27th March 1937, Page: 299, Column: 1
Controlling Spoil Heap Fires
A paper on "Treatment Applied to Control a Colliery Spoil
Heap Fire" was presented before the Manchester Geological and
Mining Society on 9th March by Mr. Herbert Price, B.Sc. He
said many attempts have been made to extinguish, or to control
colliery spoil heap fires, and only in a few instances have such
attempts been successful. A colliery spoil heap consists of a
mixture of many kinds of material, the bulk of which is combustible.
The size of the material varies from the finest dust
to lumps, and the mass of the heap is frequently high and extensive.
The heterogeneous mass has every chance of developing
spontaneous combustion unless measures are taken, either to
encourage complete oxidation by exposure to air for a sufficient
length of time, or to prevent oxidation by efficiently sealing it to
exclude the entire access of air. Both these measures present
difficulties at most collieries.
The first heating of a spoil heap does not always commence in
the material most recently put down; a heap may be quiet for
a long period of time, extensions to it having proceeded in the
meantime, and the heating be first evident in a section considered
to be solid and spent. The preliminary heating usually occurs
near to an open side, and it is feasible that the risk of a fire commencing
increases directly as the perimeter of the heap, provided
that its depth or thickness is such that the heat generated by the
oxidation is prevented from escaping.
Usual methods applied to arrest a fire are: Treating with water
externally, or internally, covering with some incombustible
material as flue dust, clay, slag dust, or sand, or with waste
material such as washery dirt. The forcing of cement grout by
the methods used in cementation has been tried with success on
fires which have been under colliery buildings.
With reference to the particular case discussed Mr. Price
explained that a danger requiring immediate attention was the
cause leading to a method of treatment successful beyond expectations.
The treatment is simply the flooding of the interior
of the hot, or burning, spoil heap with water and limestone dust.
The method of application is very simple, all that is necessary
being a supply of water flowing at four to twelve gallons per
minute, a number of 8-inch diameter tubes of varying lengths
up to 8 feet, at least one of which has a number of 1-inch diameter
holes drilled in its sides, a tundish and a good supply of limestone
dust. As mentioned, water alone will put out a fire when applied
internally, but of itself is suspected of being responsible for
introducing conditions leading to subsequent trouble. The
limestone dust carried in by the water acts as a preventive of the
sequellae of water alone. So long as the water is flowing, some of
the limestone travels with it, but on the water becoming still,
or just filtering through a mass such as shale, the limestone is
deposited. The deposit fills up the cavities in the heap, and
surrounds all the particles that the water is able to encircle. The
action of limestone in the form in which it is deposited in the spoil
heap is primarily physical, it having both a cooling and blanketing
effect, thus limiting or preventing oxidation.
The heap on which it was ultimately decided to use limestone
dust covered an area of approximately 74,600 square yards. Mr.
Price explained that the first indication of heating occurred in
January, 1933, and it was not until September, 1936, that any
buildings began to be affected, when heating under the saw shed
became apparent. In the vicinity of the saw shed were the timber
stocks and means were taken of safeguarding these. Having
described the various measures of dealing with this particular
case, Mr. Price submitted the appended general observations
(1) Where there is a spoil heap fire, the existence of cavities
can be assumed with certainty. As proof of this, rods put down
following the outbreak which occurred early in 1936, kept under
by covering with slag dust, revealed a cavity under the wagon
roads. This was opened out, and the cavity found 4 feet down,
about 15 feet in diameter and 4 feet high at its most open part.
The sides and bottom of this cavity were hot, but there was no
actual fire.
(2) Water alone will extinguish a fire, but after a time may be
instrumental in causing another.
(3) Covering the surface of a spoil heap with slag dust does
not prevent fire from starting, nor from travelling. Slag dust
sets fairly solid, and easily cracks with the heat, allowing gases
to escape and air to enter.
(4) Limestone dust and water treatment has effectively extinguished
fires in conditions favourable to the further propagation
of combustion.
(5) The treatment is easily applied into the heart of a fire, the
mixture flowing readily into all available cavities, and settling
rapidly when its flow is retarded or stopped.
(6) The extent to which the mixture will penetrate the heap
is dependent upon the available cavity area; if the heap is open,
as would be the case with actual fire, the penetration will be greater
than in the case of primary heating.
(7) The chemical reactions of the mixture under the conditions
occurring in spoil heap fires are preventive of the further propagation
of combustion, and minimise the nuisance consequent to
fires.
(8) An excavation in a section of fire treated has shown that the
dust settled in all the spaces between the dirt, and completely
filled a cavity which had existed.
(9) The water used in the treatment eventually gets away,
but it has not been possible to trace its course.
(10) The cost of the treatment compares favourably with
other injection methods.
(11) No special plant, or trained labour, is required.
(12) There is nothing deleterious to the health of the workmen
employed in applying the treatment.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Price, Herbert | | | |