Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

12th September 1936, Page: 70, Column: 1

May (1936) Examinations

Report of Central Examiners

The Question Papers set at this Examination have been published in pamphlet form and are obtainable (2s. net) from H.M. Stationery Office.

In presenting the report of the Central Examiners on the examinations for certificates of competency as managers and under-managers of mines held in May (1936), the text of the questions is reproduced for ease of reference. The comments of the Examiners on the work done by the candidates are in italics following the setting of each question.

Methods of Working (2nd Class).

(1) Two seams dipping 1 in 7 are worked from the same shaft. One seam (a thick one) requires debris for packs and the other (a thin one) has a surplus. It is therefore decided to transfer the surplus debris. The thick seam is equipped with shaker conveyors on the face. Describe in detail how you would expeditiously get the debris, when delivered to the district, into the packs where it is required. (50)

This question was generally dealt with in a satisfactory manner. As was expected, practically all the candidates would hove a read at the top of the face on which to take the debris to be transferred on to the shaker conveyers and into the pack, but the arrangements far expeditiously getting the dirt on to the pans were often very crude and slow.

(2) A direct haulage rope cannot deal with the required output and it is not desirable to increase the rope speed or the number of tubs on a train. Still maintaining the same system, what arrangements would you make in order to increase the output, the incline being of sufficient width to allow an extra track to be laid ? Give details of the lay-out of the rails at the top of the incline. (50)

The layouts at the top of the incline were generally poor. It was expected that three rooms would be shown, one for the full train in the centre and the two side roads for empty trains. By this method an empty gang could stand ready for the rope to be transferred to it from the full gang as soon as it landed. The majority of the candidates would be content with two roads at the top, which would only be suitable for a single rope.

(3) In a certain district it is decided to eliminate all shot-firing. To what alternative methods would you direct your attention ? (50)

The substitutes for explosives were well known by the majority but few candidates thought of suggesting that altering the line of face might make the coal more easy to work and so eliminate shot-firing.

(4) As under-manager you are making a general inspection of a district. State the principal matters to which you would give your attention. (50)

The accounts were usually quite good, and covered most of the important points connected with a general inspection.

(5) Sketch and explain a lay-out at a shaft bottom in order that a large output may be expeditiously dealt with at one landing level. The cage has three decks. (50)

The lay-outs were generally poor. Instead of using one loading level, as stated, many of the candidates described some form of simultaneous decking plant. The lay-out of the sidings at the shaft bottom was ignored in many cases.

(6) A large fall has occurred on a roadway at the end of a length of steel arch girders, 8 feet high and 12 feet wide, and the cavity so formed is approximately 16 feet high from the floor and 8 yards long. The fall exposes a treacherous roof. Explain in detail the precautionary measures you would take In clearing the fall and how you would erect the arch girders in this section. Illustrate your answer with sketches. (50)

Only moderately well answered. With a cavity 16 feet high some temporary covering should be pushed forward from the end of the existing steel arches so as to protect the men from falling debris; this was very often omitted. This platform would also help in the erection of the new arch girders.

Ventilation (2nd Class).

(1) On the plan . . . show how you would arrange for the distribution of the air-currents, using the signs and colours as given in the General Regulations. Sheets to be shown thus S. (50)

In more than half the answers the arrangements were unsatisfactory. The plan selected would give three almost equal splits with two air-crossings, but few candidates gave such an arrangement. Fire splits were the predominating number, and various others up to 13, a ridiculous number for a practically continuous face only 500 yards long. Many gave far too many useless doors and air-crossings a few neglected the statutory provision of a second intake. Many candidates failed to notice that it is impracticable to have an intake current passing into, and a return current passing out of, two adjoining places in a longwall face; as the two currents cannot be divided off. A few omitted the essential separation doors at pit bottom.

(2) What are the properties and chemical constituents of: (a) Atmospheric air; (b) firedamp; (c) carbon monoxide; (d) carbon dioxide; (e) blackdamp ; (f) water ? (40)

A fair number of good answers. Of the others same gave composition of gases only, neglecting their properties others did the reverse. Too many confuse blackdamp with sulphuretted hydrogen.

(3) What points have to be observed in the construction of a permanent air-crossing? Give a description of one, with sketches. (40)

Some very good answers. Many others neglected the return road altogether, confining themselves to the intake only. The great majority carried the return over the intake, which is usually the preferable method. Some provisions were woefully inadequate, such as a single line of sheet-iron air pipes for a permanent crossing.

(4) An airway is lined with steel splayed arches, 8 feet high, 8 feet wide at springings, and 9 feet wide at floor. Its length is 900 feet. Calculate : (a) Its sectional area, (b) its perimeter, (c) its rubbing surface. For the purpose of this calculation, neglect the spaces behind the line of the face surface of the arches, and assume the curved part of the arch to be an exact semi circle. (40)

Almost every candidate knew the method of dealing with this question, but the arithmetical errors were very numerous; some of them so evident as to show that proper thought was not given to the results calculated.

(5) Sketch and describe a main ventilating fan of the centrifugal type with the necessary arrangements at the top of the upcast shaft. (40)

Most of the candidates showed a knowledge of the necessary arrangements, but most of the sketches were crude.

(6) How would you ventilate a shaft, 20 feet in diameter, in course of being sunk from the surface to a depth of 500 yards? Describe the method used and the plant necessary. (40)

Most candidates planned an arrangement which showed that they had no proper idea of the magnitude of the job. Nearly all provided a blowing fan, which is preferable. Some gave good reasons for the adoption of a fan of the air-propeller type for this installation.

(7) A fan working at a mine with a water-gauge of 4 inches, produces a current of 150,000 cubic feet of air per minute. Calculate the air horse-power. If the fan is speeded up so that the quantity is increased to 200,000 cubic feet per minute, what would then be the water-gauge and air horse-power? (40)

A large proportion of the candidates knew the method required, but there were far too many serious arithmetical errors. Also it is evident that the fundamental laws of ventilation — that the pressure varies as the square of the quantity, and the power as the cube of the quantity — are unknown to many of the candidates.

Explosions, Etc. (2nd Class).

(1) How may underground fires be caused by friction alone? In the instances you name, state what should be done to prevent such occurrences. (40)

Some good answers, but a few candidates only referred to the friction of rocks breaking over the wastes; others neglected to mention the danger of conveyor pans rubbing on timber, and the friction in connection with neglected haulage pulleys.

(2) Write a brief description of a test of the explosibility of coal dust proving its dangerous character, as carried out in the experimental gallery at Buxton. (40)

Some candidates were not aware of the new gallery in the strata; they only referred to the original boiler shell galleries. Very few could give an accurate description of the test, and length of gallery given varied from 50 feet to 800 yards.

(3) To what extent can workmen assist in reducing the risks of spontaneous heating? What indications of heating should they be able to detect: (a) If working in an intake gate-road; (b) if working in a return airway ? (40)

The answers were generally satisfactory.

(4) What kind of inert dust would you select for stone-dusting the underground roadways? Sketch a simple appliance for distributing the dust by compressed air, and state whether you prefer to use such an appliance, or to distribute the dust by hand; give your reasons. (40)

Some candidates gave vague answers as to the kinds of dust which may be used, merely stating that a white dust is most suitable. The sketches of a simple appliance for distributing the dust by compressed air were disappointing.

(5) How can breaks in roof strata contribute to an ignition of gas, and what precautions should be taken when breaks are discovered? Illustrate your answer by a sketch. (40)

Some good answers, but the danger of firing a ripping shot where a break may extend into a goaf containing gas was not fully realised.

(6) What alteration would you expect to find in the composition of the air in the workings of a mine after an explosion? What tests would you make of the air in such workings before permitting workmen to enter? (40)

It was frequently stated that there would not be any oxygen left in the air in the mine, which is obviously incorrect. In certain parts of the mine there would be no change from normal conditions, whilst in other parts where the ventilation had been deranged there would be a considerable reduction in the oxygen content, and dangerous quantities of carbon monoxide.

Machinery (2nd Class).

(1) Describe and sketch a set of bridle chains and attachments for a cage whose top hoop is about 10 feet long x 3ft. 3 in. wide. The cage weighs with tubs and coal about 5 tons gross. (20)

A number of candidates failed to state the metal of which the chains would be made. Six chains were sometimes shown, all attached by the end link to one large top link. Many answers made no attempt to give dimensions. Many candidates showed the rope capping and detaching hook, which were not asked for.

(2) What materials are used to insulate the copper conductors in an electric 3-phase cable? When paper is used as insulator how is the cable treated and constructed? (20)

Much weakness was shown describing electric cables insulated with paper.

(3) What is a star-delta starter? Give a diagram of connections of the starter and the machine it controls, showing both the starting and the running connections. (20)

Some candidates knew nothing about a star-delta starter. Others explained the theory well but did not know how the apparatus works in practice. Only a small number realised that the stator of a motor for star-delta starting must have six terminals available. The number of diagrams of connections having even approximate accuracy was very small.

(4) What horse-power would you expect from a steam engine having one cylinder 15 in. bore x 24 in. stroke, running at 80 r.p.m. ? The steam pressure at the stop valve is 80 lb./sq. in. The engine exhausts to atmosphere. (20)

There were two very common mistakes. First the engine was treated as single-acting, and secondly the mean effective pressure was taken to be the full stop valve inlet pressure. Another mistake less often made was to arrive at the mean effective pressure by deducting the atmospheric pressure — 14.7 lb./sq. in. — from the inlet pressure. A minority of the candidates allowed for the mechanical efficiency of the engine. There were few good answers to this question.

(5) What are the types of safety valve that may be applied to a steam boiler? Describe one type of safety valve in detail by the aid of a sketch. (20)

The type most commonly described was the dead-weight safety valve, and the next, the lever safety valve. The arrangements sketched were often crude. A number of candidates attempted to sketch and describe a high steam and low water safety valve. The commonest mistake was to omit a fulcrum of the lever inside the boiler.

(6) An incline is being driven dipping 1 in 5. The measures are wet with water dripping from the roof. The rate of income of water is 40 gal/mm. Electric power and compressed air are available. Describe a portable pump plant for keeping the incline drained, the head being limited to 100 feet. Give reasons for your choice. (20)

This question was often well answered. Weakness was shown in the description of the pump chosen. Where a compressed air type of pump was chosen the description of the water end was often theoretical, and frequently there was no reference to the compressed air end.

Mining Legislation (2nd Class).

(1) Compulsory. — In the form of a report to your manager make any suggestions which occur to you, arising out of your practical experience underground, of alterations of the Mines Act, 1911, and General Regulations which, in your opinion, would tend to reduce accidents under the following heads : (1) Support of roof and sides ; (2) haulage; and (3) shot-firing. (20)

A large number of candidates, instead of answering what was asked, suggested improvements in practice at their own collieries which in most cases are already specified in the Act. The answers revealed a very surprising ignorance of the provisions of the 1911 Act as it stands and the meaning of its wording. Some suggestions for amendments were — Uniform systematic support of all roofs and sides — The substitution of steel arches, girders and props for timber — A minimum age for all haulage hands — Total prohibition of travelling on haulage roads — Better lighting of all loading points and junctions — The fixing of a minimum size of roads — Limitation of number of shots to be fired by a deputy — Total prohibition of all blasting, or to be only between shifts — Extension of the area of examination for gas and stone-dusting — Increased length of shot-firing cables — Universal use of sheathed explosives. Some advocated simultaneous shot-firing and some opposed it.

(2) Give a concise summary of the various provisions of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, and General Regulations, relating to travelling roads underground and to the safety of persons passing therein. (20)

Not generally well answered. Many did not refer to travelling roads alongside haulage, and those who did were confused as to the variations for inclination and speed.

(3) How and by whom are firemen, examiners or deputies to be appointed under the Coal Mines Act, 1911, and the General Regulations? Explain fully (a) their qualifications, and (b) their statutory duties. (20)

Generally well answered, but too many candidates failed to refer to the inspection before the shift.

(4) Assume that a fire is discovered in an electric haulage house near the pit bottom in the intake airway. Explain in detail what steps you must take to comply with the Coal Mines Act, 1911, and the General Regulations. (20)

Generally well answered but not in great detail. Some forgot the first step-to cut off the current, and some to withdrawing the workmen from the inbye side.

(5) Detail the provisions of the General Regulations as to the use of explosives on main haulage roads and main intake airways. What is the definition given of a "main haulage road" ? (20)

The requirements as to withdrawal of men, except a limited number, were usually correctly given, but a large number did not refer to the compulsory use of Permitted Explosives where the road is not naturally wet. Very few gave the correct definition of a "main haulage road." (See Clause 11 of the Explosives Order.)

(6) Describe the provisions of the General Regulations as to arrangements to be made on the surface for rendering first-aid treatment to any person in or about the mine who may be injured or be taken ill. (20)

Generally well described, but many did not distinguish between mines employing under 100 persons underground and those over. The expression "small mines" was often inaccurately used.


Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
29 Feb 1936  Board for Mining Examinations (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Examination Results (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Aug 1936  Notes On Surveyors' Examination, Central Examiner's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Sep 1936  May (1936) Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Sep 1936  May (1936) Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
10 Oct 1936  May (1936) Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Oct 1936  May (1936) Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print