Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

15th August 1936, Page: 33, Column: 1

Safety In Coal Mines

Recommendations for Scottish Mines

These notes are based on the evidence and statements of witnesses appearing before the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines.

In his evidence before the Mines Safety Commission Mr. E. H. Frazer, O.B.E., M.Sc., Divisional Inspector for Scotland, whose mining experience has been mainly in Yorkshire, Northumberland and north of the Tweed, said his recommendations applied to Scotland only. Though the Division comprises all Scotland coal is mined in only eleven counties. On the average, compared with other Divisions, the mines are smaller. The average number of persons employed per mine is 233 and the average production of coal is about 300 tons per day. Of the 370 mines 333 employ under 500 men and only five find work for more than 1,000 persons. Forty per cent. of the mines in 1934 were small mines not required to be under the supervision of a certificated manager.

Modern Mining Changes.

As stated by Mr. Frazer, Scottish mines are generally very wet and the seams are badly faulted, dividing the workings into a large number of small, isolated and badly shaped districts, but fortunately they have very little inflammable gas and the coal dust problem does not present much difficulty.

The mines in Scotland are more mechanised underground than in any other division. About three-quarters of the coal produced is cut by machines and half of it is mechanically conveyed and loaded into tubs.

Naked lights are used to a greater extent in Scottish mines than in collieries elsewhere in the kingdom. About 72 per cent. of the mines are worked with naked lights only, 17 per cent. with safety-lamps only and 11 per cent. with mixed lights.

Among the changes in the nature of mining in Scotland since 1911 are :—

(i) A great increase in the use of electricity;

(ii) An increase in the use of mechanical power, which is accomplished by a reduction in the amount of manual, horse, and gravity haulage;

(iii) An improvement in the size and safety of roads. The use of arched girders and straight girders in responsible for this

(iv) Concentration of work to a few intensively worked conveyor faces;

(v) An improvement in the ventilation of mines, due to the effects of (iii) and (iv)

(vi) The use of steel for roadway and face supports;

(vii) An increase in the number of persons employed on afternoon and night shifts, compared with the number on morning shift;

(viii) An increase of noise at the coal face, caused by mechanical devices such as coal-cutting machines, pneumatic picks, jigging conveyers, etc.

(ix) An increase of 20 per cent. in the amount of explosive used per ton of coal.

In his notes on changes in methods of work and equipment Mr. Frazer said that since the tendency is for electricity to be employed at the face of gassy mines to replace compressed air, there is an added danger of explosion. The use of apparatus certified flameproof by the Mines Department should be made obligatory where there is a firedamp risk. That measure, coupled with a suggested lower limit for the percentage of firedamp necessitating the cessation of current, should lessen the danger.

Inspectors have power to object to the installation of electricity, but usually a decision has to be made when conditions ore at their best, i.e., when a district is newly opened out; is not extensive; has a good ventilation; and has not been advancing so swiftly as it will do when the electrical plant is installed. It is suggested that, instead of the duty being placed upon an inspector to object if he considers the use of electricity dangerous, the burden should be placed upon the owner to show that the use of electricity is safe by weekly sampling and analysis of the air. This sampling might be limited to the faces of a certain class of mines.

Some steps might be taken to limit the amount of noise produced by machinery at the coal face.

The propagation of explosions along roadways has been rendered less liable by the general application of stone dust but the danger at the coal face has not been reduced. Mr. Frazer would like to see further steps taken to render coal dust at the working face innocuous. As a move in this direction it is suggested that coal dust should be dealt with where produced, i.e., at gate-end loaders and conveyor ends, by auction hoods, etc.

Administration.

Supplying information in more than usual detail respecting the work and duties of the Mines Inspectorate, Mr. Frazer expressed the view that the limit of the effectiveness of inspection has been reached, if not passed, unless the inspectorate is to relieve managers of some of their functions. There is room for more instruction to the workmen and minor officials in their duties, but whether this is to be the duty of managers or whether it is to be undertaken by inspectors is a matter of policy which it is not his province to decide. Already a great deal of instructional work is done during inspections, particularly to shot-firers and firemen.

The splitting of Scotland into two divisions would relieve the Divisional Inspector of nearly half of his office work and he, the highest paid inspector, would be able to devote more time to outside work, such as making contact with agents and managers, underground inspections, investigation of accidents, etc., and so would become better acquainted with the division and more up-to-date; but, of course, his experience would not be so wide.

If it is desired to retain the present arrangement, the Divisional Inspector and those above him most become reconciled to the fact that his main work lies inside his office or at conferences and that inspection will necessarily occupy only a small proportion of his time.

Organisation and Management.

At a group of mines under one ownership it is usual to have under the Board of Directors some or all of the following higher officials : General mining manager, Agents, Chief electrical engineer, Chief mechanical engineer, Sub-agents, Managers, Under-managers. As a rule all these persons, said Mr. Frazer, except the chief electrical and mechanical engineers have certificates of competency, although the under-managers may only have second-class certificates. Only the agents, managers and under-managers have responsibilities under the Coal Mines Act. There is usually a surveying department with a head surveyor. The general mining manager interests himself in matters of general policy and co-ordination of departments rather than in detail work, though on occasion small matters of detail may be referred to him.

Managers have most of the executive duties and particularly the duty of controlling the underground workmen. Upon these falls the responsibility for observance of the provisions of the Act, even though their power be limited and they have only indirect control over electricians, engineers and surveyors.

They generally have complete control of underground officials and men, and a large measure of control over the surface staff. It is only in regard to the provision of materials, selection of underground plant, lay-out of the workings, and general policy, that their powers are restricted.

The surveying staff usually plans its own work regardless of the individual colliery staffs, though it may always be called upon for special work by the agents or managers. The head surveyor is often not answerable to anyone but the general mining manager. Surveyors, having planned their work, may inform the managers of their intentions with a view to ascertaining whether it will be convenient and, if not, will defer to their wishes.

It would seem desirable, the Inspector averred, to impose statutory responsibilities upon all persons who take part in the technical management of mines.

Provision should be made for responsible officials to be in charge of a mine during the afternoon and night shifts when a large number of persons is employed in such shifts.

Provision should also be made for managers and under-managers to make inspections of all working roads and faces within specified periods.

Works contractors. — Coal-washers, headgears and extensive additions to screening plants are usually erected by contract the contractor supplying material and labour. Accidents which occur are deemed to be colliery accidents though no return of the persons employed by contractors is made. The accidents may be due to defective plant or improperly installed plant over which the colliery manager has little control, if any. Contractors escape liability and the manager can escape penalty by proving Section 102 (3) of the Act, and the inspector adds that some revision of the Act in this respect seems desirable.

Mining engineers. — At mines where no surveying staff is maintained it is customary for firms of mining engineers to make the surveys and plans. Time manager cannot check the accuracy of the plans to any degree of fineness but he is responsible for keeping an accurate plan, whilst no legal burden is laid upon the mining engineer. The latter, Mr. Frazer considers, should be made responsible for preparing accurate plans.

Manufacturers of machinery, such as coal-cutting machines, conveyers, haulage gear, screens and washer machinery, frequently supply appliances insufficiently protected. Colliery officials must start, when the machinery is turned over to them, to alter it so that the protection is adequate. The inspector said there should be an obligation to supply machinery intrinsically safe or else efficiently fenced.

Firemen and Their Duties.

Firemen are required to devote their whole time to statutory duties except that they are allowed to measure work done and to fire shots. In practice it is difficult to ensure compliance with this prevision, and the divergences from it may be small or large. The district of a fireman has to be small enough to allow him to make a complete inspection in two hours and he is only required to make two inspections a shift. That leaves him four hours to spare, which he may, as a fact, spend in further inspections, in firing shots or in other work.

Excessive numbers of shots are fired by some firemen, so many that they may not only absorb all the spare time but encroach upon the periods required for inspection and, even then, cannot be done with full regard to the requirements of time Explosives in Coal Mines Order. It would be better, in the view of Mr. Frazer, to enact that an extra inspection should be made per shift, or perhaps two extra inspections.

The qualifications necessary for a fireman, he considers, should include good eyesight and hearing, a knowledge of gas testing and an ability to pass an oral examination upon the law relating to the specific duties laid upon him, in particular as to ventilation, support of roof and sides, and shot-firing, it is unnecessary for a fireman to be able to measure the quantity of air. Such an examination would tend to improve the status of firemen and would lead to a better class of men being appointed than at present. Mr. Frazer does not consider that there is justification in the often repeated statement that an experienced miner makes the best fireman, nor does be consider that it is necessary to have two years practical experience at the face in order to qualify for a position as a fireman.

Ventilation.

Evidence was submitted regarding ventilation standards, falls of ground, haulage accidents, accident analysis, etc., from which we give the following extracts :—

The standards of adequate ventilation laid down in the 1911 Act are: (i) Oxygen — minimum of 19 per cent. (ii) Carbon dioxide — maximum of 1¼ per cent.: (iii) Firedamp — maximum of ¼ per cent. in intake airways. There is also another requirement that a place shall be deemed dangerous if the percentage of inflammable gas in the general body of the air exceeds 2½ per cent. This, Mr. Frazer says, has come to be regarded as a standard of adequate ventilation and therefore it can be quoted as another standard, viz. (iv) Firedamp — maximum of 2½ per cent. in the general air.

In regard to the implied standard (iv) it has not been found satisfactory because when there is 2½ per cent. of inflammable gas in the general body of air in a place there is almost sure to be more than double that percentage in parts, which means the presence of an explosive mixture. Time addition of 2½ per cent. of firedamp to air greatly increases the risk of propagation of a dust explosion and makes the usual precautions, by means of inert dust additions, less effective. It is difficult to envisage an intermediate stage, the witness remarked, between a place being fit for working and a place being dangerous. If a place is not fit for working, it implies withdrawal, so there should only be standards of withdrawal. Anything more safe than the standards should be considered to be fit for working therein.

The maximum percentage of firedamp for working should be less than 2½ per cent. where safety-lamps are in use. That percentage does not allow a sufficient margin of safety.

The standard for the use of electricity is now a maximum of 1¼ per cent. of firedamp. The average fireman professes his inability to detect with accuracy 1¼ per cent., and, in practice, it is difficult to estimate precisely whether this percentage is exceeded or not. An additional safeguard, by weekly air sampling and analysis, has been suggested. If reliance was placed upon analyses of samples there is no reason why the maximum permissible percentage should not be reduced to, say, 1 per cent.

The standard for withdrawal for naked lights and for cessation of shot-firing could be made the same as for stoppage of electricity.

It is suggested that a restriction as to the number of persons to be employed in any ventilation split should be imposed. it would tend to reduce the size of splits and so improve the ventilation, and it would also reduce the number of persons liable to be affected by an explosion or a fire,

Falls of Ground.

The accident rate from falls of ground on roadways has slightly decreased and will further decrease as more roads are supported by steel arches. Most of the progress in supports has been on roadways. The position is reasonably satisfactory.

At the working face the serious accident rate has increased in Scotland by nearly 50 per cent. since 1924, on a man-shift basis. Even on a tonnage basis there has been a continuous increase in the rate for the last six years. The reason for the increase is "conveyor faces," though how this has operated to produce an increase in the rates is not very clear. The following reasons are alleged (i) Less packing in the waste ; (ii) More rush and bustle (iii) Inadequate time when working to a time-table to do all the operations safely ; (iv) Inexperience.

In Mr. Frazer's opinion the packing has much to do with the matter, and it is suggested that this subject should receive more attention. It should be compulsory for a manager to specify how, where and at what distance apart packs should be built. To neglect propping is an offence but to neglect packing, a far more serious matter, is no offence. This should be altered.

It has been found that a great deal of a miner's time is spent in advance of the supports, under untried new roof. The adoption of a rule that temporary supports should be set would obviate this to some extent.

Inspectors, the witness said, have consistently urged the compulsory use of straps or bars on all working faces. An erection consisting of two or more props and a strap is more stable and less likely to be swung out than single props with lids.

The use of a timber appliance for withdrawing all supports at a distance of, say, nine feet or more from the face should be enforced. The provision of withdrawing tools and timber setting tools ought to be the duty of the owners.

Better means of supporting undercut coal are required in thick seams than in thin ones. Sprags under the coal are not sufficient.

Haulage Accidents.

Haulage by hand and by means of horses is becoming less common. Less than 20 per cent. of the number of horses used in 1911 is used now. Further legislation for hand haulage and horse haulage seems unnecessary.

In mechanical haulage the human factor is most important. Few accidents are caused by mechanical failures, but some of those could be prevented by systematic examination and annealing of coupling chains, drawbars and lashing chains. Wide roads and more space for working, in Mr. Frazer's opinion, would prevent other accidents.

The prevention of travelling by persons on haulage roads in newly opened seams would be effected by the provision of separate travelling roads on which there was no haulage, except for conveying persons. In seams already opened there could be fixed intervals when the haulage would be stopped to allow persons to travel.

The Human Element.

Minors become accustomed to danger and meet so much of it that it becomes too familiar. Safety must become second nature to them if it is to be of service.

Accident analyses, Mr. Frazer remarked, carried out at individual mines, often indicate defects or suggest improvement. For example, an analysis might disclose that one district in a mine had an exceptionally high injury rate. Attention would then be directed to that particular district and increased supervision might expose time particular defect and show the remedy. Or perhaps an analysis might prove that hand or leg injuries were more prevalent amongst a certain class of workman than others and result in gloves or shin guards being supplied to that class or else a change of methods might result in eliminating the source of danger. The more common types of accident would surely be exposed by analysis and stimulate efforts to obviate them. Accident records for districts are sometimes made the basis of a system of bonus payments to under officials.

It is difficult to suggest what measures could be made statutory. If, for instance, the appointment of a safety engineer were made compulsory, the manager's interest in safety might diminish. Possibly the allocation of an inspector in each division to safety organisation might produce results.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Frazer, Edgar Hamilton    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
18 Dec 1935  Safety Of Mine Workers, Royal Commission Personnel (The Yorkshire Post)
04 Jan 1936  Personnel Of Royal Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Feb 1936  Royal Commission Operating (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Feb 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Some Points in Evidence (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Mar 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, The Deputy's Prayer (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 May 1936  Safety In Mines, Inspectors Offer Suggestions (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 May 1936  First Hand Studies (The Science and Art of Mining)
20 Jun 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Reason Given for More Districts (The Science and Art of Mining)
18 Jul 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Midland and Southern Division (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Under-Managers Give Evidence (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Swansea Division (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Recommendations for Scottish Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Northern Division Conditions (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Sep 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, The Cardiff Area (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Sep 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Dividing Divisions into Districts (The Science and Art of Mining)
10 Oct 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, New Conditions Created (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Oct 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Firemen's Associations (The Science and Art of Mining)
07 Nov 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Evidence of Research Stations Director (The Science and Art of Mining)
21 Nov 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Major Hudspeth's Evidence on Researches (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Dec 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Under-managers' Views before Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Dec 1936  The Personal Factor (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Dec 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Colliery Officials' Views (The Science and Art of Mining)
02 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Electricity in Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 Jan 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Electricity in Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Medical Problems Considered (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Feb 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, More About Silicosis (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Feb 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Mar 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Colliery Managers' Statement (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Mar 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 Apr 1937  Mine Haulage Problems, Some Commission Pointers (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Apr 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Mineworkers' Federation (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 May 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Mining Association's Views (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Jun 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Dust Prevention Methods (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Jul 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Dangerous Conditions or Occurrences (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Jul 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Education of Mine Workers (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Aug 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Institution Council (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Aug 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Institution Council (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Dec 1938  Mines Safety Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Dec 1938  Safety Commission's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Safety In Coal Mines, Royal Commission's Recommendations (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Problems For Mining Community (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Jan 1939  Safety In Coal Mines, Royal Commission's Recommendations (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Feb 1939  Development Of Safety Legislation (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Feb 1939  Mines Safety Bill Proposed (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Feb 1939  How Mining Industry Has Changed (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Mar 1939  Colliery Ventilation (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Mar 1939  Support Of Workings (The Science and Art of Mining)
22 Apr 1939  Colliery Explosions And Fires — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 May 1939  Colliery Explosions And Fires — II, Shot-Firing Standards (The Science and Art of Mining)
03 Jun 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Jun 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — II (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — III (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — IV, Safety Organisation at Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — V, Occupational Diseases (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print