|
12th September 1936, Page: 74, Column: 1 Safety In Coal MinesThe Cardiff AreaThese notes are based on the evidence and statements of witnesses appearing before the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines. In his evidence relating chiefly to the Cardiff and Forest of Dean Division, of which he is Divisional Inspector, Mr. J. Macleod Carey, O.B.E., explained that it consists of the eastern part of the county of Glamorgan, a small part of the county of Brecknock, the counties of Monmouth and Gloucester (west of the River Severn), and includes therein the major portion of what is generally known as the steam coal area of South Wales. There are now 266 mines at work, giving an output of some 25 million tons of coal and employing 96 thousand persons. Of these, 97 mines employ less than 30 persons, and of the 97, nine are under the control of first class certificated colliery managers, two being under the control of second class certificated colliery managers. There were 465 accidents last year, 31 1 occurring during the morning shift, 67 on the afternoon shift and 87 on the night shift. Superintending Inspector Advocated. Mr. Carey does not find his own clerical work overwhelming, and he spoke very highly regarding the services rendered in the Division by the sub-inspectors, whose long experience and careful training in the performance of their duties has made of them to-day a band of excellent officials who command the respect of all with whom they come into contact. They are treated by everyone in the Division with the same courtesy and consideration as any of their colleagues of higher rank. Mr. Carey proceeded to say that generally speaking, the administration work of the Division is performed quite satisfactorily with the present staff and its present distribution. The Inspector considers, however, that the South Wales coalfield should be placed under the control of a superintending inspector having under him two, or even three, district inspectors. Such an official should initiate and control the whole policy of the administration of the various Acts of Parliament regulating the mining industry in both the present Cardiff and Forest of Dean and the Swansea Divisions. Such an arrangement would simplify intercourse between the Coal Owners Association, the Miners' Federation and other organisations which now deal with the coalfield as a whole. The question of statistical information might thus be simplified and given in one report by a superintending inspector. Such an arrangement was in force twenty years ago, when the late Sir William Atkinson was appointed superintending inspector for South Wales. Each district inspector acting under the superintending inspector should be provided with an office and suitable clerical assistance. Control of Mines. With regard to organisation and management generally Mr. Carey has little criticism of present methods to offer. Nevertheless, he feels that all persons, by whatever designation they may be known, who have authority over the manager and power to order the method of working and general policy of a mine, should be qualified and bear some responsibility for its safe conduct, rather than that the whole onus should be placed upon the certificated manager. He thinks that mechanical and electrical engineers might be given statutory responsibility, always provided such statutory responsibility does not in any sense encroach upon the final responsibility of the colliery manager, whose position as such should be jealously safeguarded and supported. Such officials should, in his opinion, relieve the manager of immediate responsibility for their own particular department subject, of course, to the overriding authority of the manager himself. The Inspector is anxious to see the position of colliery managers improved in status and commensurate with the heavy responsibilities they carry. These important officials should be less confined to underground work, and spend more time in their offices considering the numerous problems that arise from time to time, thus supervising in a more efficient manner the whole work of the colliery, both above and below ground. As to under-officials, this is a question upon which colliery managers should have undisputed and decisive authority. It would appear desirable that there should be, as in fact there are at all large collieries, responsible officials in charge of the mine as a whole on both afternoon and night shifts. By responsible officials the Inspector means persons with first or second-class certificates who are subject to the manager and under-manager of the colliery. It should be remembered, however, that everything depends upon the circumstances at any particular colliery; some being easier to manage than others. With regard to the question of firemen, Mr. Carey does not think that the present requirements contained in the Coal Mines Act and in General Regulations require alteration. It is sufficient for the purposes of safety if the working places in a district are inspected within two hours of the commencement of work in a shift. It is also, in his opinion, quite sufficient if two inspections during each shift are carried out by the firemen. Whilst it is true that the majority of falls occur at the working face, and that the principal duties of a fireman are in that neighbourhood, nevertheless he has other duties to perform backbye with regard to ventilation, maintenance of roadways, and so on. In the steam coal collieries no shots are fired by any fireman during the day shift; some few shots are fired by these officials during afternoon and night shifts. Mr. Carey suggests that a definite form of signalling for conveyor faces be instituted so that conveyers, when necessary, can be stepped instantly without resort to shouting. As regards the question of shot-firing generally, voluntary arrangements were entered into by the Inspector and colliery managers many years ago by which the use of pneumatic picks replaced a considerable amount of explosives. There are within his Division now well over 1,000 pneumatic picks used for the purpose of ripping instead of shot-firing. In addition arrangements were made, also on a voluntary basis, that shots should be fired between shifts, and at week-ends, wherever it was possible so to do. Ventilation and Roof Support. Ventilation is the most important part of the safety side of mining. Section 29 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, if properly implemented provides sufficient safeguards against explosion of firedamp. Mr. Carey thinks, however, that a definite standard of air quality might be once and for all laid down — say a firedamp content not exceeding 1½ per cent. The standard laid down — at any rate by implication-in section 67 (2) of the Mines Act might be abolished. He appreciates that in suggesting 1½ per cent, as a standard throughout the mine that one is aiming at high perfection, and that there might be practical difficulties in enforcing so high a standard. He would be prepared to say that 2 per cent. should be the maximum standard of firedamp content, and that men should be withdrawn when this standard was reached. In making this suggestion Mr. Carey remarked that 2 per cent. represents a firedamp cap which can be seen by all practical persons below ground, and that, furthermore, it is the standard cap by which firemen are examined for their certificates. All other standards at present fixed in the Mines Act should, he suggests, be retained. Upon a general survey of ventilation being made in his Division recently, it was found that out of 350 samples taken in the main return airway of different districts only six contained over 1½ per cent. firedamp. The question of good ventilation is inextricably bound up in the question of roof support at the working face; the two subjects must always go hand in hand. If the working faces in the Division are adequately and systematically supported with tight packs, not only do the faces become safer, but the roadways behind are more easily maintained. For this reason Mr. Carey does not recommend double intakes or double returns, but rather that a minimum standard size should be put upon such roads, and that they must be maintained accordingly. It may be inferred from the results of the sampling of the ventilation current referred to that, generally speaking, the roadways in the Cardiff Division are kept in satisfactory condition. Falls of Roof and Side. The fatality rate in 1935 in Mr. Carey's Division from falls of roof and side at the working face per million tons of mineral raised was 145. He says that in the South Wales coalfield, in the steam coal series, there are approximately a dozen coal seams lying within a vertical thickness of strata of approximately 200 yards. It will be appreciated then the difficulties inherent in working out so many seams in such close proximity to one another, and herein lies, in part, the explanation for so many accidents occurring as the result of comparatively small falls at the working face, which falls continue to account for the majority of fatal accidents below ground. Mr. Carey is firmly of the opinion that such occurrences can only be appreciably lessened by means of solid and complete stowing of the wastes behind the working face, and the rigidly systematic support of the roof between the packs and the coal. Such methods, if adopted with regularity, not only tend to reduce the incidence of accidents at the working face, but backbye on account of their steadying influence upon the general stability of the strata throughout the mine workings. With regard to the question of systematic roof support between the working face and the wastes, this, where it can be adopted, is best achieved, Mr. Carey thinks, by the use of a steel flatting system, such as some two years ago he attempted to bring into existence. At one pit steel flats were used in a rather modified form with fairly satisfactory results, but at the other, unfortunately, the workmen refused to continue their use, although a small length of face was actually flatted in this manner. Reference was made to the question of escape roads in conveyor faces. It is undesirable to have a face at work where the roadways leading into it are spaced further apart than 100 yards. This distance should be a maximum-although it is always to be remembered that the less number of roads to be maintained and ventilated in any fiery colliery the better. Again, it depends upon the circumstances at any particular face. It might be that in a thin seam of say about two feet in thickness it would be desirable to have roadways spaced at distances less than 100 yards. Haulage Accidents. The number of haulage accidents has been substantially reduced in recent years. The magnitude of haulage gear in the Cardiff Division may have something to do with the number of accidents that otherwise might not be attended with serious consequences. No fatal accidents were caused in 1935 due to ropes or chains breaking. Practically all accidents were due in some way or other to the human element. Mr. Carey recommends better roadways, as suggested in his Report for 1931. Defective tracks leave been estimated to be responsible for nearly 12 per cent. of the total of haulage accidents, and if only this aspect were to be considered good tracks would prove a good investment. Frequent derailments are costly. Output is disorganised, and time, labour and money are expended to repair the damage done. All tracks should be laid under the direct supervision of an experienced plate-layer, and he should be given the responsibility for the maintenance of the roadways in either a section or the whole of the pit. Where curves are necessary, they should be of ample radius and properly laid out for the loads and speeds desired with due regard to correct super-elevation. Short, sharp curves are distinctly dangerous and should be avoided. A few well chosen, judiciously placed safety appliances, maintained in perfect working order and regularly operated, give greater security than the indiscriminate use of complicated appliances which are perfunctorily maintained, and which, in time, tend to become mere "eyewash." When repairs are being done on haulage roadways, especially on inclined ones, each repairer should be supplied with a pair of portable, wedge-shaped stop-blocks for use above and below the place where the repairs are being executed. The convenient placing of signal wires, either mechanical or electrical, is an important point. They should be run out on the side of the road on which the refuge holes are made. They should be so suspended that they do not obstruct the entrance to the refuge holes but should, at the same time, be within convenient reach of them. The best laid out and equipped haulage systems will not work satisfactorily unless an intelligent interest is taken by the persons responsible for operating them. Haulage is a dangerous occupation, and the employment of young people, with no training, in haulage operations does not tend to reduce the dangers. Every person employed on haulage should be taken in hand by an experienced and responsible person and given instruction in the correct performance of the duties assigned to him. Officials and overseers should never miss the opportunity of checking a faulty or dangerous practice and, at the same time, illustrating the correct and safe method of performing the particular operation. Practical demonstrations will be found of infinitely more value than verbal instructions. Explosions. The steam coal seams of the South Wales coalfield are notoriously fiery, and large quantities of gas are given off continuously. This demonstrates the necessity of restricting shot-firing to the minimum of urgent requirements, and, further, the elimination of all electric plant from the working faces and their neighbourhood. With regard to the stone-dusting of the roadways, required by General Regulations, Mr. Carey suggests and recommends that the roof and sides should be heavily stone-dusted, but that the floor should be kept, not normally, but perpetually, free from dust of any kind, and, if necessary, should be watered so as to form a hard surface upon which man and beast may move without raising any dust whatever. With regard to the question of dust raised in suspension in the air at conveyor dumps, he looks upon this as one of the most important questions for consideration in the immediate future. The clouds of dust that are now being raised in the air by the falling of coal from one conveyor to another, and from conveyors into trains, constitute, in his opinion, a danger the importance of which cannot be over-stated. The risk of explosion is great where machinery works in the neighbourhood of clouds of dust. He has himself suggested that the speed of conveyors carrying coal both at the face and on gate-roads should be limited, that the coal should not be permitted to fall from one conveyor to another, but should be conveyed down suitably graded chutes, and that a very serious attempt should be made to trap the dust that must necessarily be made at loading points. He is aware that this is an extremely difficult problem to solve. The Human Element. This purely intangible element in the incidence of mining accidents is more applicable to haulage than any other type of accident. Mr. Carey says it can be said to have its origin in the complex of human nature which compels a man when at work to wish to perform his task in the easiest and quickest manner for himself and his employer. This is not, unfortunately, always the safest or most efficient way. The only remedy lies in slowly — and he fears laboriously — educating those concerned to think a little more of the possible consequences of their actions. This in a small way he has endeavoured to do by deputing the task to the sub-inspectors, who have for lengthy periods at different times during the past years spent time among the haulage hands watching the actual operations, and correcting when opportunity offered the faults being committed. The Inspector believes, and many general managers agree with him, that much good has been done and the number of accidents reduced as a consequence. Health. The health of workmen underground should be considered especially in relation to the ventilation of the workings. Brisk currents of clean air sweeping the working faces and roadways will improve the men's general stamina, and keep them free from the depressing debility consequent upon close and stuffy atmospheres. This is of primary importance although obviously so elementary.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||