|
28th August 1937, Page: 58, Column: 1 Notes On Surveyors' ExaminationCentral Examiner's ReportThe Question Papers set at this Examination have been published in pamphlet form and are obtainable (2s. net) from H.M. Stationery Office. The report of the Central Examiner on the examination for surveyors' certificates held in May (1937) shows that 79 candidates presented themselves for examination, and 22 qualified in the written examination. Those who qualified in the practical examination numbered 19, the percentage being 24. The percentage passes at each of the examination centres were: Edinburgh, 36.8; Newcastle, 138; Sheffield, 16; Wigan, 50; Cardiff, 12.5; Birmingham, 37.5. In his report the Examiner says that while the results were not quite up to the high standard attained at the examination held in November last, they were, on the whole, not unsatisfactory, the ultimate percentage of candidates qualifying for a certificate having rarely been equalled in past years. The percentage of candidates who obtained qualifying marks in the written part of the examination showed a reduction when compared with November last, but the percentage of failures in the oral and practical examination was less, and in consequence kept up the final qualifying figure. As a matter of fact, the percentage of failures in the oral and practical examination was the lowest yet recorded. The answers to questions set in the morning paper of the written examination did not encourage much hope of such satisfactory results being obtained, for with few exceptions they were somewhat disappointing. As it so happened, however, the work done in the afternoon generally showed marked improvement, and enabled a considerable number of candidates to make up their lost ground. In this part of the examination, Birmingham and Wigan centres had a high percentage of passes with a relatively small number of candidates, but Edinburgh, with considerably more, has well maintained the marked improvement which was a feature of the November examination. Reviewing the written part of the examination as a whole, it again falls to be stated that candidates atm show definite weakness in tackling questions out with the surveying and plotting work which no doubt forms the major part of their daily routine. There are also definite grounds for the assertion that in many instances the questions are not given sufficient careful perusal and study before the attempt to answer them is made. Comments on Answers. Below we give the text of the questions set at the examination, each question being followed by the comment of the Examiner on the work generally of the candidates. The "comments" are in italics. MORNING SESSION: (1) Compulsory Question. — The plan...., drawn to scale of 1 in. = 1,000 ft., shows certain topographical and geological details, including isopachytes lines (lines of equal strata thickness) between two certain horizons. It also shows two exploring headings in a coal seam which are approaching an unproved area, and have encountered a reversed fault. A cross-measures drift driven beyond the fault from the heading AB has proved the seam to be at a distance of 320 feet above the floor of the drift. Draw in your answer book a longitudinal section on the line AB produced, and show the probable north-easterly extension of the coal seam. Plot the horizontals of your section to the same scale as the plan, and the verticals to scale of (14) About one-third of the answers were good — a few being excellent — but the remainder were generally disappointing. The question was not a difficult one, although it may have looked so on paper, and when once the position of the Marine Band on the tine of section had been determined, the position of the underlying coat seam was easily obtained. Many candidates erred by drawing the latter seam parallel to the Marine Band. (2) Draw in your answer book, from a common centre, two circles 6 inches and 2½ inches respectively in diameter, and assume that they represent the plan — drawn to scale of 1 in. 50 ft. — of a debris heap from which the uppermost portion has been removed down to a plane parallel to and 60 feet above a level surface. It is now proposed to drive through the centre of the debris heap a road 80 feet in width with sides sloping at 2 to 1. Show on your plan by dotted line the road and the top of the slopes, and calculate the approximate quantity of debris remaining in the heap when the road is completed. (12) Answers generally were unsatisfactory. A surprisingly large number of candidates showed the top of the slopes parallel to the base of the roadway throughout the entire heap — a proceeding which a moment's reflection should have shown to be erroneous. The calculation of the volume of the remaining debris was only rarely estimated with reasonable accuracy. (3) The co-ordinates of the point of intersection of the west and south marginal lines of 25 in. Ordnance Survey sheet Blankshire XVIII. 13 are as follows :—
A point A on this sheet is situated 6,727 links N. and 11,263 links B. of the above point. The co-ordinates of a distant church spire are 47,923 links N. and 68,270 links E. from the initial point. State (a) the bearing and distance from A to the church spire in relation to the Ordnance meridian for the district; (b) the number of the sheet on which the church spire is situated; and (c) any reason known to you for the above-mentioned distances being stated in links instead of feet. (10) The solution of this question called for little beyond a knowledge of the dimensions of an Ordnance Survey Map drawn to the scale above mentioned. Even so, only about one-third of the answers were correct or approximately correct. (4) You are asked to determine as accurately as possible the position of a coal face in relation to the leasehold boundary, towards which it is approaching, by precise magnetic methods. The coal face is approximately 2,000 yards distant from the shaft, which is 500 yards in depth, and part of the roadway leading therefrom to the face is a cross-measures drift rising at 12 inches to the yard. State fully but concisely how you would carry out the work, and in particular to what parts thereof you would devote especial care. Descriptions of the method of setting and reading the instrument are not required. (8) Answers generally were satisfactory — several exceedingly so. Many candidates either ignored, or omitted to mention, the precautions which ought to have been taken in consequence of the existence of the steep cross-measures drift referred to in the question. (5) Part of a colliery leasehold has surface composed of peaty moss-highly impregnated with water — of considerable and variable thickness. Workings in a seam of coal lying at comparatively shallow depth are advancing towards that area. State, with sketches if necessary, how you would determine the extent of the area that might be worked free from the restrictions imposed by the General Regulation dealing with workings under moss, etc. (8) This question was seldom attempted, and the answers indicated that few candidates have any real knowledge of the method of procedure essential under the circumstances stated. AFTERNOON SESSION: (1) Compulsory Question. — Undernoted are certain details with regard to four traverse stations A, B, C and D situated in two different roadways in a mine.
The stations C and D are in a roadway which is being driven direct to the rise at 12 inches to the yard, and which is to be driven further ahead in the same direction and at the same gradient for a distance of 190 yards to a point E. Thereafter the roadway AB is to be driven ahead from B in the direction of AB produced, and at the gradient of AB, until it meets at a point F a level cross-measure drifts to be driven from E. Calculate the azimuth and length of the level drift EF. (14) Answers generally were good, errors for the most part being merely arithmetical. It was, however, surprising to find a large number of candidates going astray by stating that the roadway CD would rise 190 feet when it had been driven ahead 190 yards at a gradient of 12 inches to the yard. Obviously that is not so. (2) The undernoted readings were taken at the commencement of a tacheometric survey, the multiplying factor of the tacheometer being 100, and the additive constant 13 feet.
Calculate the co-ordinates and reduced level of station D, assuming station A to be the point of origin, and the reduced level thereat 657.6 feet above datum. The azimuth of AB is 205°40'. (12) This question was generally shunned. Less than one-third of the candidates who attempted it obtained a correct or approximately correct answer. (3) The plan . . . drawn to scale of 1 in. = 1,000 ft., shows surface contours at vertical intervals of 200 feet. At the point A, marked thereon a seam of coal crops out, and an exploring drift driven in the seam has proved the line of full dip to be in the direction AB. The seam has been further proved by a bore put down at the point C, shown on the plan, where it was intersected at a depth of 166 2/3 fathoms from the surface. It is proposed to sink a shaft at the point D on the plan to work the coal seam. Calculate the approximate depth at which the seam will be intersected in that shaft. (12) This comparatively simple question, which was attempted by about every candidate, was capable of easy and speedy solution by several methods. Despite that fact less than one-half of the answers were correct or even approximately correct. (4) In levelling a round of levels ABCDA it was found that B was 5.82 feet above A, C 4.70 feet above B, D 2.59 feet above C, and 13.05 feet above A. Find the probable heights of B, C, and D above A, assuming the accuracy of all the four levellings to be equal. (10) This question also puzzled many of the candidates who attempted it, rather less than 20 per cent, obtaining a correct answer. (5) In terms of Section 20 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, there is an obligation to keep in the office at the mine "an accurate plan of the workings of the mine. . . ." State what you understand is meant by the words in italics above quoted. Thereafter enumerate in tabulated form the chief sources of error in the preparation of mine plans, and state any improvements of which you are cognisant which have been made during recent years with a view to minimising such errors. (8) Answers generally were good, and indicated satisfactory knowledge of modern methods of ensuring greater accuracy in the preparation and upkeep of mine plans. (6) A heading in a coal seam rising due east at 3 inches to the yard meets a fault bearing at right angles thereto with downthrow displacement of 10 yards, measured on the hade of the fault, which is 300 from the vertical. It is known that on the east side of the fault the measures dip eastward at 4½ inches to the yard. Another seam which lies conformably below the above seam at a distance of 120 yards measured at right angles to the strata, has also been worked from west to east up to the fault. Calculate the length of the shortest cross-measures drift dipping at 9 inches to the yard which can be driven from the lower seam on the west side of the fault to win that same seam on the east side thereof. (8) Practically every candidate attempted this question, but the results were exceedingly disappointing. With very few exceptions candidates failed to observe that owing to the steeper angle of dip of the seams on the east side of the fault the extent of the displacement was greater in the lower seam than in the upper. A preliminary section drawn roughly to scale would almost certainly have made that clear.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||