|
29th August 1936, Page: 56, Column: 2 Notes On Surveyors' ExaminationCentral Examiner's ReportThe Question Papers set at this Examination have been published in pamphlet form and are obtainable (2s. net) from H.M. Stationery Office. The report of the Central Examiner on the examination for surveyors' certificates held in May (1936) shows that 100 candidates presented themselves for examination, and 29 qualified in the written examination. Those who qualified in the practical examination numbered 23. The percentage passes at each of the examination centres were: Edinburgh, 7.7; Newcastle, 29.4 Sheffield, 28.5; Wigan, 25 ; Cardiff, 18.2 ; Birmingham, 33.3. The Examiner says the results show a gratifying increase in the percentage of candidates who ultimately qualified for a certificate, the figure being, with one exception, the highest recorded for many years. Even so it falls to be noted that the percentage of candidates qualifying in the written part of the examination on this occasion is only very slightly greater than In November last. At first glance, therefore, he proceeds, it would appear as if the ultimate success achieved by candidates on this occasion was almost wholly due to improvement in the work performed at the oral and practical examination. While, to some extent, that may be so, it is not the sole reason for the improvement, for, with one exception, the work accomplished at all centres in the written examination was generally of a higher standard than has been accomplished for some time past. The outstanding feature of the written examination was the excellence of the work accomplished by candidates at the Sheffield Centre, both in the morning and afternoon papers. Newcastle also maintained the reputation for good work which has been a feature of recent examinations. On the other hand candidates at the Edinburgh Centre made one of the poorest showings ever recorded thereat. Reviewing the written examination as a whole, there is still pronounced weakness in tackling questions outside daily routine, and the Examiner says it is not unfair criticism to say that the qualifications of a considerable number of candidates appear to be limited to the manipulation of surveying instruments and the resultant plotting and plan work. Comments on Answers. Below we give the text of the questions set at the examination, each question being followed by the comment of the Examiner on the work generally of the candidates. The "comments" are in italics. MORNING SESSION: (1) Compulsory Question. — The plan . . . shows surface contours at vertical intervals of 25 feet. The outcrop of the top of a thick bed of ironstone has been proved at the two points marked A and D, and the outcrop of the base thereof has also been proved at other two points marked B and C thereon. Mark on the plan the area covered by the outcrop of the bed and determine the stratigraphical thickness of the latter. (14) Answers generally were disappointing, only six candidates obtaining a correct or even approximately correct solution. Of the others, more than one-half showed by their work that they had little or no idea of how to obtain what was required. (2) An exploring heading AB, advancing direct to the rise in a coal seam, meets at the point B a downthrow fault of unknown displacement which bears from east to west and hades at 60 deg. At a distance of 366 feet and 791 feet respectively from B, in the direction of AB produced, two boreholes have been put down from the floor of a level cross-measures drift driven from B, and have intersected the floor of the seam at depths of 65 yards and 36 2/3 yards respectively. The co-ordinates in feet of the points A and B are as follows :— @ Calculate the vertical displacement of the fault in feet, assuming that the measures dip uniformly on each side thereof. (12) This by no means difficult question was as a rule poorly answered. Practically the only point calling for observation in order to obtain a correct solution was the fact that the heading d d not cross the fault at right angles to its direction. Only four candidates gave evidence of having realised that fact. (3) In a report recently issued by a joint committee dealing with "Standards of Accuracy and Limits of Error for Surveys and Plans of Mines," it is inter alia recommended in considering methods of correlating surface and underground surveys that "in the case of workings at a greater distance than 1,000 yards from the point of reference to the surface, the correlation shall preferably be carried out by simultaneous magnetic observations on the surface reference base line and on each of the underground observation bases respectively." State any reasons which in your view may have led to the recommendation above quoted, and thereafter describe as briefly as you can how you would carry out the work entailed in such a correlation. (10) Answers generally were fair, with some exceedingly good ones among them. It was, however, obvious that a considerable number of candidates had only a perfunctory knowledge of the report referred to. Generally speaking, the descriptions of the correlative work were satisfactory. (4) A colliery leasehold contains four shafts, and the coordinates in feet of the centre of shaft No. 1 relative to the south-east corner of a Ordnance Survey sheet marked XIII 5 are N. 3,679.5 and W. 448.5. From the leasehold triangulation survey, correlated to the Ordnance Grid, it is found that the azimuth of a line joining the centres of shafts No. 1 and No. 4 is 233°55' and that it measures 21,258 links. Calculate the coordinates, in feet, of shaft No. 4 in relation to the south-west corner of the Ordnance Survey sheet on which it is shown, and state the number of that sheet. (8) This question called for nothing more than knowledge of the size of an Ordnance Survey map drawn to scale of Despite that fact only 25 per cent, of the answers were correct or even approximately correct. (5) Describe briefly the term "zero circle" used with reference to a planimeter. If a planimeter reading tens of square inches were handed to you to enable you to measure areas on plans drawn to scales of and 1/10560, what multiplier would you use in each instance to convert the instrumental reading into acres? (8) Comparatively few candidates attempted this question, and few entirely satisfactory answers were obtained. AFTERNOON SESSION: (1) Compulsory Question. — The undernoted short traverse was made with a theodolite graduated clockwise :— @ It is proposed to drive out of DE — commencing from a point vertically under AB — in the same direction as BA, and rising at an inclination of 8 Inches to the yard, a cross-measures drift to connect with BA produced in direction and gradient. Calculate (a) the distance from D to the starting point of the cross-measures drift, and (b) the length of the drift when it holes through on BA produced. (14) This compulsory question was a practical and straightforward problem which a surveyor might any day be called upon to deal with. There were many excellent answers, but the fact that 30 per cent, of the answers received less than half marks speaks for itself. (2) The diagram . . . shows four up-stations A, B, C and D, and a down-station X which is to be rediscovered. From a trial point X1, near X, the angles measured clockwise from A as a reference object were found to be as follows :— @ Assuming A as the R.O., plot a scale of 10 feet to the inch, on the square paper supplied, the point X and the rays of the reverse bearings BX1, and DX1. Thereafter, from inspection, indicate on your plotting the probable position of the trial point X1. (12) Only sixteen candidates attempted this question and only three of the answers indicated any real knowledge of what was required, which was somewhat surprising in view of recent discussions and publications on the subject of re-section. The question was framed with the object of obtaining from the details given a "triangle of error" rather larger than would be expected in good practice, the object being to test the candidates' method of ascertaining the position of the point X, by inspection. (3) The following are the notes of a trigonometrical levelling in a straight underground roadway. Calculate the reduced level of each intermediate point between stations A and E, together with such additional information as would enable you to plot a longitudinal section between these stations if you were asked to do so. Assume the B.M. at station A to be 150 feet above Ordnance datum. (12) @ Few candidates attempted this question, and fewer still gave by their answers any definite evidence of a knowledge of the subject. (4) A, B and C are points on the floor of a coal seam. Azimuth BA 279°30' and distance BA 146 feet horizontal. Azimuth BC 5°30' and distance BC 232 feet horizontal. Levelling from B to A showed a fall of 0.50 feet, and from B to C a rise of 15.78 feet. Calculate the direction and rate of full dip of the seam. (10) This question was attempted by almost every candidate. There were again a fair number of good answers and a great many exceedingly poor ones. (5) A disused colliery railway was laid on an embankment on level ground measuring 10 feet at the top, 22 feet at the base and 6 feet in height. The level of the embankment was subsequently lowered to a plane parallel to the base, and to such extent that only one-half of the original volume now remains. Calculate the depth of material removed. (8) Attempted by almost every candidate, the majority of answers were strangely poor. A simple and speedy method of solution by the use of similar triangles was only in one or two instances made use of. (6) A vertical shaft, 1,000 feet in depth, is sunk to the floor of a seam of coal 51 inches in thickness in the trough of a syncline, the radius of which is equal to the depth of the shaft. The pillar left for protection of the shaft is on plan in the form of a square, with sides each measuring 206 yards, and is in such position that the centre of the shaft coincides with the point of intersection of the diagonals, and the axis of the syncline bisects two opposite sides. Calculate the tonnage of coal contained within the area of the shaft pillar, assuming S.G. to be 126. (8) This simple question was not generally attempted. About one-third of the answers earned full marks, and the remainder were generally disappointing.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||