24th October 1936, Page: 119, Column: 1
Derailments In Horse Haulage
The programme of haulage accident research undertaken by
the Safe Working of Mines Committee of the South Staffordshire
and Warwickshire Institute of Mining Engineers includes an
investigation Into the occurrence and means of prevention of
derailments in horse haulage operations. The Fourth Progress
Report of the Committee, presented for discussion at the meeting
of the Institute on 12th October, includes the results of investigations
at four collieries where 352 derailments were observed by
the investigator (Mr. J. W. Robinson), and their causes noted.
Though the serious accidents due to horse haulage derailments
are few in number many minor accidents are so caused; and because
most of the factors contributing to derailments in horse haulage
operations are common to the problem of derailments in general,
the Committee say the results of this investigation have a wider
application than to horse haulage only.
An examination of the information relative to accidents in
horse haulage operations indicates that they are of two kinds,
those associated with the actual derailment, e.g., when the injury
results immediately from a derailment, and those which occur
during re-railing operations, a particular case being, when
attempting to re-rail a tub without detaching the horse, It is
of interest in this connection to quote a notice posted at the pithead
and in all pass-byes underground at a particular colliery,
viz., "If a tub becomes derailed, no person shall move or attempt
to move the tub whilst a horse is attached to the tub or train."
The observance of this requirement, the Committee add, would
undoubtedly save a large number of accidents, and its wider
adoption is strongly recommended.
The chief circumstances in which horse haulage is practised for
conveying tubs in the district are: (1) Between the face or
conveyor loading points and mechanical-haulage collecting points.
(2) In driving headings and when opening out and working the
panels in the South Staffordshire Thick Coal. (3) When repairing
roadways. (4) When working small detached areas of coal,
usually panels, where the expense of installing mechanical haulage
may not be justified.
Methods of Attachment.
The Report explains that the method of attachment between
horse and tub is chiefly by means of a tail-chain and spreader.
No less than 91 per cent. of the total number of horses used underground
are so fitted, the tail-chain being attached to the drawbar
of the tub either by means of a hook, where the drawbar contains
a hole, or by a large link when it terminates in a hook. The
remaining horses are provided with limbers fitted with a hinged
bolt which passes through a hole in the yoke bar fixed on the
front of the tub and is then secured by means of a spring cotter-pin,
which prevents the bolt from lifting and the limbers detaching.
The height of the point of attachment above rail-level in the first
case is about 11 inches, and in the second, approximately at
the centre of the tub, about 23 inches.
Each method of attachment has its advantages and disadvantages;
for example, with a tail-chain a horse cannot hold back
and control the load as when limbers are used, and to prevent
the tubs from overtaking the horse when travelling downhill
the wheels have to be more often lockered. On the other hand,
when turning horses equipped with limbers in narrow and closely
supported roads, freedom of movement is more restricted than is
the case with tail-chains, and there is always the danger of dislodging
the supports and causing a fall of ground.
As the height of the point of attachment between the horse
and the tub affects the direction of pull, it is an important factor
in derailments. The lower the point at which the pull is applied,
particularly with a short tail-chain, the greater is the tendency
for the front of the tub to be lifted off the rails. This is likely to
be further accentuated when the tub has a long body and a short
wheel base.
It is essential that horses be properly trained, be provided
with suitably fitting harness, and be placed in charge of competent
drivers, otherwise they are apt to become unruly and get out of
control, causing derailments and, in many cases, accidents.
As given in the report the causes of derailments are track
deficiencies; bad rail joints; incorrect gauge; fouled rails,
points and crossings; damaged sleepers; rolling stock defects;
striking roof or side; broken wooden lockers; collision at pass-byes,
and very occasionally locked buffers. The human factor
was responsible for 63 per cent. of the derailments. In the
presentation of the summary and conclusions it is stated that an
analysis of the horse-haulage accidents shows that 23 per cent.
were attributable to derailments. Apart from being potential
causes of accidents, derailments involve disorganisation of output,
loss of time, energy, and money.
Though some of the 352 observed derailments were due to causes
peculiar to horse haulage, the great majority resulted from causes
common to other methods. An examination of the causes of the
derailments suggests not only preventive measures but also an
improvement in practice in certain directions, and the Committee
recommend that particular attention be given to the following
more important points: (1) The provision and maintenance of
roadways of ample dimensions, and adequate clearance between
tubs at all collecting stations. (2) The use of uniform rail sections
of British Standard Specification. (3) With flat-bottomed rails,
the use of properly fitting fish-plates; with bridge rails, the use
of sleepers fitted with guides. (4) The distance between sleepers
should not exceed 3 feet. (5) The prevention of movement of
sleepers. (6) The careful laying, jointing, gauging, and maintenance
of rail-tracks. (7) The provision and use of efficient
iron lockers. (8) The more extended use of limbers.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Robinson, J. W. | | Investigator | |