Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

11th September 1937, Page: 74, Column: 1

May (1937) Examinations

Report of Central Examiners

The Question Papers set at this Examination have been published in pamphlet form and are obtainable (2s. net) from H.M. Stationery Office.

In presenting the report of the Central Examiners on the examinations for certificates of competency as managers and under-managers of mines held in May (1037), the text of the questions is reproduced for ease of reference. The comments of the Examiners on the work done by the candidates are in italics following the setting of each question.

Winning and Working (1st Class).

(1) In a seam of coal 4 ft. 6 in. thick inclined at 1 in 3 an area of coal lies to the rise side of a level main haulage road. The roof is a strong sandstone and the floor a soft fireclay inclined to heave. The seam gives off gas freely. Describe the method of working you would adopt and lay out by sketch a district to produce 400 tons in an eight hour shift. (50)

The majority of answers tacked detail. The longwall retreating system with faces on line of full dip appears to have been lost sight of by all candidates; and yet such a system may be worked very satisfactorily under the conditions laid down in the question.

(2) Discuss folly the advantages and disadvantages of belt and shaker conveyors respectively on a coal face. Which do you prefer and why ? (40)

On the whole this question was answered fairly well, but little originality was shown in adapting either type of conveyor to meet special conditions.

(3) Explain in detail how you would change a heavy wire rope guide in a shaft 600 yards deep, and describe with sketches the means of securing the guide in the headgear. (40)

This was not a popular question, and few good answers were received. In many cases candidates had very little idea of a safe method of carrying out such a job. Answers were generally tacking in detail and too much was assumed. Students would do well to make a point of seeing such work carried out in actual practice.

(4) Describe with sketches the following: (a) Inverted or reversed fault; (b) Trough fault; (c) Anticine. Give examples of the following: (a) Arenaceous rocks; (b) Calcareous rocks. (40)

In most cases this question does not appear to have caused much difficulty to candidates, although a large number failed to complete the second part of the question.

(5) Describe two methods of illuminating a coal face other than by portable hand or cap lamps. Which method do you consider the better and why? (40)

Answered satisfactorily on the whole.

(6) To what features of an explosive may be ascribed its explosive force P What is meant by sheathed explosives, and does sheathing of explosives have any advantages over ordinary permitted explosives? (40)

Candidates appeared to have a good knowledge of sheathed explosives, and the answers generally were very fair.

(7) On an endless rope haulage dipping 1 in 4 there are several intermediate levels feeding on to it in addition to the bottom. Describe with the aid of sketches the means you would adopt on both loaded and empty tracks to protect persons working at such places from runaways. (40)

Answers in many cases were disappointing. Automatic devices were not taken advantage of as much as they might have been. Any form of protection inside the intermediate levels was omitted in most cases.

Ventilation (1st Class).

(1) On the plan . . . . show how you would arrange the distribution of the air-currents, using the signs and colours given in the General Regulations. Sheets to be shown thus f. (50)

Nearly everyone answered this question, and there were a number of good arrangements. The principal defect was the tendency to oversplit, especially on the west side around the pit pillar, through a path much too short for splitting; and the same applies to the developing face. Such minute splitting would not occur in practice under ordinary conditions. Unusually few failures to place essential separation doors at the pit bottom were noted, and most candidates observed the requirements of a second intake.

(2) Give a description of a hygrometer. Of what use is it in the ventilation of mines? What improved types have come into use? State fully how you would deal with the air-current so as to obtain the most favourable result in deep workings in a steep seam. (30)

Although some of the descriptions were crude, especially the sketches, the use of the instrument was well known.

(3) What are the objects aimed at in making a ventilation survey ? Give in detail the precautions necessary to secure accurate results. (30)

Although a recent development, the object was well understood; there was a lack of detail and of definiteness in many cases.

(4) A mine is ventilated by a current of 240,000 cubic feet of air per minute. The water-gauge at the fan drift is 4 inches. For a length of 3,000 feet the air divides between two airways in parallel; one lined with brick sidewalls and ordinary steel girders -its dimensions are 10 feet wide by 7 feet high; the other is lined with splayed steel arches, 10 feet wide at springing, 11 feet 2 inches at floor, and 8 feet 10 inches high. All dimensions taken in the clear. Make an estimate of the quantity of air which passes along each airway. (30)

The question was made simpler by the ventilating pressure length, and perimeter being the same or nearly so. The calculations proved too difficult for the majority. Many estimates were the reverse of the fact in that the larger current was wrongly given the smaller roadway. The calculation of roadway areas (apart from rectangular ones) was very poor. The question of splitting, in practice a common feature, is not given sufficient attention.

(5) What is the fundamental principle of a flame safety-lamp in mines P Give a short description of the essential details of an early lamp, with a fuller description of a modern lamp as developed from its predecessors, suitable for present-day requirements. Enumerate the precautions necessary to obtain the highest efficiency when in use. State your views on the proportions of flame lamps and electrical lamps desirable in a fiery mine. (30)

The fundamental principle of the flame lamp was well known, and the answers for the most part were good.

(6) A pair of adjacent shafts are each 400 yards deep and 20 feet diameter. At a given time the surface temperature is 60°F., that of the air at the bottom of the downcast 66°F., and the air in the upcast averages 84°F. Calculate: (a) The weight of air in each shaft; (b) the motive column; and (c) the maximum water-gauge under these circumstances, stating where this will be obtained. (30)

This involved some calculations and there were a good many errors. There is also a widespread uncertainty as to where the maximum water-gauge will be found.

(7) Describe, with a sketch — (a) an electric hand safety-lamp, or (b) an electric cap safety-lamp, and state what precautions are necessary so as to obtain the maximum efficiency when in use. (30)

Answers were generally good; the points for the cap-lamp were exceedingly well put.

Explosions, Etc. (1st Class).

(1) In consequence of an underground fire it becomes necessary to construct stoppings in the main intake and return airways, which comprise a pair of stone drifts, 1,000 yards long, dipping 1 in 6, and thirlings or crosscuts 60 yards apart. Make a sketch showing the positions in which you would place the stoppings. Of what material and in what manner would you build them, and what precautions would you take to ensure the safety of persons engaged in these operations? (30)

Many candidates failed to realise that in circumstances of this kind prompt action is necessary to extinguish the fire; there is no time to cut back the strata as is necessary in the construction of permanent stoppings or dams. Some candidates suggested building the stoppings at the bottom of the stone drifts, overlooking the length and gradient, and the consequent difficulty of getting materials to the stoppings. Others did not appreciate the necessity of maintaining the ventilation to avoid an explosive mixture in the area until stoppings are quickly built of any material available.

(2) A seam of coal 3 feet in thickness, dipping 1 in 8, is to be worked from the outcrop to a distance of 600 yards on full dip. Another seam, 20 yards above and 4 feet in thickness, has been worked; there is no access to the old workings, which are believed to contain a lot of water. What measures would you adopt to ensure the safe working of the lower seam? (25)

There were a number of good answers, but some candidates merely described advancing headings in the lower seam with advance and flank boreholes as though approaching old workings in the same seam, and said nothing about the working of the coal in the lower seam.

(3) You take a new appointment as manager of a colliery which is old, extensive, dry and dusty. Spontaneous heating has occurred at various times and there are several areas sealed off. What sort of investigation would you make to satisfy yourself about the safe working of the colliery in the future? (25)

The answers were generally satisfactory in respect of the investigations concerning the areas sealed off, the stale of the roadways as to coal dust, and the ventilation, but little was said about the methods of working and what might be done to ensure safe working in the future.

(4) In working a seam of coal known to be liable to spontaneous heating, show by a sketch how you would lay out the workings so as to limit the area that might be affected by a fire, and state what precautions you would make to deal with an outbreak quickly. (25)

Some of the sketches were very crude and incomplete, and the roadways were not suitably arranged for haulage and ventilation.

(5) Discuss the use of rescue apparatus in an atmosphere of dense smoke and high temperature after a fire. What type of apparatus would you prefer and what special care should be exercised in these circumstances? (25)

Under these circumstances the use of any kind of rescue apparatus is very limited, but some candidates failed to realise this and spoke of teams being in such atmospheres for periods of 1½ to 2 hours. The life-line is essential; the distance that can be covered and the amount of useful work that can be done are very limited. Many candidates, quite properly, preferred the smoke helmet if used within the limit of 120 feet.

(6) An explosion occurs in one of the districts of a large mine. A number of persons are engaged in all the districts of the mine at the time of the explosion. What steps would you take for the safe withdrawal of all persons from the unaffected districts, also for entering the district in which the explosion has occurred ? (25)

Some satisfactory answers, but some candidates overlooked the danger of polluted air in the return airways and upcast shaft. The danger of fire in the affected area was also overlooked, and too much time would be lost in the efforts to enter the affected area if the arrangements described by some of the candidates were carried out.

Machinery (1st Class).

(1) In the case of an alternator generating 3-phase current at 3,800 volts, 50 cycles, how is the voltage controlled? About how much power is used in exciting a 1,000-kw. alternator? How should an alternator be stopped from generating power in an emergency? (28)

This question was chosen less frequently than others. The exciter was sometimes referred to as a motor. A minority only could give the power required for exciting.

(2) An electric over-rope endless haulage is installed in an incline for bringing up loaded tubs of coal and lowering empties. The motor full load rating is 100 b.h.p., but the normal load is 90 b.h.p. Describe the arrangements that you would make for controlling this haulage system, especially for stopping and starting. (28)

A number of candidates confined themselves to a description of a motor and switchgear. Others properly took into account the tendency of the haulage to run backwards and provided against this.

(3) Give a specification of starting plant suitable for (a) a 3-phase squirrel-cage motor of 10 b.h.p. at 400 volts, driving a centrifugal pump; (b) a 8-phase induction motor with wound rotor driving a direct rope incline haulage with frequent starts. Power, say, 75 h.p. at 3,000 volts. (28)

Most of the answers chose correct starting apparatus for a 10 h.p. motor coupled direct to a centrifugal pump. A common mistake was to say that with a star delta starter the current in the starting position is 58 per cent, of the current in the running position. This proportion is, of course, true of the voltage or pressure. In the case of a 75 h.p. motor driving a direct haulage, good answers were given, but a weakness was not to say anything about the rating of the resistance in the motor circuit of this motor, which had to make frequent starts at full load torque. A number of candidates stated that brush-lifting gear would be applied to the motor, omitting to refer to short-circuiting gear. For this duty brushes would not be lifted off the slip-rings.

(4) Compressed air at collieries is a convenient, but expensive, form of power. Describe a well-arranged compressed-air plant and system, including compression, transmission and use in pumps, haulages and pneumatic tools. (38)

This question was generally attempted and earned good masks.

(5) Mention and describe briefly the apparatus that may be applied to a steam winding plant for ensuring the safety of the people travelling the shaft by the plant. Is a ball governor, in the steam supply pipe to a winding engine, of any service? Give reasons for your answer. (28)

Most candidates confined themselves to a mention and description of apparatus for preventing overspeed and overwind, though the terms of the question allowed of the mention of other safety apparatus. The replies as to whether the ball governor in the steam supply pipe of a winding engine is of service, showed that only in one or two cases did candidates appreciate that such a governor is of no use when the winding plant is running free or motoring and is not taking any steam.

(6) A sheave or grooved pulley, with shaft and bearings, are wanted for carrying a 1-inch diameter steel-wire winding rope in a headgear over a vertical shaft. Draw up, in detail, a specification to be sent to makers when inviting tenders. Assume your own conditions and include all dimensions and particulars likely to be useful. (28)

Answers to this question were poor. A number stated that the rim and boss of the sheave would be made of mild steel. Some would screw the mild steel arms or spokes at both ends, but did not explain how they would be placed in position. There was a tendency to make the boss and the shaft too large. In giving dimensions some were of parts not wanted in a buyer's specification.

(7) Describe plant for burning small inferior coal in a boiler (either of Lancashire or of water-tube type). Roughly, how much water would you expect to convert to steam at full pressure per lb. of inferior coal? (28)

Answers to this question were not good. The arrangement most frequently described was a chain grate stoker with forced or induced draught for a water-tube boiler, but a chain grate stoker was sometimes specified for a Lancashire boiler. The approximate weight of water to be evaporated per pound of inferior coal was often given correctly, but answers varied from 0.4 to 400 lb. Some candidates chose to describe a boiler at length, which was not called for.

(8) Describe the action of a centrifugal, or turbine, multi-stage pump in raising water. What are the various common arrangements of casing of these pumps? State the merits of each design. (28)

The mode of working of a centrifugal pump was often well stated. A weakness was the omission to say why water rises from the sump to the pump. In sketches there is a tendency to show the direction of the fixed guide vanes incorrectly in relation to the impeller vanes.

[To be continued.]


Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
27 Feb 1937  Board For Mining Examinations (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 Aug 1937  Mining Examinations, Successful Candidates (The Colliery Guardian)
14 Aug 1937  Examination Results (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Aug 1937  Notes On Surveyors' Examination, Central Examiner's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Sep 1937  May (1937) Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
09 Oct 1937  May (1937) Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print