10th October 1936, Page: 97, Column: 1
Correlation Of The Coal Measures
In the Geology Section at the Blackpool meeting of the British
Association the Correlation of the Coal Measures was discussed by
Professor A. E. Trueman, Dr. Emily Dix, Dr. A. Raistrick,
Dr. J. Weir, and Dr. D. A. Wray. Professor Trueman stated that
problems of correlation in the Coal Measures involve both the
recognition of zones and the identification of individual horizons.
In comparing sequences in different coalfields, in recognising strata
met with in new explorations (especially of concealed coalfields)
and in the interpretation of structurally complex areas, the
identification of floral or faunal zones is of outstanding importance;
the recognition of datum planes and correlation on a more detailed
basis is more often necessary in actual mining operations. Within
the last ten years work on the faunas and floras of the Coal Measures
and on the coal seams has provided a basis for the solution of
most of these problems. The charge of neglecting the stratigraphy
of that formation which is of most economic importance can no
longer be justified. In many instances minute palaeontological
studies have confirmed the correlations which have been based
on thicknesses and on comparisons of sections, but in other cases
erroneous conclusions had been drawn from such data. The
broader divisions made by palaeobotanists probably hindered the
development of real floral zones. The peculiar conditions under
which the Coal Measures were laid down, and the surprising
uniformity of many horizons (coal seams, marine bands, etc.)
over wide areas, facilitate correlations even when the fossils would
at first sight be thought unsuitable for detailed work.
Dr. Emily Dix in a communication pointed out that, in many
cases, the non-marine fossils form the most reliable indices for
detailed correlation, yet at certain horizons the plants are so
characteristic that they are quite as important for zonal purposes
as the non-marine shells. In areas where their use is difficult,
especially in the upper measures, the evidence afforded by the
plants is particularly important. Dr. Kidston had shown that
plants could be used for subdividing rocks of coal measure age;
subsequently further studies on fossil floras have substantiated
this view. The Upper Carboniferous rocks of South Wales can
be divided into nine floral zones (two of which are confined to the
Millstone Grit). In general the succession of plants in the South
Wales coalfield agrees very closely with that of other coalfields in
Great Britain, and also with that of corresponding strata on the
Continent and in North America, as shown by the work of Bertrand,
Gothan, Jongmans, Renier, Darrah and others.
For many years it was recognised that the correlation of the
coal measures based on the faunas was not in agreement with the
results obtained by workers on the plants. This discrepancy does
not exist. In the upper part. of the Millstone Grit and the lower
part of the Coal Measures distinctive fibres are found in every
coalfield in Britain where the sequence is known, which are
comparable with those found in the zone of Neuropteris schleheni
and Sphenopteris hoeninghausi on the Continent.
It appears that certain floral changes took place more or less
simultaneously over the whole of Europe and North America.
Perhaps the most striking floral change takes place at the entry
of the rich Staffordian flora of Kidston [Flora G (Dix)]. This
marked change has been emphasised by Prof. Trueman and the
writer, and it has been suggested that the Westphalian can be
divided into lower and upper divisions at this level, and that
the palaeontological change is of greater magnitude than that
which takes place between the Westphalian and the Stephanian.
It is also suggested that it is comparable with the Palaeobotanical
Break noted by Prof. Gothan between Lower and Upper Namurian.
In South Wales the flora of a part of the Upper Coal Series
resembles that of the Lower Stephanian, while certain species
occurring in the Keele Series of Warwickshire may possibly indicate
that these strata should be correlated with the Upper Stephanian.
Discussing the Use of Microspores in the Correlation of Coal
Seams, Dr. A. Raistrick mentioned that two seams of coal have
been studied in great detail over a wide area by means of microspore
separations: the Trencherbone seam of Lancashire, and the
Busty seam of Durham. In the first case, a marked change in the
microspore content of the seam in one district is correlated with
changes in the structure of the seam and the proportions of its
constituent subsections. In Durham, the samples examined are
of the Top and Bottom Busty seams, taken at more than fifty
localities, the older correlation and naming being accepted for
sampling. The microspore analysis shows three distinct areas
in the coalfield, the pair of "Busty" seams giving uniform
diagrams over each single area, but the diagrams being different
in different areas. The areas of different microspore content
coincide approximately with areas of different physical and
chemical properties of the coals, a suggested revision of the Busty
correlation being given. Some indication of correlation between
different coalfields was also discussed.
Dr. J. Weir urged that the remarkable variability of the
Carbonicolidae, apparently so chaotic as to render the family of
little use in stratigraphical work, is in fact capable of systematic
application to stratal zoning, and the use of "mussel" zones for
correlating the Coal Measures is now established practice. Attention
may therefore be directed to the value of smaller divisions,
or subzones. Originally only local value was claimed for these,
but it is now clear that some extend through several coalfields,
and give a detailed synopsis of the faunal succession that affords a
more secure basis for homotaxial correlation than the broader zones.
On the other hand, it is doubtful if the definition of major
palaeontological subdivisions (of higher rank than zones) would
serve any useful purpose. In Scotland, subdivision of the Coal
Measures is possible only at Skipsey's Marine Band, a recognised
formational boundary, which marks approximately a change in
the physical character of the sediments as well as modification
of the non-marine fauna (failure of Carbonicola and Naiedites;
dominance of Anthraconeuta in the meagre fauna of the Barren
Red Measures). The only possible palaeontological partition of
the Scottish Productive Coal Measures (i.e., between Skipsey's
Marine Band and the Millstone Grit) is afforded by mussel zones
(and subzones) and by the floral zones recently worked out in
South Wales and England.
In the view of Dr. D. A. Wray there is a remarkably close
similarity in the succession of the lower part of the Coal Measures
in each of the Pennine coalfields, and in 1929 he published a detailed
correlation of these measures based largely on general lithological
comparisons. In the Main Productive and higher Coal Measures
such data are insufficient, and consequently the faunal and floral
successions are of prime importance. The persistence of very
occasional and comparatively thin marine bands over wide areas
has been much used, though their value has been considerably
enhanced by the studies of the non-marine faunal succession.
The striking value of the latter was recently revealed in East
Yorkshire, where lithological comparisons failed completely ; yet
by means of the non-marine shells it was possible to indicate the
presence of a complete though greatly attenuated succession of
the Main Productive measures as far east as the Trent valley.
The floral succession has not hitherto proved of the same value
In Northern France, however, an intensive study of the succession
of plant life by Bertrand and others has led to the establishment
of a zonal system of considerable precision and refinement. Its
application to the succession in this country by Dr. Dix appears
to be yielding promising results. In 1922, Theissen and his
co-workers in America pointed out that individual coal seams
had a characteristic spore-content, suggesting its employment as a
basis of correlation. Attempts have been made to extend this work
to Britain, and, if combined with the stratigraphical data already
available, it may prove of considerable value in instituting more
precise correlations between detached areas of Coal Measures.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bertrand, — | | | |
| Darrah, — | | | |
| Dix, Emily, Dr. | | | |
| Gothan, —, Prof. | | | |
| Jongmans, — | | | |
| Kidston, —, Dr. | | | |
| Raistrick, A., Dr. | | | |
| Renier, — | | | |
| Theissen, — | | | |
| Trueman, A. E., Prof. | | | |
| Weir, J., Dr. | | | |
| Wray, D. A., Dr. | | | |