flame lamps or naked lights. With certain exceptions, the use of safety-lamps is obligatory in fiery mines, i.e., those in which the presence of firedamp has been — even if only once — established. In non-fiery mines where safety-lamps are not used, the regulations require the use of flame-protected lamps; but as a result of exemptions granted to small mines where no trace of firedamp has ever been observed and where there is little or no liability of fire, i.e., in mines which are wet or where timbering is practically non-existent, some 500 naked flame lamps are in use. Even in such mines, however, the use of naked lights is not allowed in stables or stores of inflammable material (fodder, straw, etc.). The advantage of the flame-protected lamp (some 8,000 were in use in 1935) over the naked light is the reduced risk of underground fire. The total number of safety-lamps at mines in France in 1935 was 190,026. Naked flame lamps and protected flame lamps therefore represented approximately only 0.25 per cent. and 4.1 per cent, respectively of the total number of lamps at all mines.

Safety-lamps. — The explosion risk from the use of safety-lamps is small. The ascertained opinion in France as regards flame versus electric safety-lamps is stated to be, as in Germany, in favour of electric lamps being used for lighting and flame lamps for gas testing. The tendency is to provide workmen with portable electric lamps (except in so far as a flame lamp must be provided as a firedamp indicator in each separate working) and otherwise to confine the use of flame lamps to officials. This is especially so where spirit lamps fitted with internal relighters are used, their danger in inexpert hands being recognised. The spirit lamp is a better gas detector than the ordinary oil lamp.

Considered in relation to the numbers employed, the explosion risk from safety-lamps was approximately the same in each country during the 10-year period under review.

Shot-firing. — Both in France and Great Britain, explosions attributable to shot-firing accounted for a greater number of deaths than any other specific cause. And though the death-rate in Great Britain was only slightly the higher, the explosion risk in France — relative to the numbers of persons employed — was approximately 50 per cent, less. Of importance in this connection is the consumption of explosives, since, other things being equal, the greater the quantity used the more numerous will be the ignitions therefrom. For the year 1935 the quantity of explosive used per ton of gross output in France was 0.136 lb.; for the Moselle district, where approximately 50 per cent, of the output is got by explosives only, the amount was 0.33 lb. per ton. The relative figure in Great Britain for the same year was 0.11 lb. The number of shots fired was proportionately — by tonnage — about 25 per cent, less in France, i.e., the average amount of explosive per shot was greater in France than in Great Britain.

Though, as in Great Britain, shots in fiery or dusty mines can only be fired by men appointed specially for the purpose, those appointed as shot-firers in France have usually no other work than shot-firing to do.

Simultaneous shot-firing — in fiery and dusty mines electrically — is practised in coal and in stone and is generally regarded as good practice though it would appear to be more usual to fire rounds of 3 or 4 shots rather than 20 or 30; for example, on longwall faces.

Because of the higher ventilation standards in France it seems likely that the average conditions as regards gas when shot-firing are safer than in this country; for, even though it might be contended that it is as safe to fire shots in 2 per cent. of firedamp as in 1 per cent., it is also equally true that in practice the maintenance of a 1 per cent, standard of ventilation will give a greater margin of safety than would exist were the standard 2 per cent.

Electricity. — As in the case of naked lights, herein lies in part an obvious explanation for the higher accident rate from explosions in this country. In France electricity is little used underground other than for pumping, and chiefly near downcast shafts ; the use of electrically-driven coal-face machinery is practically unknown, though some gate conveyors are electrically driven.

Underground Fires. — Three explosions caused by underground fires, all attributed to spontaneous combustion, accounted for 54 deaths in Great Britain. These contributed to the higher death-rate from explosions in this country, for none with fatal results was so caused in France. Where there is liability to spontaneous combustion in France, the stowage must be so constituted that it cannot give rise to outbreaks of fire.

Matches or Smoking. — Explosions attributed to matches or smoking also contributed to the greater death-rate in Great Britain. As in this country, searching is authorised in France, but there it must be done before descent. The usual practice in Great Britain is to search underground; H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines has, on more than one occasion, recommended that searching be carried out on the surface.

Miscellaneous or Unknown. — Attention is drawn to the augmentation of the deaths under this heading consequent upon the impossibility of determining the cause of the Gresford disaster in 1934. As, however, the British death-rate from whatever cause is higher than that in France, its elucidation would doubtless have served only to accentuate the difference existing as regards one of them.

Conclusion.

Major Hudspeth in his conclusion expresses the view that to assess accurately the effects of all the factors contributing to any difference in the explosion death-rates of two countries is impossible. Nevertheless, some definite conclusions can be drawn from the information and statistics available for the period 1925-34.

From no specific cause of explosion was the death-rate in Great Britain less than that in France. Those causes in respect of which the death-rates for the two countries most closely approximated were safety-lamps and shot-firing. The death-rates due to explosions caused by naked lights and electricity were very much higher in Great Britain than in France, where the use of safety-lamps is almost universal and electricity is very little used at or in the vicinity of the coal face. The British explosion death-rate relative to that of France was increased by explosions due to underground fires and matches or smoking, causes not operating in France during the period under consideration, and by an unduly high number of deaths under the miscellaneous or unknown heading.

There are, however, two predispositions which must co-exist before an explosion can occur — a source of ignition and an ignitable medium ; the latter in present-day mining practice is almost inevitably firedamp. The higher the standard of the ventilation the greater must be the factor of safety against the occurrence in given conditions of an ignitable mixture of firedamp and air; and it seems clear that there is in France a broad general relation of cause and effect between a high statutory standard of ventilation and a low accident rate from explosions.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Hudspeth, Henry Moore, Major      Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print