|
13th February 1937, Page: 241, Column: 1 Safety In Coal MinesMore About SilicosisThese notes are based on the evidence and statements of witnesses appearing before the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines. Dermatitis. The evidence submitted by Dr. S. W. Fisher, given in part in last issue (page 228), was not purely medical and further reference may interest readers of this journal. Asked if he had anything special to say about dermatitis or other diseases. Dr. Fisher mentioned that dermatitis cases are roughly of two classes, the one which comprises the greater number being cases that happen in deep hot mines where there is a high wet-bulb temperature. In these hot mines excessive sweating seems to irritate the skin. Owing to the irritation the men tend to scratch their skin, and that infects the primary areas of irritation, causing a general rash. Other cases have been attributed to water containing a good proportion of saline matter, which either drops from the roof on to the men's shoulders — it will be understood that in these hot mines the men are practically stripped — and drying there irritates the skin as salt water will; or, in other cases, it is attributed to water on the floor of the mine which, during their work, has been splashed on to their legs and again causes irritation. Those are more or less cases of so-called dermatitis producing a general rash. Then there have been others, few in number, where the cause has been attributed to handling various substances in the mine. In a few cases it was attributed to the handling of powder, but Dr. Fisher has never been quite satisfied that the powder actually did cause the dermatitis. It is really a matter for a skin specialist. Object of Silicosis Inquiry. Attention being drawn to the distribution of the cases of silicosis in the various divisions Dr. Fisher said the preponderance of cases in South Wales is a question of great complexity. A large number of investigators and research workers has studied the subject recently, but with no definite final conclusions. Many causes have been suggested, but none actually fits the whole of the cases seen and dealt with. So much so that the Pulmonary Diseases Committee of the Medical Research Council is now taking up the subject, and with the approval of the Medical Research Council itself, will begin a very large and thorough scheme of inquiry. The object of the investigation is to obtain information under various headings at selected coal mines. By selected coal mines he means mines from which many cases have been reported. Also investigations will be made at other mines near by. Strange to relate, quite close to a mine from which a lot of cases come, one finds a mine where things seem to be similar on a superficial examination, and yet from which no cases are reported. The first heading of investigation would be "Medical." Under that medical investigation would be all the sub-divisions appertaining to a medical examination of the problem. Then another heading is "Occupational." A third heading is "Radiological," which becomes a question of X-rays in the examination of silicotics and is rather complicated, especially in South Wales. Then there is the question of the diagnosis of the disease — actually being able to say whether it is silicosis, or, if it is a disabling dust disease which is not silicosis, what exactly it is. That is another important matter for South Wales. Then there is the question of pathological investigations. That means that every patient they can possibly get that can be examined pathologically will be so examined. This of course means a whole team of specialised workers, clinicians, radiologists, pathologists ; various Government Departments concerned, the Home Office and the Mines Department, and of course the owners and workmen, will all have to take their share as far as the Council can see in this. With that reservation, many causes have been suggested. Mr. Ashley in his evidence, in answer to the question: "Then it is true there are more shots fired in the anthracite ?" says: "Yes." That would perhaps suggest that there was more exposure to possible fumes from explosives, and concentrated dust in confined places. Others explain it in various ways; for instance, through men getting chilled when they are being brought outbye, or because there is an individual susceptibility among the people who live in these districts. Others have various views as to something in the rock causing it, and so on. Spakes May Aggravate Condition. The question of spakes is of course one of the things which would be carefully examined by the Pulmonary Diseases Committee, but Dr. Fisher says, with the reservation that this is his own personal opinion, that the figures that have been brought forward by various writers do certainly show that there is a connection between the riding out on spakes and the incidence of silicosis. Whether the riding out on spakes, which is undoubtedly a chilling process, is a predisposing cause, or whether as he is inclined to consider, it brings on a catarrhal condition which aggravates the existing dust condition, and thus brings on symptoms earlier and more pronounced than otherwise they would be, he does not quite know. That is more or less his opinion. These men coming out on spakes get chilled, and that brings on what you may call an ordinary bronchitic and catarrhal condition, and naturally if their lungs are impaired, it is going to aggravate their condition. But that is a question that will be taken very carefully into consideration by the investigation that is proposed by the Pulmonary Diseases Committee. As a rule what happens is this. The men come from their working places and gather at the bottom of the slant. There they wait until the spake is ready to come up. When the spake comes up the slant it takes anything up to 20 minutes to do so. Usually they are coming up against the intake air, which naturally in cold weather is very cold, and one knows by experience that it is a definitely chilling process likely to bring on a cough or a cold. Asked how could men be best protected from cold in a spake? Would wind screens be sufficient ? — Dr. Fisher thinks that, as suggested by Professor T. D. Jones in his paper, individual covering is more important than general covering over the spake. It is a matter as to which is practical, the witness thought. A waterproof or windproof covering would really do what is necessary. He means that it is not necessary to have heavy clothes, or heavy coats, but something that would not allow the wind to get through. That, however, is purely a suggestion. Effects of Nitrous Fumes. Dealing with the point that fumes from shot-firing may affect the lungs in such a way as to render a man liable to sillcosis, Dr. Fisher said work has been done by medical men in the Banting Institute in Toronto which has shown that small quantities of nitrous fumes inhaled regularly over a long period have an effect, in this way. If silica dust is inhaled together with or after the inhalation of small quantities of nitrous fumes, damage can be done to the bronchial tubes. Witness thought he might put it in this way: As far as he can see nitrous fumes have three effects. One is a chronic local effect. Very minute percentages in the atmosphere will so impair the bronchial tubes which have such a great deal to do with the elimination, of dust, that the dust is apt to be retained, and therefore do harm. The other effect of nitrous fumes of which he has experience is what he calls the acute local effect that is to say, the effect of a larger percentage of nitrous fumes in the air. A man breathes this in and gets a slight irritation of what are known as the mucous membranes (i.e., anything that is not skin-eyes, nose and throat). This is transitory and passes off, and the man may not attach much importance to it; but later on, perhaps an hour afterwards, or perhaps three or four hours afterwards, he gets a very acute and serious congestion or oedema of the lungs. Those are the local chronic and local acute effects. Then nitrous oxide fumes also have an effect which is not local but generalised. They act on the heart and depress the circulation, and also impair the oxygen-carrying capacity of the blood. That is why the local pulmonary effect of nitrous fumes is dangerous. The general effect lowers the resistance. Questioned as regards the drafting of new regulations, Sir Malcolm Delevingne asking if he was correct in thinking it is the very fine dust in the air that causes the damage, Dr. Fisher agreed; It is the very fine dust of whatever kind. He means by that, it does not matter what type of dust it is. All people do not agree as to that, but it is generally agreed that the dust must be fine, to the order of one or two, or certainly less than ten microns. It follows, he agreed, that any preventive measures which do not deal with the very fine dust are either useless or at any rate inadequate for the purpose of preventing dust disease. He would agree that dust prevention is important in mines where silica is involved. Dealing with Dust. "Do you think enough is being done in the way of dust prevention in mines ? "That is an embarrassing question. One has to wait — it certainly Is a source of delay — for the preventive equipment or apparatus which one would desire to be fully developed and placed on the market. What I mean is this: Take dust respirators, for instance. The Mines Department are desirous of issuing regulations which will tighten up this question of the inhalation of various dusts. A great deal of those regulations depends on the existence of a proper respirator. I mean one which can be worn by the man with comfort and with goodwill, and yet offer no disadvantages such as resistance to breathing, or local irritation to the face where it is worn-a thing which respirators so often do. I understand Captain Hay will tell you more about this, but I may say that although such a respirator seems to have been approved, and seems to have undergone very careful tests, and to have come out of those tests satisfactorily, yet I understand it is not yet on the market. It is not a commercial proposition. Obviously regulations cannot be made requiring people to have men wearing respirators when working in various parts of the mine if the respirator is not easily available on the market. The same thing applies in a lesser degree to an apparatus called a mist-projector, which is a very useful apparatus in confined places for allaying the dust following shot-firing, and not only the dust but the fumes about which we have been speaking which combine with water and come down on to the men. Until those two things are generally available to the whole industry, the regulations are held up." "What are the places in a mine which in your opinion require most attention in this matter of the prevention of inhalation of dangerous dust ? "Obviously one of the most important places is where they are using high-power drills in rock containing a high percentage of free silica, because that is a direct danger in any mine. Then wherever large concentrations of dust in a mine are made, those are obviously places where something should be done. Take the loading end of a conveyor. It is universally the case that the loading end of a conveyor is a very dusty place, but in some cases I have seen it is extremely dusty, and the dust is extremely fine, and one would think the workers should be protected at such a place. At other times one sees the coal coming off the conveyor belt into the tubs with very little dust. I assume that it depends a good deal on the nature of the coal. "Would that be almost entirely coal dust ? "Yes. Then other places where dust may be sent out in large quantities are where a machine coal-cutter is working. There again the quantity of dust differs. At times one sees a coal-cutter working without a terrific lot of dust, but at other times one sees a lot of dust. I believe that by adjusting the speed at which the coal-cutter works or by selecting the type of coal-cutter, the amount of dust may be modified in these cases. Then again when a person is boring in a ripping, if no precautions are taken a good deal of dust is let out into the general atmosphere. Those are the places where obviously a great deal of dust is produced. "Owing to the air-current the dust does not all settle at the place at which it is produced, but in part is carried along through the workings of the mine? "Yes, but if the dust is liberated into a roadway where there is a good air-current I should not myself think that the danger to the workers is great. It is in the case of high concentrations of dust in confined spaces where men cannot avoid breathing in a good deal of dust. In such places, no matter what the dust is, I think, it cannot do the men anything but a certain amount of damage, especially if those men have suffered at some time of their life, perhaps as a child, from some illness which has affected the lungs, perhaps an early tuberculosis or bronchial pneumonia, or something like that, which has in some way impaired the eliminating power of the lungs."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||