|
17th September 1937, Page: 523, Column: 1 The Holditch ExplosionOfficial Inquiry OpenedMr. F. H. Wynne, H.M. deputy-chief inspector of mines, opened at the Guildhall, Newcastle, on Tuesday, the official inquiry into the Holditch Colliery disaster of July 2, in which 30 lives were lost. After reading the warrant of appointment to hold the inquiry. Mr. Wynne said he was sure that the gentlemen present would join with him in expressing sympathy with the relatives of those who lost their lives in the unfortunate disaster. Mr. Wynne said he thought that, in the course of the inquiry, they would get some very definite evidence as to the spot in the workings where fire commenced, and that it commenced at a coal-cutting machine. They would not, however, have any evidence — so far as he knew at present — of the immediate cause of ignition by the machine. The machine, of course, had not been seen since the men left it on the morning of the explosion. Since then, it had been exposed to the effects of all the elements — air, fire, earth and water. When it was reached, it was doubtful whether there would be much left that might give a true knowledge or guide as to what exactly happened. Replying to Mr. Wynne, Mr. W. Hartley Shawcross, representing the owners of the colliery and the manager, said it was anticipated that not less than two months would elapse before the machine could be reached, when they would he able to see what, if anything, it indicated. Mr. Wynne said that one appreciated the importance as far as possible of being able to get definite information and knowledge of what actually happened at the machine to cause it to set something on fire, but it seemed to him that that was a question rather for experts in a laboratory than for an inquiry of that kind. He was going to suggest, therefore, that they proceed with the inquiry in the absence of that fundamental knowledge. He did not think that the proceedings would suffer from the want of that knowledge, and he did not propose, if the other parties approved, to adjourn for the purpose of going into that. It would mean a long adjournment — possibly with no result, for the machine would be in "a horrible mess." Mr. Shawcross and Mr. J. F. Bourke, representing the North Staffs Miners' Federation, indicated their approval. Mr. F. Collindridge, representing the Mineworkers' Federation of Great Britain, said he would like the question left open, and, in answer to him, Mr. Wynne said he would not rule out a possibility of seeing the machine or the face, should the need arise during the inquiry. J. Armstrong, mining surveyor, was the first witness called, and he gave evidence of preparing plans produced at the inquiry. Cross-examined by Mr. Shawcross, he said that in making the plans he went in the pit about once a week. He wore his shirt and waistcoat, and found the ventilation very good. The state of the roads, in regard to stone dust, was very good. He added that the depth of the district from the surface was 793 yd. W. D. Cumberbatch, assistant surveyor at the colliery, said he had been taking air measurements in the pit since July last year, and said that on the date of the last measurement of the air in the Four-feet seam before the explosion, he had the largest quantity of air circulating in the return airway since he had been measuring. He took his measurements 100 yd. from the upcast shaft in the return airway. In reply to Mr. Frazer, the witness agreed that he did not measure the air in the Four-feet seam "as near as practicable to the downcast shaft," and that although he was directed twice to take air measurements as near as possible to the downcast shaft, he did not do so. He just carried out the procedure of his predecessor. Witness said he always thought the ventilation in the Four-feet seam adequate, but he had heard men complaining of the velocity of the wind there, though they said nothing directly to him. They wore goggles, and complained that dust was driven on to them by the velocity of the wind. Mr. J. Johnson, underground assistant surveyor at the colliery, said that it was part of his duty to take dust samples in the Four-feet seam. He took the samples in the seam twice a month, obtaining them from the cruts and actually in the seam. No result showed more than 27.61 per cent, of combustible matter. W. Beardmore, a coal cutter at the colliery, said that at 10.30 p.m. on July 1, he descended the pit to the Four-feet seam. He and a man named Payne were instructed to take a coal cutting machine from the big dip to the main gate. They were then to start cutting with the machine, and to cut upwards. He said that the machine was cutting quite normally. Coming to the events of the early hours of July 2. witness said that at 5.45 a.m., he and his companions, Payne and Moore, saw a white flame running round with the picks. It seemed to be attached to the picks. In reply to Mr. Frazer, witness said the flame extended at the back of the machine, all the length of the cut — which was 7 or 8 yd. — and slightly along the roof. Witness said they did not try to put the fire out, but made for the shaft and got out. There were some stone balls in the coal. The machine pulled up when it met one of these, but he could not tell if it met one just before the ignition. He heard no difference in the sound of the running of the machine. Asked by Mr. Frazer if he saw a stream of sparks come from the machine at the time of the ignition, witness replied, no. Mr. Frazer then asked the witness if he remembered an incident on the night shift at the colliery on June 6. Witness said he did, and described how the glass of an electric lamp was broken by the cutting machine. This breaking of the lamp, he thought, lighted gas, and there was a flame, 4 or 5 yd. long, in the cut. They put out the flames by blowing compressed air under the cut. Asked why they did not attempt some method of putting the flame out on July 2. witness said because it was blazing too big. On June 6, he said, the ventilation was very good, and it was about the same before the fire on July 2. He saw Payne make a test for gas, but he (witness) never saw any gas. There was sometimes some water on the face, and there was water on June 6. It was used in putting the fire out. On July 2 there was no water, and it was very dry. That was one of the reasons why he went away from the fire. He agreed that there was stone dust obtainable 10 to 15 yd. from the face and could have been used to put out the fire if they had thought of it. In reply to Mr. G. H. Jones, representing the Midland Miners' Federation, witness said he was frightened by the outburst of fire on July 2, and went because the flames were so high that he thought he could not beat them back. Mr. J. W. Sumnall, secretary of the Staffs Firemen's, Overmen's and Shotlighters' Association, then cross-examined the witness, who said, in reply to his questions, that he could not be sure it was gas which was ignited, either on June 6 or July 2. He agreed it might have been oil or dust from the machine. In reply to Mr. Shawcross, witness said he had never seen the picks on the machine red-hot. He had seen sparks emitted from the machine two or three times. H. Payne, a coal-cutter, said he had worked in the Four-feet seam at the Brymbo Colliery since it was started. Dealing with the incident on June 6, he reported the matter to the manager. Describing the fire of July 2, witness said it was a white-hot flame along the holing where they had cut. It was too hot to look at. He did not stop to put the fire out because it was too big. Witness said that the ventilation in the district was always excellent, he did not know whether gas became ignited on July 2, and could not say what else it could have been. Mr. Frazer asked if witness thought it possible that someone left a canister of explosives at the coal face. He said no. After the fire in June, witness continued, the type of lamp was changed, and the July fire could not have been due to one of the lamps. On July 2, firemen had been on the coal face two or three hours, and there was. therefore, no need for him to test for gas when he reached the face. He carried a flame lamp to test for gas, but he did not use it on that occasion, because firemen had been there. Witness admitted that he never saw a fireman make a test that night. There was such a big current of wind that there could not have been any gas. There was plenty of stone dust spread. Cross-examining, Mr. Bourke asked whether witness agreed that there was a good deal of gas about the coal face, and that one had to be careful. Witness said he never saw any gas. Mr. Shawcross asked the witness if he was still of the opinion that the fire on June 6 was caused by the breaking of the lamp. Payne replied that he was. Subsequently, he added, the manager (Mr. Davies) made them use cap lamps. He had never seen any gas in the pit. Witness said he had been in four or five pits. In his opinion the Brymbo was the finest pit in North Staffordshire. J. Moore, a colliery fireman, also described the fire of July 2. He said he heard "a sound like a puff," looked round, and saw the flame behind the cutter. It was a yellow-reddish flame. It appeared to be lapping from underneath the cut, up to the face of the coal. He went nearer to it to see if he could get down that way, but he could not, because of the heat of the fire. He described the measures taken to get the men out of the pit when the fire had started. He said that at no time were the doors of the main dip left open after the fire had started. Eventually, they took a roll call, and two men — W. Heystead and A. R. Stanton — were missing. They got into communication with the lamp house at the surface, but found they had not taken their checks in. Later he heard two further "puffs" — and explosions more serious than the first, causing smoke and dust to rise. Witness said that officials of the colliery — Mr. Davies, Mr. Whitfield and Mr. Adkins — were on the scene at 7 a.m. Mr. John Cocks came just before 9 o'clock. They were advised by the overman of what had happened. The second explosion occurred exactly at the time a rescue team arrived. This time the organisation of supplies of materials — sand, stone dust, and so on — to seal off the burning area, was in progress. Just as he (witness) went through the ventilating doors there seemed to be a big explosion, and a heavy reversal of the air. He was flung through the doors nearest the return airway. Replying to Mr. Bourke, Moore agreed that the only change that followed the fire of June 6 was the provision of cap lamps. Replying to Mr. J. W. Sumnall, witness said the efforts from 6 to 9 o'clock were concerned mainly with trying to get the two missing men. He went into the return to look for them. When the hearing was continued on Wednesday the witness, J. Moore, asked by Mr. Bourke whether he entered in any book the report he made on the fire of June 6, replied in the negative, and Mr. Bourke then submitted that there was an obligation to enter such a report in a book. He asked for Mr. Wynne's ruling with regard to s. 64 and 67 of the regulations. The legislation, he said, was designed to prevent spontaneous combustion in the pit, and, for that purpose, it ordered that certain things should be done when any fire occurred. The regulations could not have intended that the workman in charge should be the judge of what was the cause of a fire. The legislation was that, on the appearance in any part of the mine of smoke, or any other sign indicating that fire had or might have broken out, every workman other than those dealing with the emergency should be withdrawn. If fire broke out, the obligation at once arose to have an examination and order the withdrawals. Otherwise, the preposterous position arose that the decision was left to the workman. Mr. Wynne said the spontaneous combustion regulations did not apply in that case, but Mr. Bourke submitted that s. 64 was not observed. Dealing with s. 67 — that concerning the withdrawal of workmen — Mr. Bourke said that this ordered that if at any time it was found, by reason of the prevalence of inflammable or obnoxious gas, or any cause whatever, the mine or any place in the mine was dangerous, men must be withdrawn. On June 6 there was an occurrence coming under the description "any cause whatever," making the mine or a place in the mine dangerous for the time being. In his submission, s. 67 should have been carried out. Mr. Wynne said he did not want to give a ruling then, but would make some reference to it in his report. Questions on that subject were relevant. Mr. Bourke asked witness why the report was not entered in a book and witness replied that he had the advice of the manager, but no one advised him either to enter or not to enter the report in a book. Mr. Shawcross, replying to Mr. Bourke's submissions, said that, so far as s. 64 was concerned, it was abundantly clear that that related only to occurrences discovered by the fireman in the course of his inspection before work commenced. Such an occurrence was to be recorded in a book, and the Secretary of State himself had shown that he adopted that construction of the section by the form of report prescribed to be used. If at any time other than during his inspection, some occurrence of danger happened, there was a separate obligation to report under s. 50. It was under that section that Moore made his report of the fire on June 6. He complied literally and properly with the requirements of the regulations, and went even further by making a written report — on the advice of the manager — in addition to his verbal report. With regard to s. 67, continued Mr. Shawcross, the construction that Mr. Bourke sought to apply meant that the moment fire occurred, however trivial and however easy to put out, the men should be withdrawn, whatever disaster might occur from allowing the fire to go on. It was a matter for the person in charge of the mine at the time being to decide whether the fire was dangerous or not, submitted Mr. Shawcross. The fireman had stated that, in his view, the situation of June 6 could be dealt with, and, being dealt with, was not a dangerous situation. For that reason, the men were not withdrawn, Mr. Wynne indicated that he would deal with the matter of reporting fires in his report. E. Astles, the night fireman, said, in reply to Mr. Frazer, that everything had been more or less normal on the night shift, of July 1 to 2, up to the time of the outbreak of fire. He was near Beardmore and Payne at 5.30 a.m., supervising their work. They were then about to begin cutting. On leaving Beardmore and Payne, he went to the main gate dip. He stemmed a shot there, but did not fire it. He was about to make his final examination when the fire started. He could see it from where he stood. When he saw it, it was all up the face. It spread to the whole length of face which was cut. It was a uniform wall of flame. In reply to Mr. Frazer he agreed it was very hot, and would have been impossible for anyone to have passed it. Witness said he kept asking the men if they had seen different men, and he took a roll call. He told one, Bossons, who he knew would be last out, to clear all the men out. He being the last would sweep all the others before him. Asked by Mr. Frazer why he did not put stone dust on the fire, witness said they did not think it was safe to get near it. There seemed to be a weighting of roof by the main gate end; they heard a cracking; they heard small falls of roof soon after the start of the fire, round about 6 a.m. on July 2. Mr. Frazer asked if witness thought that, had it not been for the roof weighting, they could have extinguished the fire with stone dust. Witness said they would have had a good chance, but were being driven back by the smoke coming uphill. The doors in the main dip were not open at that time; he said they were always closed. Further replying to Mr. Frazer, witness said he did not recall any trouble about an emission of gas in the right-hand side of the district about a month before the disaster; neither had he seen any report about this in the firemen's book. He himself had never seen or had occasion to report any gas in the pit since the seam was struck. Continuing, witness said they went back. Trevor Hughes and the day fireman went into the cross-cut, and he met them there. Then the first "puff" went off, and they went up the dip. They could not account for Heystead and Stanton. Hughes and Moore tried to get as far as they could down the back dip. Eventually those efforts had to be abandoned. Questioned about the "puff," or explosion, at 6.50 a.m. on July 2, Astles said that Bentley and Hassall were in the right-hand carving when this occurred. Bentley was singed round the head, but Hassall did not return. They (witness and others) then went to the main dip and out towards the pit. An explosion occurred when they were on their way out, about 100 yd. at the bottom of the main dip. It was a more severe explosion than the first, and raised a big cloud of dust and reversed the air. On continuing their way out they met Mr. Davies, Mr. Whitfield and Mr. Adkins, and stayed about the "Fives" cross-cut to help to get stone dust down for completing a stopping. They were to put the stone dust on the haulage and it was to go right through. That work went on while Mr. Davies and Mr. Whitfield and Mr. Adkins made some sort of inspection. Witness also saw Mr. Cocks and an inspector of mines just after eight o'clock. The next thing that happened was that round about 10 o'clock they heard a door rattle, and knew that a rescue team were going up the back dip. A message had been sent that a team was coming. Shortly after this, continued witness, the "big puff" went off. It did not make any noise, but there was a very big reversal of air. Witness said he could not say how long the state of air reversal continued, but it would not be more than a few seconds. Both Moore's and his own safety lamps were extinguished when they were blown down. Hughes had no lamp either, and they were in the dark until they met two other men, one of whom had a lamp. With this light they got to the pit bottom, and saw Mr. Davies there. He told them to go up the pit. Cross-examined by Mr. Bourke, witness said he had tried the wastes, but always found them entirely free from gas. It was well known among the men that sparks were occasionally emitted from the cutting machine. Replying to Mr. Sumnall, witness said that he had been at work, on the day of the fire, since 6 p.m. on July 1. owing to the illness of a colleague. Witness said he did all he could to put the fire out, and later tried, with others, to locate Stanton and Heystead. He added that he had at all times been satisfied with the conditions of ventilation. E. T. Hughes, overman at the mine, said that he was in charge of all the Four-feet workings on the night shift. He tested for gas during the shift and found none. In the morning of July 2 a man drew his attention to an unusual smell, and he was met by a wave of heat. The smell was like that of burning rubber. He ascertained that all the men he could see were out of the face, and he followed them out. There was smoke about, and he sent a man for two men whom he knew to be in the back heading. With regard to Heystead and Stanton, he said he thought they would have got away from the fall before him, as they were working within 20 yd. of the back dip. He now thought they must have been overcome, but agreed it was possible that they went down a waste instead of the back dip. He made arrangements for stone dust to be got down right away, and, while this was being done, he telephoned for the manager. Having given the warning, he went down to see what could be done about putting the fire out. He went as near the face as he could — within 8 or 10 yd. Witness then described the roll call at which Heystead and Stanton were found to be missing. He and Moore immediately went to find them. After about 40 yd. they were beaten back by fumes and smoke. He again went down towards the fire, and then met the day-shift, officials. Witness said that the men were later ordered out, and on their way two explosions occurred. Before they reached the cross-cut, they met Mr. Davies, Mr. Whitfield, and Mr. Adkins. When he had told them what occurred they told him and those with him to prepare to get some dust and material for stopping, presumably to be deposited at "Fives" cross-cut. Mr. Davies and Mr. Whitfield and Mr. Adkins made an inspection of the return at "Fives" cross-cut, and then went down the dip to the seat of the fire, to see if they could find Hassall. Some of the day officials went with them, but not the night officials. They were to stay at "Fives" cross-cut and get the materials ready. All the night-shift men went out except Moore and Astles and himself. While they were at "Fives" cross-cut, Mr. Cocks came down, at about 7.30, and went down the main dip. He was at the cross-cut when a rescue team arrived, a few minutes after Mr. Cocks. Witness told the captain, Ezeriah Clarke, what had happened, and the locality where he thought the missing men were. Later, he was instructed by telephone to put the stopping materials on the rope and let them go down to the bottom. Continuing, witness said that Mr. Bloor, at the time of the explosion at 9.50. asked him to note the time by his (witness's) watch. He (Mr. Bloor) made a note of it in his notebook. Mr. Finney and Mr. Bloor went into the return. When they came back Mr. Finney said it was impossible for anybody to live in that atmosphere. He also asked witness the whereabouts of Heystead and Stanton, and asked him to make a sketch of the workings. He did so with a piece of chalk on an iron plate, indicating where he thought the two men would be. He also mentioned Hassall. The inspectors asked him which way he would take to get out if he were in their position. He explained which was the nearest way out, and asked them if they wanted his assistance, to go down. Mr. Finney said "No," the plan witness had made was sufficient, and he added that witness had been down the pit all night, and he thought that was enough. They went down the main dip. Shortly after this, added witness, the big explosion occurred. He came to the surface soon after. He was in the mine from 10 at night until 10 in the morning, and then he stayed at the surface, helping to dress injured men as they were brought up. He was there until 4 p.m. In reply to Mr. Collindridge, Hughes said the position was so acute that the recovery of Heystead and Stanton was impossible. In reply to Mr. Shawcross, Hughes said a fall of roof at the face, if one occurred, would certainly interfere with ventilation. In regard to the stoppings, there was no reversal of the instructions when the inspectors arrived. In reply to Mr. Wynne, witness could not say it was a good roof. If the timbers were burned and their strength gone, it would rapidly fall. Witness endorsed Astles statement about hearing the timber crackling. Mr. Collindridge said he must insist that, in view of the witness making the point about possible interference with ventilation by a fall of roof, it was necessary for conditions at the face to be seen before any final decision or opinion on the disaster could be reached. In reply to Mr. Wynne, the witness said about 20 men were down the pit after the shift had been withdrawn. Mr. Wynne asked what witness thought those men were down for. Witness said he presumed they were to erect stoppings. D. Mayhew said he considered that the ventilation in the pit was as good as anyone could wish. Answering Mr. H. S. S. Scott, he agreed that his mate took 4 lb. of explosive into the pit. While they were at work it was placed with their clothes, and when they left hurriedly he supposed it was left there. H. Bentley, a day shift fireman, said that he descended the pit shortly after 6 a.m. He decided to follow Hughes and Bloor, and asked a man which way they had gone. The man — who, he later learned, was Hassall — told him and went with him. Witness felt the wind reversing, and he turned round and lay on his stomach. When he came to himself it was dark and he started to crawl out. He saw a glimmer of light in a small fall of dirt, but saw nothing of Hassall. He later went back about the same distance as he had been, but could not find Hassall, and later learned that another man went about 60 yd. further than he had been without success. Witness then described the second explosion. He said he felt the wind reverse and got into a man-hole on his knees. He was in the manhole a second or two and put his hands behind his head, and it was then that he was burned on the hands. The rescue team arrived and sent for the stretchers and brought him out. At the resumed hearing on Thursday, P. Bloor, a day fireman at the colliery, in giving evidence, said, in reply to Mr. Frazer, he was at the pithead at 6 a.m., when H. Johnston received a telephone message that there was some trouble in the Four-feet seam. Johnston, H. Bentley and he went down at 6.15. They went towards the face with Trevor Hughes and got almost to the face rip when they saw smoke and heard the face rip weighting very badly. Witness agreed with Hughes that nothing could be done there, and volunteered to go with Hughes to the return airway in an endeavour to locate the two missing men (Heystead and Stanton). The return was heavily laden with smoke, and they were forced to retreat after going 10 or 12 yd. When they were retreating, they came to the first door to go through the cross-cut. They tried to open it, but it would not yield. Hughes said "Some fool has been through the other door and left it open." They eventually got the door open and went through the next door, which was open. They closed it, he said, and went to the landing, where a cloud of dust indicated that there had been a minor explosion. Bloor described the series of explosions which followed the first one at 6.50 a.m. Before they got to the "Fives" cross-cut on their way out they saw some of the officials — Mr. Davies, Mr. Whitfield, Mr. Adkins, Mr. Jones (day fireman) and Mr. Pepper (day fireman). Bentley, Johnston and witness went forward, down the crut. There was a consultation between Mr. Davies, Mr. Whitfield and Mr. Adkins. They had got to know what had happened down below from the night overman, and they had made up their minds to put a stopping in the main at that point, "Fives" cross-cut. When Mr. Cocks came down he told witness to stay where he was and look after the telephone while he (Mr. Cocks) went down the dip. Asked if, following Mr. Cocks' meeting with Mr. Davies and Mr. Whitfield, instructions as to sending materials down were altered, witness replied yes, because when Mr. Davies came out he said he was going up to organise stone dust supplies, and he said he was going down to the bottom, as they had decided to stop up below the bottom cross cut. Witness said about 14 more men went down to deal with the tubs of stone dust and sand, which were due to arrive. In addition there were at least half a dozen officials there, four men in the rescue team and a further rescue team went down. All these men were in the Four-feet workings between 9 and 10 o'clock. Witness said he did not see the site of the proposed stoppings, either then or afterwards. The inspectors and Mr. Cocks were down the main dip when a sixth explosion occurred. Bloor stated that there was some talk about disconnecting pipes and cables, for the purpose of making the stopping more efficient. Harry Johnson told him that Mr. Cocks had given instructions that they wanted fitters and electricians. Some fitters — William Hodgkinson, Abel Mayer and Harry Mitchell — and an electrician, Frank Turner, went down and went forward to do the work for which they were sent. The Hanley rescue team then arrived to back up the Holditch team. Mr. Adkins came out and made a request for life lines. These were not immediately forthcoming and witness went up the crut and met the men with the life line. He took it off them, and made his way down the dip. When he stopped to take a drink the big explosion occurred. It blew him into the side and started to roll him over a bit. He grabbed the rail while it passed over, and saw a flame above him, but was not burned. When the ventilation was right he made his way up to the cross-cut and dropped across the Holditch rescue team. Asked by Mr. Frazer as to whether he thought it was wise to stay, Bloor answered that they were being guided by superior officers. He had no grave misgivings about staying down. Asked how he accounted for the big explosion, witness said he thought that the smaller explosions were caused by the roof breaking down in small quantities and making cavities. He thought the big explosion was caused by the gas accumulating in a big cavity, and then there was a sudden fall, forcing the gas on to the fire. Ezeriah Clarke, day overman at the colliery, and captain of the Holditch rescue team, said that at first two members of his rescue team were missing. They went down, arranging for the others to follow. One of the missing members, Durbar, had been ill for two days. He turned up later, although he was not really fit. The team followed Mr. Cocks down. He said that Mr. Davies seemed "very much annoyed" when he asked him for instructions. He said witness would get his instructions down below, as Mr. Cocks had taken over. Describing the position underground before the big explosion, he said he saw Mr. Cocks coming out of the right-hand carving with an electric spot light and a flame lamp, which was out — he said he had knocked it over. He told them (the team) to couple up and search the right-hand carving for Hassall. They coupled up as instructed and went along the right-hand carving. There was some fall of dirt in a part of the carving which had been described by Bentley, but it was not, in his opinion, enough to cover a man up. They went past this spot, but at a point about 40 yd. further on the bird they were carrying died. There was a fall at the face, and the road was completely blocked. They had to retire the same way as they had come. When they got back to the main dip they found Mr. Cocks waiting there with Durbar, the other rescue man, and witness asked Mr. Cocks for further instructions. He said he wanted them to uncouple the joint box 50 yd. below the right-hand carving, and he further explained that he was having 6 in. air pipes undone, so that he could get a stopping in in the main 20 yd. below the new heading. Witness went to the fitters for spanners and tools. Mr. Cocks said when witness got back that it didn't matter then. He told them to try and get to the face by the back dip to find Heystead and Stanton. Witness went with the team along the bottom cross-cut. As he was going by the dip he met Mr. Bloor (the inspector) and told him where Mr. Cocks was. There was a party of men towards the cross-cut, including Mr. Pepper, the fireman. They were moving trestles and other stuff off the railings. Then the team coupled up and went in search of the missing men. They carried on down the return. It was so dense that they had to got down on their knees and find their way by the rail. They were not able to see at all. They went about 50 yd. then returned and asked for a lifeline. They waited until the Shelton team arrived, and met them at the bottom cross-cut. They coupled up again, and started up the return. Smoke was coming out of the 8 ft. return in thick clouds, and they again had to get down on their knees; but above the abandoned seam the smoke was thinner, and they were able to go on better. At ten past ten while they were taking gauges they heard a distant bang below them. There was a reversal of air for some moments. They knew what had happened, and quickly got out of the return into the main, to "Fives" cross-cut. When they got to the cross-cut the whole place was thick with dust, and they could not see. Mr. Davies on the telephone asked witness to go down and see what he could do. but witness thought it best to get the team down to the pit and exchange apparatus with that of another team, and get a lifeline. Mr. Davies agreed that was the best course to pursue, and told witness to go to the pit and he would get a team down. In reply to Mr. Frazer, witness said they were in the dark as to what had happened inbye, and the manager had no knowledge. They changed their apparatus and started down again with a safety lamp and a life line. At the second cross cut they found Harry Bentley, who was in a state of collapse, but was conscious. He was sent out on a stretcher. They encountered falls of roof and other signs of violence. They looked down the "steer" and saw the bottom of the dip was on fire. They were 120 yd. away. They went down the dip to see what they could do. They got about half-way down and could hear men groaning. They coupled up, of course, then, and lost no time in getting to the bottom. There was quite a lot of sludge at the bottom of the dip. It seemed that the fall of a girder had broken the water range, and left some handy stuff for putting on the fire. They used it. Right at this point there were five men alive. They put the fire out, and then turned their attention to the injured men. They had to tie some of them together to control them. They let Mr. Davies know there were five men alive, and to send some volunteers. The road there was so steep that it would take six men to take one man on a stretcher. Witness sent word that he wanted from 30 to 60 men. They made a further search round the bottom of the cross-cut. They found Ernest Jones at the corner of the cross-cut. He was alive, in a sitting position. They searched in the cross-cut itself, and went right to the far end. They found one of the rescue team alive and some dead, and then they found Salt. Five of the rescue men were together, dead in the cross-cut where they had left them. One was barely living. The doors in the cross-cut were blown completely out, and the flames had been carried along the cut. Stretcher men eventually came, and they got the men out. He sent for more help, and told them actually how many men were still alive and how many men he wanted to get them out. When they had got the injured men out, they received an order to withdraw everybody from the pit. Witness had got down to where he had left fitters and electricians doing the pipes. They were dead. He did not go any further. When they had word that everyone was to leave the pit, he came out. In reply to Mr. Frazer, witness said he did not think anyone could be alive in the main, and everyone was dead in the cross-cut. He reached the surface at ten past four in the afternoon. Some doubt was raised then as to whether anyone might still be alive. Witness was quite certain in his own mind that there was nobody alive down the pit, but, to satisfy all, he made a subsequent search, between 6 and 8.30 p.m. There was no one alive then. He looked at them all and identified every body except Mr. Cocks. All the time he was down he only experienced one explosion. In reply to Mr. Shawcross, witness said there was a heavy fall of roof on the right-hand side of the face. Both Mr. Bourke and Mr. Shawcross expressed admiration for Clarke's work and courage. Mr. John O. Davies, manager of the Holditch Colliery, said that when he went down the pit he decided to put stoppings at the main gate as soon as the night men came back. He decided on the positions for the stoppings because they were on solid stone and would give him a chance to make an airtight seal. When Mr. Cocks came down a change was made in the arrangement, as Mr. Cocks selected three other places for the stoppings. He told Mr. Cocks these places would not provide an airtight seal. Mr. Cocks took full control and told him to go to the pit and organise supplies. Of the 50 men in the pit, 10 or 12 were engaged in rescue work, and the others were working in connection with the stoppings. Mr. Frazer asked if witness knew there was a danger of an explosion? Witness replied, yes. Asked if he thought he was justified, as manager of the colliery, in risking so many men in the district when there was a danger of an explosion, witness said control was taken out of his hands. After his examination in the morning, his mind was made up that the three men were dead. He didn't know how they possibly could have been alive with the atmosphere as it was. Regarding the fire on June 6, he did not think it was his duty as manager to report it to the divisional inspector, as he had been instructed to report all dangerous occurrences to Mr. Cocks, who would deal with them. When told of the fire on June 6, Mr. Cocks said leave it to him and he would deal with it. Mr. Cooks mentioned that the occurrence was trivial. Mr. Davies, answering Mr. Bourke, agreed that it would be a good thing to have fire extinguishers near the cutting machines. He would go further, he said, and say they should keep some fire extinguisher liquid in the district — about 50 gal. or so — and appliances to use it.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||