2nd January 1937, Page: 202, Column: 1
Machine Mining In Northumberland And Durham
By A. C. Moonie
Extracts from paper presented at meeting on 12th December of
the North of England institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers.
To illustrate the range of machine mining in the two counties details
were submitted of seven examples in the Low Main, Five Quarter,
Busty, Maudlin, Harvey and Beaumont Seams.
Machine mining in Northumberland and Durham has made
tremendous strides in the past ten years, and the application of
coal-cutters and conveyors in suitable conditions coupled with the
use of steel supports' and better knowledge of roof control, have
made possible results which were only dreamed of ten years ago.
The amount of coal cut has been almost trebled in that period,
and is now almost 24½ million tons, or 52½ per cent. of the total
output. The amount of coal conveyed has also been enormously
increased in that period, and is now over 11½ million tons, or 25.3
per cent. of the total output. Coal-cutters have increased in
number from 632 to 1,414, and conveyers from 136 to 913.
During the past ten years the mining industry has passed through
a period of strain, worry, and continual anxiety, and while the
struggle is by no means over, there is evidence in the swelling
volume of world trade which gives hope that the worst is passed.
Coal-cutters.
To keep pace with better organisation and methods of working
at the coal-face there was a need for improved coal-face machinery,
and this has not been lacking. Praiseworthy attempts have been
made to solve the problem of combined cutting and loading. In
one case the arrangement is an adaptation of the ordinary long
wall machine with a loader attached. In another case the machine
is fitted with three jibs ; one jib under-cutting, another over-cutting,
and the third jib slicing the whole seam off at the back
of the cut. In the first case the coal is cut going one way and
loaded by the conveyor coming the other way. In the second
case the cutting and loading are done in one operation. They have
met with moderate success, but difficulties have been encountered
with roof control and the preparation of the coal for convenient
handling.
The application of coal-cutters has not undergone any radical
change. The average depth of cut on longwall faces has increased
slightly, and is generally 4½-5 ft. There are odd cases of faces
cut up to 6 ft., and at least one case where the cut is 8 ft. deep on
a longwall face working in conjunction with conveyers. The
average yardage cut per machine has increased, and it is not
uncommon for machines to cut faces 160-200 yards long every
day. The ordinary undercutting of seams is well understood,
but it is becoming increasingly necessary to work seams with
dirt-bands intersecting the coal, or seams with ramble between
the seam and the roof. To get the largest percentage of clean
coal it is a problem sometimes whether to cut in the band or
immediately below or above it. Where the hand is friable it is
generally best to cut it out and goaf the cuttings before filling
commences. Where the band is hard and strong it is sometimes
better to cut immediately above or below the coal. In the former
case, the top coal would be cleaned off, the band next, and the
bottom coal last. In the latter case, the process would be
reversed. In some instances it is best to cut out a ramble on
top of the coal so that the clearing away of. the dirt will be a
separate operation from the coal filling. Overcutting longwall
machines have been successfully applied cutting up to a height
of 7 ft. from the floor.
The bord-and-pillar method of working with arcwallers or
universal heading-machines is used to a greater extent in Northumberland
and Durham than elsewhere, due largely to the amount
of coal under property. The cutting of bord-and-pillar places
with arcwallers was first attempted in this district about 15 years
ago, and since then arcwallers have fulfilled a very useful function
in the more efficient production of output from bord-and-pillar
workings. Universal heading-machines which are arcwallers
designed to give a vertical shear in addition to a horizontal cut,
fill a small but useful place in machine mining. There are about
250 arcwallers and universal heading-machines in use in Northumberland
and Durham.
Conveyors.
During the period under review much progress has been made
in the design of belt-conveyers. This has been mainly in the
direction of protection of the bottom belt, making provision to
avoid spillage, and in the construction of the framework to facilitate
dismantling and rebuilding each shift. In one type of conveyor
the orthodox practice has been reversed, and the coal is conveyed
on the bottom belt while the return belt is carried near the roof.
In some cases the dimensions of the driving gear have been greatly
reduced by incorporating the motor inside the width of the gear.
head, thereby reducing congestion at the loading point. A good
deal of attention has been given also to belt wrap and the arrangement
of drums so as to reduce belt tension as much as possible.
With the improvement in design and the increased durability
and strength of belting some remarkable results have been achieved
with mothergate conveyers. Outputs of 300, 400, and 500 tons
per shift from double-unit faces being handled at one loading
station are not uncommon in Northumberland and Durham,
and there is at least one case where 730 tons are loaded every
day in two shifts from one trunk-belt conveyor. There is one
ease of a trunk-belt conveyor working up to 1,250 yards long with
one driving head, but it was found that 800 yards was the limit
in order to ensure a reasonable life from the belting. In some
cases where the crush on roadways is excessive it is found that
300-400 yards is the most suitable distance, and the lay-out is
arranged in panels to suit this distance.
Shaker conveyers have done yeoman service for many years,
but latterly they have been largely superseded by belts, especially
in the North of England where the seams are undulating. Where
the seams have a definite gradient there is still a large amount
of work done with shaker-conveyers on the rise side of double
units and also with conveyers in tandem and the mothergate at
the bottom end of the face instead of in the middle. Where the
gradient is small and regular they are sometimes used on both sides
of a double-unit face laid out on the strike of the seam and delivering
into a gate-end loader or mothergate belt-conveyor.
There have been no outstanding changes in the design of shaker-conveyers,
but there have been changes in detail in the method
of fastening the lengths of troughing together and in the support
of the troughing. Ball frames, roller paths, and small wheels
are in use for supporting the troughing.
The Blackett scraper-chain conveyor, which was the first
conveyor used underground in this country, is still used to a certain
extent and has given good service in the past. It has certain
advantages over other types of conveyers in wet conditions.
The scraper-conveyor of the box type has been much in evidence
in recent years, and has given some excellent service in thin seams.
It is limited in capacity and is used mostly in seams under 2 ft.
in thickness. It has advantages from the point of view of easy
filling and ease in moving over.
Organisation of Conveyors.
The successful operation of machine mining required the most
carefully thought-out organisation with skilled and constant
supervision. The best results are obtained where there is an
official in charge whose whole time is occupied in looking after a
district of a limited size, such as a double-unit face.
The operations of cutting, shot-firing, filling, ripping, packing,
timbering, and moving forward conveyers, are performed in a
sequence of co-ordinated operations, the whole cycle being completed
in 24 hours, and a constant output being obtained from a
definite length of face. It is essential that the coal filling should
be done in one shift to allow time to complete the other Operations
necessary in the 24-hour cycle. The greatest danger is in attempting
to fill a greater output than the system can handle comfortably
in a shift. To allow for stoppages of various kinds it is wise to
arrange an output that can be filled in less than the full time
available at the face.
Where large outputs are being handled, continuity of operation
is of the utmost importance, as the loss of one day's output is a
serious matter, and the greatest care must be exercised to ensure
that there are no serious stoppages. With the excellent face
machinery of various types now available, mechanical breakdowns
can be reduced to a minimum by systematic supervision. In
normal conditions, adequate and rigidly systematic roof control
will prevent falls of roof on the face. In the majority of cases,
faces are carried forward for long periods without a hitch except
where faults appear, and these cannot be foreseen. Much experience
and skill in dealing with faults on conveyor faces have
been acquired in recent years, and where these do not exceed
the thickness of the seam they seldom cause any interruption or
difficulty beyond the grading for the machinery, and the extra
care of the roof required in the vicinity. Larger faults are a serious
matter as they cause either sudden or gradual diminution of
output from the face, and may necessitate the transference of the
plant to another face as quickly as possible in order to restore
output.
Roof Control.
The successful working of conveyor faces is impossible without
an efficient system of roof control. So far, no accurate system
of rules has been defined to say what system of roof control will
give the best results in any particular set of conditions. This is
largely a matter of experiment and observation, and would seem
to indicate that in most seams any one of several arrangements
would be equally successful. The most commonly used arrangements
of roof control are: (1) Wood or steel props and straps;
(2) Wood or steel supports with chocks; (3) Wood or steel supports
with packs; (4) Wood or steel supports with chocks and packs.
In the case of wood props and straps these are generally used
where the cutting is done in the floor or in a band in the seam,
and where cuttings have to be cast back into the goaf. The
efficient recovery of steel props and straps in such instances is
extremely difficult and costly, and puts the use of them out of the
question. If there is a soft floor in addition, their use is rendered
impossible owing to the fact that they are sunk in the floor as
well as half buried in the cuttings.
In the case of steel props and straps without the assistance of
chocks or packs, successful results are obtained where the roof
and floor are hard, and the roof breaks off behind the steel supports
with every cut and where the weight is not excessive. The back
line of props is generally strengthened with extra props and lids
between the straps to stiffen the breaking-off line. This arrangement
of roof control is often used where the roof is composed of
bands of soft sandstone, which breaks off readily.
Chocks are often necessary, in addition to steel or wood props
and straps, in order to strengthen support where the roof is heavy
and of a bending nature and breaks only occasionally or after
every two or three cuts. Chock-releasing devices have done much
in recent years to facilitate the withdrawal of chocks, both from
the point of view of safety and cost.
The use of packs is a necessary and widely used factor in roof
control in conjunction with the use of steel or wooden supports,
and they have in many cases improved the roof conditions after
their introduction. The use of goaf packs is more general in
seams from 2½ ft. upwards. The experience with packs would
seem to indicate that while the timber provides a support for the
roof immediately above the coal, the packs provide a support or
cushion for the upper roof. To build packs it is necessary to use
broken roof fallen in the goaf, and for this reason the packs must
be near enough together to give the support necessary and still
far enough apart to enable the roof to break down between the
packs. The distance between the packs is a matter of experiment
and is easily arrived at. In odd cases it may be necessary to fire
shots in the roof between the packs to get the roof to commence
breaking.
In the hardest and strongest of post roofs it may be necessary,
in order to provide packs and achieve control, to carry dummy
roads in the goaf. These are kept open only from the face end,
and a top canch is drilled and fired every cut and the stone packed
in the sides as in an ordinary gate-road. Only the loose stone
is taken down from the sides for safety and no attempt is made
to square back the sides. This may seem expensive, but there is
no alternative in seams working longwall, as to leave such a roof
without packs means that it will break only once a week or once
a fortnight, and then it will break over the coal with serious results.
A roof of this kind is usually a splendid roof in bord-and-pillar
working, but it often means the loss of much coal in pillars when
it takes a break.
The foregoing notes on roof control are by no means arbitrary,
and there are many who will not agree with some of the conclusions
stated, but they may be taken as nearly correct as it is possible
to be, in general, dealing with a subject in which there are never
two sets of conditions exactly alike.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Moonie, A. C. | | | |