7th August 1936, Page: 275, Column: 1
Notes from the Coal Fields
Scotland
[Local Correspondence.]
In the Sheriff Court of Lanarkshire, Glasgow, Sheriff Haldane
awarded weekly compensation to R. Newall, in arbitration
proceedings under the Workmen's Compensation Act, which he brought
against his employers, James Nimmo and Co., Ltd. The claimant, who
worked in the company's colliery at Auchengeich, Chryston, as a
roadsman, alleged that on June 3, 1935, he sustained severe laceration
of the left groin and injury to pelvis by accident in the course of his
employment. His explanation of the accident was that when he went on
duty on the shift in question he was ordered by the oversman to go to
another section of the colliery to get two bogies for wood, and that he
was accompanied by a fellow workman. The men found the bogies and
coupled them on to the haulage rope. An attempt to bell on the haulage
by the claimant's fellow workman was unsuccessful. The claimant was
meantime standing in a manhole. On the fellow workman informing him
that he was proceeding no a telephone to arrange for the haulage being
started, the claimant stepped out of the manhole and started to look
for a chisel which he had lost. In doing so, the claimant was in front
of the wood bogie when the haulage suddenly started. He endeavoured to
reach a manhole, but was unsuccessful. There were a number of empty
hutches on the other line of the haulage road, and when the haulage
started the jerk caused these hutches to leave the rails and to swerve
and collide with the two wood bogies which were moving in an opposite
direction. The pressure of the hutches on the wood bogies caused the
latter to swerve in towards the manhole, blocking its entrance and
preventing the claimant from entering The claimant alleged that he was
struck by a bogie as he jumped towards the manhole, causing him to lose
his balance and fall between the two wood bogies. He averred that he
endeavoured to regain his feet. but that he was caught and that the
second bogie caused the injuries alleged. The employers denied
liability, alleging that the accident did not arise out of and in the
course of the employment, in respect that the claimant was either
walking on the haulage road, in breach of s. 43 (1) of the Coal Mines
Act, 1911, or that he was riding on the wood bogies contrary to s. 43
(2).
Sheriff Haldane awarded compensation at 29s. 2d. up to April 13,
1936. reserving all questions as to compensation in respect of any
period subsequent to that date, with expenses to the claimant. In
giving judgment, his lordship said that he saw no reason to doubt the
substantial accuracy of the account of the accident given by the
claimant, and in all essentials it was corroborated by the fellow
workman who was with him at the time. On the other hand, the suggestion
put forward on behalf of the employers that the claimant was riding on
the bogies is based on pure conjecture. The most that could be said for
it was that, in the absence of any positive evidence as to how in fact
the accident did occur, it might be as likely an explanation as that
put forward for the claimant, but there was no actual evidence at all
to prove that the accident did in fact happen in that way.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Haldane, — | | Sheriff | |
| Newall, R. | | Miner | Injured |