27th March 1937, Page: 293, Column: 2
Silicosis Ruling
A decision was given by the House of Lords on Monday, 15th
March, clarifying the position respecting compensation for
silicosis.
Two miners, Maurice Wragg, of Stocksbridge, Sheffield, and
Herbert Charlesworth, of Deepcar, near Sheffield, who had contracted
silicosis while driving through mudstone, and not silica
rock, in a Stocksbridge coal mine, had claimed compensation,
which was granted in the county court, but reversed in the Court
of Appeal on the ground that the employers were protected by
a proviso in the 1931 scheme because the workmen had not been
exposed to the dust of silica rock. The court held that the amendment
scheme of 1934 adding the words "any operation underground
in any coal mine" to the list of processes covered should
be inserted before the provision of limiting cases to silica rock.
The House of Lords now found that the words were meant
to go at the end of the list, and were not governed by the
restriction. Lord Thankerton said that since 1925 the Secretary
of State had plainly followed the policy by cautious steps of
adding to the processes to which compensation for silicosis applied.
The appeal of the miners would be allowed with costs. Lord Russell
of Killowen and Lord Roche concurred.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Charlesworth, Herbert | | Miner | |
| Roche, —, Lord | | | |
| Russell, —, Lord | | | |
| Thankerton, —, Lord | | | |
| Wragg, Maurice | | Miner | |