|
24th October 1936, Page: 120, Column: 2 Safety In Coal MinesViews of Firemen's AssociationsThese notes are based on the evidence and statements of witnesses appearing before the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines. In his evidence on behalf of the General Federation of Colliery Firemen's, Examiners' and Deputies' Associations of Great Britain, Mr. W. Frowen, O.B.E., informed the Commission that the approximate membership is between 14,000 and 15,000. He proceeded to say that the installation of machinery for getting and conveying coal has made it imperative that the size of deputies' districts should be limited, the suggestion being that no district should be of such a size that it cannot be inspected within 1¼ hours. The rapid exposure of roof where coal has been cut by machinery and is filled on to conveyors (and the men's jobs are definitely to fill coal) requires almost constant supervision and attention by the deputy in charge, and breaks in the roof are frequent, requiring special care in packing, stacking, and the withdrawal of timber from wastes. The Federation is also of the opinion that three inspections should be made instead of two as at present. They believe that all inspections should be made with a flame safety-lamp, in every coal mine, whether inflammable gas has been found or not. It is definitely a greater measure of safety. The Federation is agreed that Section 68 (d) should be amended to read "every 24 hours," instead of "every week." It is imperative that airways should be constantly under examination in view of past serious accidents and the greater emission of firedamp in machine-mined faces. Deputies' Obligations. With reference to the fulfilling of the legal obligations put upon him, the view was expressed that Section 67 of the Act places a deputy in a delicate position affecting not only the economic position of his employer, but that of the workmen as well, whose earnings are cut off if and when a working place or district is found dangerous or when danger is apprehended, and many deputies have hesitated to take steps they otherwise would have done when dangerous conditions were apparent, while in many instances others have found themselves on the road dismissed. Proposals to provide against unjust dismissals were submitted to the Commission, and Mr. Frowen added that they are aware that Section 14 (2) provides for appealing to the divisional inspector in the case of a deputy's district being of such a size that he cannot carry out his statutory duties, or that other duties imposed on him prevent him from carrying out his statutory obligations but this fails in so much that to get this assistance it has to be carried out in secret to a very large extent and deputies have found themselves on the road either by being later declared to be incompetent, or by a temporary reduction of staff. Hours of Work and Overtime. Having expressed the view that the conditions of employment of deputies should be investigated by the Commission, Mr. Frowen said the Federation has from time to time pressed upon the Mines Department the need for strictly limiting the hours of deputies by a hank-to-bank limit. The strenuousness of the work both mentally and physically requires that the Commission should take this view and make recommendations to this effect. Tired men are not in the condition to notice or apprehend danger and where it is necessary to have inspections requiring longer hours, four shifts of deputies should be established. This would do away with the vexed question of overtime. The inquiries into the complaint against overtime undertaken by the Mines Department both in Lancashire and Scotland showed that at least there was ground for complaint; if the investigation is continued it will be found prevalent in most other coalfields, especially where machinery is used for coal-cutting and conveying. That overtime is not in the interest of safety has been emphasised from time to time. Ventilation. No subject, Mr. Frowen proceeded to say, has received more consideration than ventilation and shot-firing, the second being dependent to a very large extent upon the first consideration of safety. For brevity, clarity, and the truth a sentence by the Chief Inspector of Mines, Sir Henry Walker, in his report following the inquiry into the unfortunate explosion at Hartley Bank Colliery in Yorkshire, was quoted, in which he says. "A generous ventilating current should be caused to sweep the face or faces where machines are at work." Many conferences have decided not only that this is true, but that airways must be provided and minimum sizes fixed so that ventilation can travel freely without obstruction, and the Association is confident it is only possible to carry this out by legislation. Airways which are not used for haulage are often neglected when economic sanctions are applied, and procrastination, not the ability to maintain them at a certain standard, is the chief cause for stagnant ventilation. Many a manager has found himself inheriting a mine where the airways are too small to meet present and future conditions. They contend that by fixing a minimum height for airways and requiring air measurements to be taken in every working place the fear of explosions can be almost wiped out. Shot-firing. Pointing out that it is too commonly taken for granted that shot-firing is a job for learners, Mr. Frowen said they would recommend the Commission to stress the importance of it requiring skilled men, and quoted from the report of Captain Macleod Carey for 1933, in which he says: "Where gas is a danger demanding the utmost vigilance, shot-firing and the operations in connection therewith are amongst the most dangerous and anxious tasks that must he taken underground. They call for strong nerves, sound common sense and great skill on the part of those performing the task." The Federation believes the status of shot-firers should be almost, if not quite, equal to that of the deputy. The shot-firer is often called upon to take upon himself the responsibilities of a deputy in cases of emergency when the deputy is off duty through sickness or other causes. The Federation has expressed itself from time to time at the Mines Department that not only should a limit be placed on the number of detonators issued from the magazine to a shot-firer but also that a time-limit, in accordance with the conditions of the seam, should be fixed for the firing of each shot. They believe this should be the duty of the divisional inspector. They further recommend that detonators should be numbered, as is the practice at many collieries, so as to prevent, as far as possible, an innocent person from charges of negligence, and the Explosives in Coal Mines Order amended to prevent detonators being passed on from one shot-firer to another. They also recommend that clause 1 (b) of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order should read "locked" case or canister instead of "secure" to prevent workmen or persons not having authority from pilfering cartridges; this is possible and unfortunately has been done in some instances. Many shot-firers, Mr. Frowen said, have found themselves in trouble under clause 2 (e) of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order, and the Federation recommends an amendment as follows: "The person firing the shot shall, before doing so, see that all persons leave the place or vicinity of the shot and shall place a suitably worded danger signal at all approaches to the shot. He shall not be responsible for any accident to persons crossing such fences, or persons injured by a shot when they are placed in shelter at the outbye side of the place of shelter occupied by the person firing the shot." It is further recommended as an amendment to clause 6 (a) of the Order to add, after the word "mineral" the words "or stone." Contractors have taken advantage of the Order as it reads at present and fatalities have taken place to shot-firers, they have good reason for believing, through being rushed. Falls of Roof. The point of view of the Associations on the question of falls of roof was expressed in the evidence as follows :— This problem has often been discussed in conference and quite as often it has been unanimously decided that the sure way of reducing accidents at the coal face is the compulsory use of bars on all longwall machine-cut faces. It is commonly admitted that breaks are much more frequent, in some seams at the back of every cut, which in many cases are only revealed after the coal has been filled away. Experience coming from all districts where machine-mining is in operation has definitely taught them that no other system will reduce the accidents better than systematic use of bars or steel straps, the latter preferred because they are more economical and can be used repeatedly besides being stronger. A very prolific source of accidents from falls of roof is the removal of timber in the waste, and it has often been decided in conference that Section 52 (2) of the Act should be amended so that "Props shall not be withdrawn from the waste or goaf otherwise than by means of a safety contrivance," and that the other part of the sub-section should he struck out, as being unnecessary and laying a responsibility on the deputy which need not be, seeing there are contrivances to-day which can be used conveniently and effectively. Haulage. The increased use of mechanical haulage naturally has created dangers to persons working or travelling. The tendency to increase output of coal not unnaturally began by substituting the machine for the man at the coal face although neither the roads nor the methods of haulage was anything like adequate to meet the situation; hence haulage machinery has been installed in roadways neither adequate in size or layout. The Associations are of the opinion that better roads, wide and high, well lighted and well ventilated, will reduce accidents on haulage, but at the same time they are convinced that the Mines Department should have power to insist on the installation of the most up-to-date safety contrivances. They further recommend that no persons should be permitted to travel haulage roads other than the official who has to make the inspection, when haulages are in motion. The airways should be the travelling roads for all workmen and gang-riding should be prohibited. There is no need for it in a properly set-out haulage road. Suggestions to Prevent Accidents. A supplementary note by Mr. J. W. Sumnall dealt with ventilation and one by Mr. J. Tuff examined the duties of deputies in Northumberland and Durham, whilst Mr. A. MacAlpine discussed the changes in method of work and equipment, remarking that with the introduction of machinery the accident rate has not been reduced, and from official figures the largest number of accidents is from falls of roof and sides and emanates from the coal face. With the view to reducing the number of preventable accidents he suggests the following :— (a) Better and more frequent supervision. (b) Where coal is machine-mined the roof should be supported with steel bars or straps, set systematically at a specified distance. (c) No roof supports should be withdrawn from the goaf or waste where coal-cutting machines or conveyors are working in the vicinity. Section 52 (2) should be amended to delete from the word goaf and insert "otherwise than by means of a safety contrivance." (d) Packs to be advanced and ripping or brushing work done when practicable before the coal face is cut. (e) Section 50 (3) should be amended to include where tubs are loaded by gate-end or conveyor loaders, and all mechanical haulage roads up to within 50 yards of the face should have supports set across the full width of the road at a specified distance not exceeding six feet. (f) On a machine-cut face (without conveyors) the roof above where the tub is filled should be supported, also the lip of the ripping or brushing. (b) Length of cutting jib to be limited. (h) More frequent attention to all machinery and equipment In use at the coal face by a competent person. The principal change in method of haulage is either by main and tail or by an endless haulage so arranged to cope with the amount of coal produced within a certain time. The size and condition of haulage roads is conducive to smooth working and to safety and where lighting is practicable it should be more extensively used on haulage roads. In this connection Mr. MacAlpine appended the following :— (a) On main haulage roads one foot clear space should be provided between the tub and the sides of the road and not less than one foot clear space from top of tub to the roof. (b) Haulage worked by gravity or mechanical power, Section 43 (1) to be amended to read after the word power "these roads must have a clear space of at least two feet in width between the tubs and that side of the road and two feet clear space between the top of the tubs and the roof supports." Clauses (a) and (b) to be cut out. (c) Separate travelling roads should be provided. (d) Safety appliances such as stop-blocks, backstays, and run-away switches should be made compulsory, all appliances connected with haulage work should be examined regularly, and kept in good working condition.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||