Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

22nd October 1937, Page: 782, Column: 1

Notes from the Coal Fields

Yorkshire

[Local Correspondence.]

Speaking at the ordinary general meeting of the United Steel Cos., Ltd., in London last Friday, Sir Walter Benton Jones, Bart. (chairman of the company) said that in the present state of demand there were few departments in any steelworks which had not been working at full capacity during the last 12 months. Their experience was that the increase in demand at home was general, with shipbuilding perhaps leading the way. They had also increased their export trade, especially in the second half of the year. The demand both at home and for export continued. The quantities of coal, coke, pig iron and steel ingots produced by the company were higher than in the previous year. The finishing departments had also been well occupied. Costs were higher. They had to give more for the materials which they bought and were paying higher wages to their employees. The price of coal, which affected them as buyers as well as sellers, had risen gradually throughout the year, but the total increase of 1s. 3d. per ton recorded by the Mines Department could not be regarded as excessive. Latterly the prices of steel had been advanced to meet the increased costs of production, but these advances assisted them only in the last two months of the year. When they considered that the consumption of steel had more than doubled since 1932 they should not wonder so much why prices had risen, but rather be surprised that the producers were able to go so far towards meeting the increased demand. The chairman added that, in his opinion, prices would have been higher than they were now if the present system of co-operation in the trade had not been established. Close investigation would show that where a trade was organised and producers were co-operating, the variation in prices was less and certainly was more gradual than where individuals without any restraint were free to fix any price they might choose. He could give two examples affecting their own operations. In the coal mining industry very large quantities of timber were used in the form of pit props. These were nearly all imported, and it was usual to buy them over comparatively short periods varying from six to 12 months. Quite recently, without any warning, prices had been doubled. This action had raised the cost of mining coal by several pence per ton. Another example was the price of coke, which was not controlled and of which he could speak without prejudice because they themselves were large producers. In some districts the price of coke had risen out of proportion to the increase in cost — that is to say, it had been increased arbitrarily, and this increase was tending to push up the prices of things in the manufacture of which coke played an important part. The prices of steel were not fixed arbitrarily, but only after consideration by very responsible persons, including the Import Duties Advisory Committee, who had the opportunity of reviewing all the circumstances which might justify an increase in price. A few weeks ago it was announced that the German State proposed to develop as a public enterprise low-grade iron ore in certain ore fields which had not been previously developed and that part of the State plan was to build on these ore fields three large new works to produce annually several million tons of iron and steel. This was made an occasion to criticise the British iron and steel industry. It was stated that this enterprise had been made possible by adopting a new British process for smelting low-grade iron ores which it was suggested was not receiving the attention it deserved in this country, and it was said that reorganisation of the British iron and steel industry had gone only a little way. Sir Walter said this criticism was not well founded. There was nothing new in smelting low-grade iron ores in this country. In none of our iron ore fields, with the exception of the relatively small hematite field on the North-West Coast, did the average iron content exceed 32 per cent., and in North Lincolnshire it was only 22 per cent. In the Midlands it had been the practice for many years to rely entirely upon these lean ores, and the ores which it was said the German State was now proposing to develop were certainly not leaner than the 22 per cent. ores which had been successfully smelted in North Lincolnshire for over 70 years. Speaking of the meaning of reorganisation, the chairman said that frequently the word was used to mean the replacing of existing works by complete new works designed in imitation of works operating in some other country. But the fact that works of a particular kind or size seem to those who built them in another country the most suitable for their needs was not in itself a reason for imitation by others. In this country, when new plant was required either to replace what was worn out or to supply a new demand, there would be general agreement that it should incorporate all the knowledge and experience gained in any and every country of what was most suitable for the duty it had to perform. It might be taken that important new installations in this country would stand this test. But the real question in this aspect of reorganisation was to what extent and when, plants which were less modern than the practice of to-day should be replaced? Many plants no longer new had many years of life left in them and were still only a little less efficient than modern plants which, in addition to the high capital charges they had to bear, required nearly full-time operation to be economical. The answer, to this question surely was that the time and extent of replacement must depend or the circumstances of each case. Others who criticised the industry meant by reorganisation, machinery for co-operation. This question of co-operation, in effect, was a question of management in its broadest sense. The steel industry consisted of all the undertakings engaged in what was called the heavy steel trade, and these it should be noted were already concentrated in a small number of units, and a large number of undertakings which formed the finishing end of the industry. These were managed by a number of individuals, but if at a single moment the management could be concentrated in one man or in a single governing body, there would still be the same number of units and they would still require the same number of individuals on the spot to direct them. Without a system of co-operation the difference between these two systems of management would be that while the individual managing each unit, without a system of co-operation, would do what seemed best to himself, the individuals managing under a centralised system would do only what the governing body directed. It would answer no purpose to consider the relative merits of these two extremes because we had left the first and had not yet arrived at the second. Within the last few years complete machinery which they called the British Iron and Steel Federation had been designed for securing far-reaching co-operation. The machinery, which incorporated all existing co-operating machinery, brought all these bodies together and co-ordinated their activities so that they might carry on their business without hurting one another and at the same time provide the quantities and kinds of steel which were required of them. It might not be unreasonable to claim that, except in matters of detail, which could not be adopted without a great deal of preparation and which experience might prove were not necessary, co-operation was now as complete and as effective as in any other country. The organisation negotiated for the whole of the trade with the international steel cartel, and it sold all the heavy steel which was exported abroad. Recently it had organised the distribution among its members of home-made scrap and had made collective purchases of all the pig iron and scrap required to be imported from abroad. It was in effect controlling the prices of many classes of steel, and it was consulted by all who contemplated major additions and improvements to their works. A few months ago the Government asked the Import Duties Advisory Committee to make an investigation of the iron and steel industry. The report of this Committee did not bear out the suggestion that the steel trade was not proceeding with reorganisation sufficiently fast; on the contrary, it said in so many words that great progress had been made. Turning next to extensions to the works, the chairman said the most important of these were at Samuel Fox and Co. and at Appleby-Frodingham. At Samuel Fox and Co. they were developing the making and finishing of finer products, and the greater part of the extensions and improvements which they had made there and were still making were for this purpose. The policy of developing Samuel Fox and Co. as a special steelworks had been fully justified by results. They found more and more, that special steel development had to go hand in hand with specialised research. The scheme of extensions at Appleby-Frodingham was by far the largest they had so far undertaken. Here they were building a new blastfurnace, works, a new coke oven works, extending the steel-melting shop, and they were adding to the rolling plant. The present extension would increase ironmaking capacity to 900,000 tons per annum, the steelmaking capacity to 800,000 tons per annum, and would provide 300,000 tons of coke per annum. The provision for duplication made it possible at some later date to bring the ironmaking capacity up to 1,250,000 tons per annum, the steelmaking capacity up to 1,000,000 tons per annum, and the cokemaking capacity up to 600,000 tons per annum. A part of the extension to the steelworks was put into operation in May of this year. Work on the ironworks and coke oven works was started in June, and it was expected that they will be completed in the second half of 1938. There was no present intention to proceed with the duplication. Sir Walter said his listeners might have heard it said that blastfurnaces in this country were too small, and they might ask what was being done about this at Appleby. He could answer this question most shortly by a series of statements. Very large blastfurnaces were only suitable for large steelworks where large quantities of iron were converted into steel, which in turn was manipulated in large quantities. The largest furnace in the world was in the United States of America, and it was said to be capable of making 1,400 tons of iron per day. In the United States the opinion now was that a capacity of 1,000 tons per day was the economic maximum. The ores used in furnaces which produced 1,000 tons per day were much richer than the ores generally used in this country. In considering the size of a blastfurnace, it should be borne in mind that the output of iron from a furnace was no real criterion of its capacity, for this depended entirely on the iron content of the ore smelted. It could readily be seen that an ore containing 50 per cent. of iron would require a furnace of much smaller dimensions for a given daily output than a furnace using ores with an iron content of 20 to 25 per cent. The lower the iron content of the ore, the more coke was required for smelting, so that in dealing with these lean ores some six tons of material had to pass through the furnace in order to produce one ton of pig iron, whereas with richer ores the quantity of material to pass through the furnace for a ton of iron would be no more than 3 to 3½ tons. The economy which had resulted from the use of large furnaces was not altogether the result of the use of large furnaces. The operating of large furnaces required especially methodical assembling of raw materials and the blending and treating of raw materials. These arrangements contributed to the lower cost of production. The blastfurnaces which they were putting down at Appleby would be the largest in this country. They would have all the latest arrangements for assembling, treating and blending of materials, and it was estimated that they would produce 500 tons of iron per day. If these furnaces were fed with the materials which were fed to furnaces producing 1,000 tons per day in the United States, they would produce 1,000 tons per day. It could be safely said that these new furnaces would be equal to the best American practice both in output and economy of production. Turning to a consideration of the future, the chairman said the demand for steel and the manufacture of steel had completely recovered. In the first half of 1937, Western Europe had not quite regained the 1929 level, while the United States had just passed it. In Great Britain we exceeded the 1929 rate of production by three million tons per annum, or 31 per cent. We consumed steel at a rate 30 per cent. higher than in 1929. Our exports, which had been stationary for the last three years, were still only at two-thirds of the rate at which we exported in 1929, but they exceeded the rate of the previous three years by half a million tons. The world's requirements of steel must continue to grow. In this country the regulation of imports would ensure for us a generally higher level of production for home use. The raw materials we possessed and the geographical advantage of close proximity to the high seas which we shared with all British industries made export trade more easy for us than for many other countries. For these reasons it seemed certain that the production of steel in this country was now established at a permanently higher level. The coal trade also had shown a marked improvement in recent months. We are now consuming as much coal at home as we did in 1929, and although exports were still only 62 per cent, of what they were in 1929. the volume of them and the higher prices realised had brought much relief to the coal fields engaged in export trade.

The appeals of the Mitchell Main Colliery Co., Ltd., their agent and their manager, against convictions at Barnsley on July 23 for alleged breaches of the Coal Mines Act. in that they failed to provide constantly adequate ventilation in the Parkgate seam of the Mitchell Main Colliery were resumed before the Appeals Committee of West Riding Quarter Sessions at Wakefield on Monday, Mr. G. E. Cooke-Yarborough presiding. The appellants were represented by Sir Lynden Macassey, K.C., and Mr. Hylton Foster, and the respondents by Mr. C. Paley Scott, K.C., and Mr. G. H. B. Streatfeild. Cross-examined by Mr. Paley Scott, Spencer Hughes said that when he was appointed manager in September 1936, he was not told of a letter to the colliery regarding the airways in the district in 1931. He could not see how he could be held responsible for any other manager's tactics. Hughes denied that he was sheltering behind the deputies who were under him, and stated that he gave the deputies instructions to report all gas. He had every confidence in the deputies. Hughes was questioned about men who were seen by an inspector coming out of the pit after work had been stopped in the district on the request of the divisional inspector. The inspector had said that each man carried a canister of explosive. Hughes denied that each man carried a canister of explosive, and stated that only one man carried explosives, and he had taken the canister as a matter of routine. The men were sent in to secure No. 3 face. It was a question of agreement with the inspectors. They were safety men. Four men were sent in for ripping and the others were "gob-drawers." William Claytor, the agent, in his evidence, gave the following monthly figures of coal production :— July, 13,334 tons, in 25 days; August, 10,113 tons (22 days) ; September, 7,582 tons (20 days): October, 10,161 tons (25 days); November, 12,337 tons (23 days) ; December, 9,649 tons (23 days) ; January, 8,479 tons (24 days) ; February, 6,652 tons (14 days) ; and September 1937, 10,774 tons (23 days). Claytor was questioned regarding ventilation in the district since the prosecution. He said he did not agree that it was very much better, because he did not agree that at any time it was bad. Re-examined by Sir Lynden Macassey, William Claytor denied that there had been any effort to push production. Production had fallen by 20 per cent. Joseph Wright, a trunk ripper, said he was one of the men seen leaving the pit by an inspector. There were eight men. He had a canister of powder with him which he had taken as a matter of routine. He had the only canister there was in the party. He saw no detonators. Cross-examined, Wright said he was not told that the district had been stopped for gas. Alfred Hardy, under-manager, said the men were not sent down to prepare the face for working, but to secure the face for safety. The fact that a canister was taken in was a mistake. The men were sent down for hand ripping work. Robert Claytor, chairman and managing director of the Mitchell Main Colliery Co., Ltd., said that when control of the pit was acquired by the Shipley Colliery Co., it was decided to have an underground inspection made by an outside person, so as to get a true picture of the pit conditions. The outside person called in was Spencer Hughes, who was now the manager. When this inspection was suggested, the agent of that time expressed his resentment, and his resignation was accepted. Answering Sir Lynden, Mr. Claytor said it was wickedly false to say that the company had been neglectful of the conditions of the ventilation in the mine. He had seen no letters complaining about the ventilation in 1933. Following the report from Hughes, he ordered that the improvements, which would take 12 months, should be proceeded with at once, and completed as quickly as possible. Had he thought that in August, 1936 the ventilation was inadequate, he would have stopped the mine. Mr. Claytor said the majority of managers and deputies agreed that the general body of air in a mine was the air about halfway between floor and roof in a roadway. Cross-examined, witness said it was a general desire to stop shotfiring in pits. The hearing was adjourned until the following day, when Sir Lynden Macassey, K.C. (for appellants) said there had been an attack on the good faith of the colliery company with regard to their agreement with the divisional inspector that there should be no shotfiring. The charge had been made that men were sent down with powder for the purpose of firing shots, despite the promise to the divisional inspector. Mr. Paley Scott said he withdrew the suggestion that there were seven tins of powder, and accepted that the amount of powder taken down was only 2 lb. Technical evidence was given by two witnesses for the appellants. Col. Harry Rhodes, mining engineer, said he did not think it was right to take samples of gas in a cavity for the purpose of ascertaining the adequacy of ventilation. The mere presence of 2½ per cent, of gas generally did not indicate inadequate ventilation. If 2½ per cent, of gas anywhere in a mine were conclusive evidence of inadequate ventilation, then it was difficult to see how any mine, except a naked light mine, could be adequately ventilated. In answer to Mr. Paley Scott, witness said he agreed that there was never any need to make these airways larger or to stop work in this district, and that the inspectors had been too fussy. There was no actual danger. Prof. S. Atkinson, Professor of Mining at the University of Leeds, said the case had caused general consternation and dismay among the general body of colliery managers. The finding of 2½ per cent. of gas in one place at one time was not conclusive evidence of inadequate ventilation. It was necessary to show the gas was not being diluted when given off, and to do that additional samples had to be taken to show whether or not the gas was being diluted. Prof. Atkinson said he had taken tests in the district, and had come to the conclusion that gas was being diluted as it was given off. He had found the ventilation very good. Regarding the differences in percentage of gas found by the inspectors and the company's officials, the inference was that the samples had been taken in different places, and it was evidence that the gas was being diluted. Cross-examined, Prof. Atkinson said he could never accept a suggestion that a fall of roof did not impede ventilation. He thought that to withdraw the men on February 16 was a prudent course to follow. The inspector was within his rights in suggesting it. Addressing the bench, Sir Lynden Macassey said the company embarked on a scheme of improvements in the district as far back as September 1936, and the improvements had keen carried out as quickly as possible. Before the scheme could be completed the prosecutions were launched. Referring to the allegations of personal negligence against Hughes and Claytor, Sir Lynden said the only suggestion of personal negligence against them was that the scheme of improvement was not complete at the dates of the inspections on which the prosecution was founded. It was not even suggested that the work was not being carried out as expeditiously as possible. The prosecution rested entirely on tests and samples taken when, he submitted, there were abnormal causes disturbing the balance of ventilation. It would be unjust to convict the company for alleged inadequacy of ventilation by the results of the one test in one particular place at any one time. To get a picture of the normal condition of ventilation tests should be taken over a long period. "It would be a most serious thing for the colliery industry," he continued, "if, when you found in any particular place a content of gas of 2½l per cent., you must not only withdraw men, but it was proof against you that your system of ventilation is deficient. Under such conditions, I submit, the colliery industry could not be carried on." Mr. Paley Scott said the basic difference between the appellants and the respondents was a question of law. It was of very great public importance to know whether it was true that a standard of safety was to be taken by all courts as being a standard of ventilation within the meaning of the Act. The required standard of ventilation, he submitted, was far removed from the danger point, and the whole object of the prosecutions and the inspections was to try and see that a pit never got to the danger point of 2½ per cent. gas content in the general body of the air. The question was not whether the men were put in danger, or whether there might have been an explosion, but of whether the ventilation was adequate. The bench then announced their decisions. The chairman (Mr. G. E. Cooke-Yarborough) announced that the appeals against the convictions on two summonses against the agent, William Claytor, and the manager, Spencer Hughes, covering a period from February 10 to March 17, and alleging personal and wilful neglect on their part and in respect of which the manager was sentenced to one month's imprisonment, would be allowed without costs. The other appeals were dismissed, the fines in those cases being a total of £200 on the company, a total of £100 on the agent, and a total of £52 on the manager.

Nine men were injured at Denaby Main Colliery, South Yorkshire, on Wednesday, when an underground train on which miners travel to and from their work at the coal face broke in two, half of the train running backwards and half forwards. It was carrying about 190 men at the time, but most of them jumped off safely. Of the nine men injured, two were detained in hospital, two others received hospital treatment, and five were given attention at the colliery ambulance room.

Fifty-three haulage hands, employed at Bentley Colliery, were summoned at Doncaster, on October 11, for breach of contract, following a lightning strike. Mr. C. R. Marshall (for the colliery company) said that on August 6 six youths had their checks stopped for something they had done, and were refused work until they had seen the under-manager. They did not see the under-manager on the following morning and because they were not allowed to work, the defendants, haulage hands on the afternoon shift, refused to go down the pit. As a result, 130 colliers in two districts of the mine could not work. The youths would not listen to the advice of their union leaders, but took matters into their own hands. Mr. G. S. Ward (for the defendants) said the breach of contract was admitted, but he had to insist on strict proof of the damage. The chairman, addressing the defendants in court, said that what struck him, as one not connected with collieries or the miners, was that when lads absented themselves from work illegally, he was sure they had not considered what the result of their action would be. He thought it ought to be brought home to them that there were other people to think about besides themselves. The first direct effect of action of this sort was that a whole lot of colliers, who otherwise would earn good wages, were thrown out of work, and there were other serious consequences, apart from the loss to the colliery company. Loss spread over the country, businesses and the running of the country were affected. He was sure a lot of the lads were too young to appreciate this, and they were probably led away by somebody else. The chairman said he wanted to impress on them that if they had a grievance they had two alternatives — to give in their notice, or to consult their union officials, who knew much more about it than they did. The claim against the defendants was £2 7s. in each case, and the bench ordered the payment of what the chairman said they considered a reasonable amount of damages — lads under the age of 16 to pay 16s., 16 to 18 years 20s., 18 to 20 years 22s., and 20 to 22 years 30s. The amounts would be stopped from their wages.

An inquest was held at Dalton on October 11 on F. Bennett, aged 21, coal cutter, who was killed in Silverwood pit in the early hours of October 10. A. Davis, coal cutter, said Bennett was working a few yards away knocking the prop out with a hammer. Witness heard a shout and found him in a sitting position with his face bleeding, with between three and four hundredweights of dirt which had fallen from the roof, on him. He could have used a Sylvester. W. H. Charity, deputy, said Bennett and Davis were turning a coal cutting machine round, and to do the work they would have to move one or two props. They should have set temporary props and used a sylvester. There was a fault slip where the fall occurred. The cause of the fall was the drawing out of a prop in or under it. Witness thought Bennett was hit by a prop. The coroner said the question whether the accident would have happened if temporary props had been set or if a Sylvester had been used was an important one and might crop up in another court. A verdict of "Accidental death" was returned.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, Frank Stuart, Prof.      Whos Who Page
Bennett, F.   21 Coal Cutter  Deceased, Individual Page
Charity, W. H.    Deputy  
Claytor, Robert    Chairman  
Claytor, William    Colliery Agent  
Cooke-Yarborough, G. E.      
Davis, A.    Coal Cutter  
Foster, Hylton      
Hardy, Alfred    Under Manager  
Hughes, Spencer    Colliery Manager  
Jones, Walter Benton, Sir    Chairman  Whos Who Page
Macassey, Lynden, Sir    K.C.  
Marshall, C. R.      
Rhodes, Harry, Colonel    Mining Engineer  Whos Who Page
Scott, C. Paley    K.C.  
Streatfeild, G. H. B.      
Ward, G. S.      
Wright, Joseph    Trunk Ripper  


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print