|
13th April 1937 Silicosis?Cleator Moor InquestsMedical Evidence At VarianceTwo inquests, held consecutively at Cleator Moor on Tuesday, were of particular interest to iron ore miners, in view of recent legislation regarding silicosis. Both concerned iron ore miners who had developed lung trouble which terminated fatally, and the only evidence produced at the adjourned inquests was that of Dr. J. H. Faulds, pathologist, of Carlisle, who conducted post-mortem examinations. That evidence was of a technical character, and had to be explained to the jury; and the verdicts in each case were not in accordance with customary form. The first inquest concerned the death on March 16th of John Graffin (60), iron ore miner, of 68, Queen St, Cleator Moor, and in respect of the post-mortem examination, Dr. Faulds said the body was well nourished. There was none of the characteristic red colouring associated with the lungs of an iron ore miner, but there were small lumps containing pus. The heart muscle was very weak, and the ultimate cause of death was degeneration of the heart muscle. There was none of the characteristics of silicosis and the affection of the lungs was a low grade chronic pneumonia. Death was due to this cause associated with heart failure. In answer to Mr. W. J. Lowery (representing the relatives), Dr. Faulds said there were some fine crystals of silica, and the low general condition of the lungs might have been a contributory factor in causing death. Mr. Lowery said that the Silicosis Board had given a certificate that Graffin was suffering from silicosis, and compensation was paid. Now it was said that he was not suffering from silicosis. Dr. Faulds explained that silicosis was very strictly defined legally, and he had to be very careful in using terms. The certificate given by the Silicosis Board was "fibrosis" of the lungs. A mild degree of silicosis might be a contributory cause of death. A percentage of 0.1 silica in the lungs was quite normal; in this case the percentage was 0.93. Mr. H. Bailiff (representing the Barrow Hematite Steel Co. Ltd.): Was the whole of the lungs affected with this silica? Dr. Francis: No, The silica was concentrated in two nodules. Egremont Doctor's Evidence Dr. B. Mitchell, called by Mr. Lowery, said that Dr. Faulds was a pathologist; he was a general practitioner, and over a long period of years he found that a man who followed the occupation of iron ore mining took a great deal longer time to recover than a man who was not a miner when lung trouble developed. He was perfectly satisfied by his own experience that the presence of iron ore dust in the lungs was a factor which definitely did retard recovery in lung conditions. They had many iron ore miners who had died from pleurisy and minor lung conditions who, had they not been miners, ought not to have died. He would say that the mild degree of silicosis would contribute to the cause of death, not "might contribute." This man had had a long and protracted illness. After a retirement of ten minutes the Jury returned a verdict of "Death from pneumonia accelerated by following his employment as a miner." Second Verdict The adjourned inquest on William Graham (63), iron ore miner, of 35, Trumpet Road, Cleator, who died on March 15th, was then proceeded with. The Coroner, Major W. T. Highet, said the cause of death given on the death certificate was :— (1) Tuberculosis of the lungs; (2) Silicosis of the lungs. The reference to silicosis made necessary a post-mortem examination. Dr. Faulds again explained his report to the jury. He said that in this case there was 2.1 percent of silica in the lungs. The body was very emaciated, there was advance fibrosis of the lung, and there was evidence of tuberculosis. The cause of death was massive fibrosis of the lungs associated with silica and hematite. The tuberculosis was confirmed on subsequent examination, but was not advanced. After a short retirement the Jury found a verdict of "Death from silicosis in accordance with his own doctor's report."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||