|
19th June 1937, Page: 394, Column: 1 Safety In Coal MinesDust Prevention MethodsThese notes are based an the evidence and statements placed before the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines. Appointed an Inspector of Mines and Quarries in 1930, after having filled the position of Engineer to the Safety in Mines Research Board for seven years, the present duties of Captain P. S. Hay, O.B.E., fall into two parts. The first is by means of inspections to assist the divisional inspectors in the administration of the existing rules and regulations on the matter of direct prevention. The second is to carry out work with the object of improving existing methods for preventing the production and inhalation of dust, dangerous in quantity or kind, by mine and quarry workers; to visit mines and quarries, and there to study the conditions and the efficacy of existing methods and, where necessary and possible, to propose modifications for the improvement of these methods or for the trial of other methods ; when required, to advise the divisional inspectors in any matter connected with the question of dust prevention; to investigate applications made to the Chief Inspector of Mines for official approval of apparatus for dust prevention, and to collaborate with inventors in overcoming faulty design or mechanical defects of such apparatus prior to submission for formal approval. Dust Trapping Appliances. Recalling, in his statement of evidence when he appeared before the Mines Commission, that in 1924 an investigation by the S.M.R.B. was proposed to devise a method of catching the dust generated by pneumatic percussive rock drills before it escapes into the air, he said that after two years' research and experimental work he produced an appliance called a "dust trap," the general principle of which is similar to that of a domestic vacuum cleaner, the dust generated by the drill being sucked. away from the borehole and retained in a special fabric filter. In 1928 it became apparent that the appliance required redesigning so that it could more easily be applied and operated by the workers, and a new design was produced which overcame many of the difficulties. Subsequently, various types of dust traps, based on the same principle but differing in design, were evolved by various inventors in this country, among them being colliery officials and workmen. To date nine different types of dust traps have been officially approved by the Chief Inspector of Mines as alternatives to water-fed drills. The "Foam" Method. In 1930 an alternative method for dealing with the dust produced by rock drills was evolved in Germany, and developed in this country in 1932. A dense, tenacious foam is forced under pressure through the hollow drill steel of a water-fed drilling machine to the cutting edge of the drill bit, and the dust produced by boring is taken up by the foam which emerges from the borehole in the form of a thick sludge. The principal advantage of this method is that only a small quantity of liquid is required. Numbers of these appliances have been supplied, but experience has shown that the method has certain limitations due to mechanical defects. Rotary Electric Rock-drilling Machines. In 1934 a method was evolved for boring shotholes in hard rock by means of an electrically driven rotary drill. Numerous tests under working conditions at mines have shown that the fine and dangerous dust produced by this machine is negligible in quantity, and this machine has also been approved by the Chief Inspector of Mines as an alternative to water-fed drills. The use of the appliance at present is somewhat restricted, however, as the cutting hits of the drill, being constructed of a tungsten-carbide alloy, are very expensive to manufacture. Axial Water-fed Drills. Axial water-fed percussive drills have not been used to any considerable extent for dust suppression at coal mines in this country for the following reasons: (i) The conveyance of water in sufficient quantities for use with water-fed drills presents serious difficulties at some mines where the workings are a great distance from the shaft bottom. (ii) The use of water in the quantities required by a water-fed drill underground may so increase the humidity of the atmosphere of the working place as to make it uncomfortable for the men to work in. (iii) The water may seriously affect the floor of a roadway and cause "pucking" or floor lift. (iv) When boring certain hard rocks with an axial water-fed drill an excessive quantity of fine dust escapes in a dry state into the atmosphere. Research has proved that this is due to leakage of air into the water stream, and that the dust becomes trapped in air bubbles which break when they reach the surface of the water and disseminate dry dust into the atmosphere. Investigations have been carried out in this country and suitable appliances are now on the market for overcoming the difficulties by feeding the water directly to the drill steel and not through the mechanism of the drilling machine, thus eliminating any possibility of air leakage. Dust Produced by Shot-firing. The chief method for the effective removal of the dust and fumes produced by shot-firing in hard rock, particularly in hard headings or closed ends, is by auxiliary ventilation. One system is to force air through ducts or pipes and discharge it near the face of the heading, thus sweeping the dust and fumes outbye from the drift into the return air-current. Another method is to exhaust or draw the dust and fumes at or near the face through ducts or pipes and discharge them into the return air. The former method is the more usual and has proved to be the more effective. However, no standard of ventilation for dealing with dust and fumes has been prescribed, and it is often found that the auxiliary ventilation in hard headings is somewhat haphazard, and inadequate for the purpose. Trials have indicated, Captain Hay pointed out, that if from 25-30 cubic feet of air per minute for each square foot of the cross-sectional area of the face is delivered at a distance not exceeding five yards from the face, the dust and fumes produced by shot-firing are removed to a sufficient degree within ten minutes to render the conditions at the face safe for the men to return. An adjunct to auxiliary ventilation is the "mist projector," the general principle of which is as follows About two minutes before shots are fired, the heading for a distance of roughly fifteen yards from the face is filled with a dense mist or wet fog. The dust particles are thus wetted, cohere, and are quickly precipitated. Further, certain products of the combustion of the explosive are dissolved by the mist and rendered harmless. In order to accelerate the action of the wet mist upon nitrous fumes, which are acid in nature, the mist is rendered slightly alkaline by adding a small quantity of common washing soda to the water from which the mist is formed. Some hundreds of these "mist projectors" are in use at coal mines throughout the country and tests in hard headings have shown that over 80 per cent. of the dust produced by shot-firing can be effectively suppressed close to the source of production, and that the products of combustion of the explosive have been to a considerable extent neutralised and rendered harmless. Another design of "mist projector" has been evolved by Mr. C. Wetherall, the manager of Florence (haematite) Mine. In this case a small quantity of castor oil is atomised with the mist, with the idea of reducing the surface tension of the water particles and forming a thin layer of oil over the wet precipitated dust, and so retarding evaporation and consequent reversion of the wetted dust to a dry state. The "mist projector" method, as so far developed, can be applied only in confined spaces such as drifts. Investigations are, however, in progress to extend the method to deal with the dust and fumes produced by shot-firing in rippings. Conveyors and Coal-cutter Dusts. Heavy concentrations of fine coal dust are often present in the atmosphere at loading points of conveyors. Experiments are in progress with different systems such as drawing the dust away from the source by a fan, through piping, and the filtration of the dust-laden air by a fabric or other type of filter; or, by removing the dust as above described and dealing with it by the "mist projector" method. Encouraging results have already been obtained, but the matter must be regarded as still in the experimental stage. The heavy concentrations of dust which are thrown into the atmosphere by coal-cutters in some seams have also been investigated. It has been found that by increasing the haulage speed and slightly decreasing the speed of the cutter chain a marked improvement can be obtained. Surface Plant Dusts. The question of dealing with the large quantities of dust produced at tippling and screening plants has received considerable attention, in particular at anthracite mines in South Wales. The extracted dust is conveyed to large chambers into which saturated steam is discharged, which converts the dry dust into slurry. At some mines the effective suppression of dust has proved to be a formidable problem owing to the straggling nature of the screening plant and equipment, but the difficulties are being overcome with consequent improvement in the conditions. Dust Respirators. A satisfactory form of dust respirator is necessary to safeguard workers against dust inhalation when other measures are not practicable or as an alternative form of protection. A survey having been made of the dust conditions underground at coal mines, experimental respirators were tested under practical working conditions. The result is a satisfactory appliance which has an extremely high filtering efficiency combined with low breathing resistance and which is comfortable to wear for long periods under adverse conditions underground. It is anticipated that this respirator will be placed on the market during the next few months. Meanwhile several designs of respirator produced by private enterprise are already available, and some of these have attained a creditable standard of efficiency. Conclusions. For the protection of the men engaged on rock work underground at coal mines, the following recommendations are made by Captain Hay :— (a) Dry Drilling. — When dry-drilling in rock with pneumatic percussive drilling machines, either with or without a dust trap, no drills should be used which allow air to pass down a hollow drill steel. Solid drill steels with spirals should be used for clearing the dust from the borehole, or, alternatively, it should be removed by a suitable scraper. (b) Wet Drilling. — When wet-boring by means of axial water feed, the passing of water through the drilling machine should be avoided and the water be fed directly into the drill steel. (c) Support of Drilling Machine. — All drilling machines should be supported to relieve the operator of the weight of the machine. This can be effected by means of a simple adjustable crutch or a compressed-air operated telescopic support. (d) Ventilation for the Dispersal of Dust Clouds. — Adequate and effective ventilation should be provided at all places, particularly in hard headings or closed ends where men are working. (e) Mist Projectors. — In hard headings such ventilation should be supplemented by the use of "mist projectors" during shot-firing operations. (f) Loading Rock Debris. — All loose dry rock debris should be thoroughly wetted before removal, or alternatively the men engaged in removing it should be provided with efficient dust respirators. Need for Co-ordination. Replying to members of the Commission Captain Hay thought it was highly desirable that all work in relation to dust prevention should be co-ordinated, and it would be better if it could be centralised. All the research and experimental work in relation to dust preventive devices is scattered about all over the country. There are bits of it being done at universities, some by manufacturers, and a great deal by colliery managers and colliery engineers, but there is no co-ordination. Nobody has very much knowledge of what the other man is doing. He added: "I am basing my opinions on what I saw in Germany. The question of silicosis prevention there is tackled jointly by what would be the equivalent of the men's representatives, and what would be the equivalent of the Mine Owners' Research Association here, and the Government. They are all inter-locked, and they work at one central station. They have a staff of chemists, physicists, mechanical engineers, and mining engineers, who are in close touch with the Government inspectorate the whole time, so that you have a centralisation there which I think is admirable. I would suggest that, if we had properly co-ordinated research on the development of preventive measures against silicosis, it should very closely follow up the question of the causative factors. For all we know to-day, these various dust preventive measures that I have described may be useless because we have not sufficient knowledge. The medical experts have not told us yet exactly the degree of protection that we have to afford to the men. If we could get enlightenment as to the causative factors, we engineers can produce the antidotes; but until we know what the cause is we are groping in the dark." Captain Hay thinks that the respirator would give as good protection as the other preventive measures, but the respirator only gives individual protection. The dust trap and other methods prevent the dissemination of dust into the atmosphere. If a man was working with a respirator and producing quantities of fine dust, he would be protected, but that fine dust would he carried to other places where men might breathe it, who were not provided with respirators. He would never advocate the use of a respirator as a preventive measure, but merely as a second line of defence where the dust suppression methods could not he applied.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||