|
1st October 1937, Page: 638, Column: 1 Notes from the Coal FieldsNorthumberland and Durham[Local Correspondence.] Jarrow Town Council has received an inquiry from a group of industrialists considering the erection of a steel smelting plant at Jarrow. The town clerk has given them information and put them into touch with the railway, employment exchange, public service undertakers and the port authorities for further information. The town council has also passed a resolution protesting at the delay in starting the new steel rolling mills at Jarrow. The President of the Board of Trade announced in the House of Commons on June 22 that a steel plant was to be built at Jarrow, and the council has decided to request that the Government should follow up this announcement by seeing that the works are built as soon as possible. The Commissioner for the Special Areas of England and Wales announces that he has decided to acquire a substantial area of land in Jarrow for the purpose of industrial development. This area includes the site of the disused shipbuilding yard and steelworks on the south bank of the Tyne, commonly known as "Palmer's" yard. Sixty men are now employed at the new shaft sunk by Hartley Main Collieries, Ltd., at Wideopen, which started operations a month ago. A drift has been driven from the new shaft to the nearby Dudley Colliery, and coal is conveyed underground to the Dudley screens. The Hartley Main Collieries, Ltd., their agent, and three colliery managers employed by the company were charged at Whitley Bay Police Court, on Tuesday, with offences under the Coal Mines Act. at the instigation of the Director of Public Prosecutions. The charges were in relation to the provision of a ready means of egress from the Nelson pit. Defendants were the Hartley Main Collieries, Ltd., of Cramlington; Thomas Thornton, agent William Herrod, colliery manager; Albert Lewin, colliery manager; and Norman Beaney, colliery manager. The first charge against all the defendants, except Beaney, was that in the Plessey seam in the Nelson Colliery they did not provide and maintain two main airways in such condition as to afford a ready means of ingress to and egress from the workings. This charge was preferred against the company and Thornton in relation to a period between February 22 to July 5, 1937, against Herrod in relation to February 22 and March 25, and Lewin between March 26 to July 5. The second charge, which was against the company, Thornton and Herrod, was that they committed a breach of the Act in that they failed to see that every part of the mine was provided with at least two ways of affording means of egress to the surface and so arranged that, in the event of either becoming impassable at any point, the other would afford means of egress to the surface. A similar charge in relation to June 30, 1937, was preferred against the company, Thornton and Lewin. The fourth charge was against the company, Thornton and Beaney, in that at Shankhouse Colliery they failed to see that the Low Main seam, worked from the Joy shaft was provided with at least two ways of affording a means of egress to the surface. The company, Thornton and Beaney, were further charged with two offences, on May 6 and July 20, 1937, that in the Low Main seam of the Joy shaft they failed to provide properly constructed stables for horses underground. Dr. J. Charlesworth prosecuted and Mr. C. B. Fenwick appeared for the defendants. On the application of Mr. Fenwick, the hearing of the charges relating to the Joy pit were adjourned to a date to be mutually arranged. Counsel pointed out that these summonses had not been served until four days ago and he had no knowledge of them. A plea of "Not guilty" was entered in respect of all the charges. Dr. Charlesworth explained the sections of the Coal Mines Act under which the charges had been brought, and mentioned that the object of the Act. was to prevent a disaster such its happened many years ago in connection with the Hartley Colliery where the only shaft was blocked and the men could not get out. Stating that the Nelson pit was constructed in a somewhat inconvenient way as there was only one circular road through the Plessey seam which he likened to the Newcastle Coast Electric Railway, Dr. Charlesworth said that if a fall occurred anywhere on that road men working there had only one means of egress. A fall had occurred on that route on February 22, and had another fall occurred men working there would have been unable to get out. Under the Act more than 10 men were not allowed to work where they had only one egress, and he contended that the men working there should have been withdrawn to a position where they would have had two means of egress. T. L. McBride, senior inspector of mines, in evidence, said when he arrived at the Plessey seam on February 22 he had to crawl on his hands and knees and then found his way blocked by a fall of stone, He told Mr. Lewin that men should not be working there because the conditions were so bad. Mr. Lewin told him that the airways were bad and, after making his inspection, witness agreed with him. There was one continuous circuit of ventilation. In answer to Dr. Charlesworth, Mr. McBride said that he was of the opinion that on a fall of stone occurring there the men should have been withdrawn. Mr. Fenwick said he objected most strongly to this remark. On his second visit to the colliery on March 9 Mr. McBride said he found that the airway was not in such a condition as to provide ready means of egress. There had been little, if any, improvement in the conditions, although the repair work was still being carried out. On March 22 the conditions were much the same, although on this occasion he was not "jammed," His final visit was on May 10, when work was still being carried out, but conditions were much the same. Answering Mr. Fenwick, the inspector said before February 22 there were two ways to afford means of egress, and the normal road was a perfectly sufficient road. There was also a second way which one might call an emergency exit. Mr. Fenwick asked Mr. McBride if his department was trying to say that if one of the roads was temporarily blocked by a fall the men should be withdrawn. Mr. McBride said that was his opinion. His reading of the Act was that workmen should be withdrawn if one way was temporarily blocked. When the hearing was continued on Wednesday, Mr. Fenwick recalled Mr. Thomas L. McBride, senior inspector of mines, to ask him if it was his view that if a train of tubs smashed up in the main haulage road, completely blocking the road. that workmen should be withdrawn until the way was cleared. Mr. McBride declined to give a definite opinion, adding that much would depend on the circumstances. Albert Lewin, manager of the Nelson Colliery, said that as an experienced mine official he was of the opinion that the airways in the Plessey seam complied with the Act. When there was a fall at the colliery be did not think it warranted the withdrawal of the workmen. He agreed with Dr. Charlesworth that the roof in the seam was bad in parts, and that up to a certain degree it required constant attention. He admitted that there were places in the seam where for short distances men had to go on hands and knees to get along, but it was not a struggle to do so. If there was an explosion or other serious mishap he was of the opinion that in spite of the fact that men escaping would have to go down on their hands and knees in parts the airways still provided a ready means of egress. Thomas Roberts, master shifter at the colliery, said the airways in the Plessey seam presented no difficulties and were easily accessible. A similar opinion was expressed by William Pitchford, a deputy at the colliery. Robert Sims, general stoneman at Nelson Colliery, said he had never experienced any difficulty in getting along the airways in the Plessey seam. William Costello, stoneman at the colliery, said he had never found any difficult in getting along the airway. On occasions when there had been falls the way had been cleared quickly and the debris deposited in such a manner that it did not interfere with the airways. Guy Clephan, mining engineer, associated with several collieries, said that he was of the opinion that it depended on the circumstances as to whether men should be withdrawn after a fall. If there was a fall in the return airway it was mining practice-and a good practice, he thought to put men on immediately to remove the fall, but for the men to continue working providing there was no danger. Asked by Mr. Fenwick what, as an experienced mining engineer, was his opinion of the meaning ready means of egress, witness replied a road over which a party of workmen could travel in a reasonable time. Cross examined by Dr. Charlesworth witness disagreed with the view that in the event of a fall, not only should the next shift not he sent down into the mine, but that the existing shift should be withdrawn. Mr. Clephan expressed the opinion that in the immediate neighbourhood of the working face an airway 1 ft. 9 in. high could be taken as a ready means of egress. Dr. Charlesworth expressed surprise at hearing this from a witness whom he described as "a man of great experience." Mr. Clephan said that if his opinion was not right then many coal mining managements in this country were contravening the Coal Mines Act. John Carr, overman at the Nelson pit, said an experiment had been made recently in taking a stretcher case along the return airway, which was substantially in the same condition as it had been in July. They had encountered no difficulty in taking the stretcher along. The bench retired to consider their decision. After retiring for two hours the magistrates, over whom Prof. Wright presided, found that the following charges were proved : That in the Plessey seam of the Nelson Colliery the defendants did not provide and maintain two main airways in such condition as to afford a ready means of ingress to and egress from the workings; and that they committed a breach of the Act in that they failed to sea that every part of the mine was provided with at least two ways of affording means of egress to the surface, and so arranged that in the event of either becoming impassable at any point, the other would afford means of egress to the surface. An additional charge, similar to the second, in respect of another date, was also preferred against the company and Major Thornton. The fines imposed were the Hartley Main Collieries, Ltd., £30; Major Thomas Thornton, agent, of Kenton-road, Gosforth, £15; William Herrod, colliery manager, Brunton Park, Gosforth, £5; and Albert Lewin, colliery manager, Cross-road, West Cramlington, £5. Costs, stated to have been agreed, were awarded against the company.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||