23rd October 1937, Page: 117, Column: 1
Mining Education And Training
Prof. Hay Explains Minority View
Directing attention, in a paper before the North Staffordshire
Institute of Mining Engineers on "Education and Progress in
the Mining industry," to the complaints as to the difficulty of
obtaining recruits of good calibre for the higher posts in the
industry, and the shortage of young entrants as miners,
Prof. Douglas Hay, M.C., B.Sc., although he does not feel competent
to suggest the ultimate remedy, said there were three steps that
seemed to be indicated, namely : (a) Improved status for all
engaged in the industry; (b) Improvement in the method of
recruitment; (c) The creation of a definite scheme of education,
training and prospects for young men seeking to qualify as officials.
He said he recognised that his views are not likely to meet with
general acceptance. There are two divergent views (1) Those
who consider that not only will suitable men and officials always
be available, but that any alteration in status or training is
undesirable. (2) A minority but increasing view that a new type
of official is required specially trained from youth to cope with
the increasing complexity of mine organisation required by
modern methods of mechanical mining. Upholding the latter
view, the Author had no intention to criticise the manager and
official of the past who have brought the industry to its present
state of efficiency and who are responsible for the modern developments of
mechanised mining, recognising that such men have
built up the experience and technique required to-day.
Following a statement on the question of status Prof. Hay
referred to the method of recruitment, suggesting that an intensive
propaganda should be commenced to point out the opportunities
mining offers, and to overcome the emphasis at present laid on
the dirty nature of the work, the early hours and constant labour
troubles. Scholarships should he offered by the Mining Association
of a type likely to attract good entrants. Similarly, so far as
recruitment for the lower ranks is concerned, local schools might
well be approached and a scheme devised in the districts for the
training of selected candidates. Scholarships might be offered
in this field. Recently the Miners' Welfare Committee has decided
to offer 30 annual scholarships and this figure might well be
increased to 300.
So far as the recruitment of the working miner is concerned,
his demands may be summed up as improved status, higher wages,
security of tenure, and more leisure.
As to the scheme of education and training, Prof. Hay wished
to make two points. First a definite scheme embodying a sound
balance as between education and practical training must be laid.
before the would-be entrant so that he is aware at the commencement
of the steps he has to take. It must provide for his continued.
training during those difficult years between taking his colliery
managers examination and the time when he can obtain a good.
post, and it must show a pecuniary remuneration commensurate
with the effort involved.
Dealing with the second point the Author said: "I see definite
danger in the type of training in many local technical schools,
apparently fathered. by the Board of Education, whereby the
youngster is asked to take a continuing course of day and/or
evening study of as much as nine years, leading up finally to the
colliery managers' examination. No boy to-day is going to tie
himself to such a scheme. The fundamental mistake, in my
view, is in endeavouring to make a single course suitable for all
ranks of officials. I am sure that the right course is to pick for
the higher grades well-educated boys from the secondary and.
public schools, and send them to the universities and better
equipped technical schools for a degree or diploma full-time course
in mining (Or general engineering) in conjunction with an approved.
course of practical training.
"The smaller technical schools on the other band should regard
their primary task as that of training boys for the subordinate
grades, though facilities might be given for training ambitious
and. selected students for the certificate examinations. These
courses should be supported by colliery companies helping to
pick out the right boys, assisting them to attend school and finally
supervising their practical training. Provision can be made for
transferring suitable candidates to the universities if the early
education is found suitable."
Commenting on so little use being made of the vast educational
machine available in this country, Prof. Hay referred to the Board.
for Mining Examinations failing to demand that officials shall have
passed through an approved. course of training. If this were done
"we should not perhaps have 75 per cent. of candidates failing
for the colliery managers' examination," he added.
In conclusion, the Author referred to the need for safety training
and for the dissemination of information relating to progress in
research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Hay, Douglas, Prof. | | | |