|
1st August 1936, Page: 26, Column: 1 Safety In Coal MinesSwansea DivisionThese notes are based on the evidence and statements of witnesses appearing before the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines. When he appeared before the Royal Commission Mr. T. Ashley, the Inspector in Charge of the Swansea Division, emphasised the point that his evidence and suggestions were confined to that Division only. Apparently no general application was intended as the conditions obtaining in many respects varied from those in other coalfields of the country. The Swansea Division, he explained, can be conveniently divided into — (1) Eastern portion consisting chiefly of large steam-coal mines won by shafts, the deepest being 714 yards. The average depth of the workings is about 450 yards. The seams usually lie at moderate inclinations and many are from five to six feet thick worked ordinary longwall. In the thinner seams mechanical conveyors have been used for some years and the number of mechanical conveyers has increased more rapidly during the last few years. Very little shot-firing is done. (2) Western portion consisting of mines working anthracite. chiefly won by slants from the outcrop. The inclination of the seams gradually increases from the Vale of Neath east wards from 1 in 15 to 1 in 3. With the exception of the Nine Feet (Big Vein or Stanllyd) the seams are approximately three feet thick and are worked longwall with stepped faces or by gravity-conveyor faces about 50 yards long. The Nine Feet seam usually, and one or two other seams, are worked single or double stall. The anthracite mines lie on the northern and north-western outcrop of the coal measures. Owing to the steepness of the measures and to the configuration of the country the workings are now carried on at depths of 300 to 500 yards, some reaching a vertical depth of 1,000 yards. At a new mine where two shafts were recently sunk six miles from the outcrop, the seams worked are over 1,000 yards deep. There is a large amount of shot-firing done in the winning of the coal. Except for a very small , mount of mechanical coal-cutting no undercutting or holing is done. Management Generally. With reference to the position and duties of managers and under-managers Mr. Ashley said :— The Act holds the manager solely responsible for matters over which he has little or no control. For instance, a few years ago a manager owing to his position as manager under the Coal Mines Act, was prosecuted and convicted for failing to fence part of the surface machinery; he had very little, if any, responsibility in the matter. The mechanic also was prosecuted and convicted, but neither the group engineer nor the agent was charged. It should have been possible to prosecute, in addition to the mechanic, the group engineer and the agent. Generally, managers in the Swansea Division are expected to confine their duties chiefly to underground work and, in some, also to the screening of the coal. hut questions, for instance, of fencing surface machinery would he dealt with usually by the agent and engineer. The position of under-managers under the present Act is similar. Better supervision would he obtained if under-managers were appointed where a total of 200 persons or more is employed underground and if power was given to the Mines Department to require two or more under-managers, according to the conditions of the mine, for instance, when several seams are worked and where the workings are extensive and scattered. Workings in the anthracite mines are very scattered and travelling is difficult. It may be of interest to note, the statement indicated, that a review of the fatal and non-fatal reportable accidents during the years 1932, 1933 and 1934 shows that 63 per cent. of the accidents occurred on the day shift, 22 per cent. on the afternoon shift and 15 per cent. on the night shift. The numbers employed either on the afternoon or the night shifts are from 25 to 50 per cent. of the number employed on the day shift, and in view of the number of accidents which occur there would appear to be need for more supervision on these shifts. At the steam-coal mines the shot-firing, which is very small in amount, and usually confined to rippings, is done during the afternoon and night shifts. At the anthracite mines, explosives being largely used in getting the coal, the largest number of shots is fired during the day shift. On the afternoon and night shifts a person holding either a First or Second-class Certificate should be appointed when more than 200 persons are employed on the shift, and where less than 200 persons are employed, a person holding a Fireman's Certificate at least should be appointed to be in charge of the whole mine. Fireman's Duties. Discussing in the precis the customs in regard to firemen and the duties they perform Mr. Ashley made the following statements :— Duties. — The custom at the mines in the Swansea Division regarding firemen's inspections is as follows : (1) At about half the mines in the steam-coal area the outgoing fireman makes the pre-shift inspection for the oncoming shift. (2) At the other half, and also at the anthracite mines, the incoming fireman comes in before the shift and makes the pre-shift inspection. The advantages of this latter system are that the shift fireman can see personally how his district stands, and it also avoids the possibility of the pie-shift inspection being made before the commencement of the statutory period of two hours. On the other hand, the fireman has to leave the district before the workmen to comply with the statutory limitation of his hours (8½). The outgoing fireman is met by the incoming fireman at the shaft or the slant mouth. The outgoing shift is seen out by the overmen, under-manager, and shotsmen where employed. While far from being universally done, three inspections are made by many firemen during the working shift., i.e., one over and above the statutory two inspections required by the Act. Mr. Ashley would suggest therefore that to enable the three inspections a shift to be made generally the size of the fireman's district might be reduced so that he could examine it within 1½ hours instead of the two-hour period now laid down. The number of inspections made depends, of course, on the size of the district and the ease with which it can he travelled, and also on the number of shots to be fired. Where a shotsman is appointed, a fireman may tire very few, if any, shots. Where a fireman has only two or three mechanical conveyor faces under his charge, he is constantly travelling the faces. Occasionally, it is found by the inspectors in the course of their duties that a fireman's district is so large as to prevent him from carrying out his statutory duties satisfactorily. Representations have always resulted in the reduction in the size of the district, usually by the appointment of another fireman. Mr. Ashley would suggest that three inspections during the shift would be made and that the first and last of these inspections should be reported. No place should remain uninspected for more than three hours, whether the mine is worked in a succession of shifts or not instead of the five hours now permitted in mines worked by a succession of shifts. Inspections as to safety under the present Act only require parts of the mine outbye of the inspection station to be examined once a week. Amendment would appear to be necessary to include a daily examination of all roads outbye of the inspection stations on which persons are to work or pass. Section 66 (d) might be amended to require all airways to he examined thoroughly twice at least in every week. Qualifications (Section 15). — Both shotsmen and firemen should be required at the qualifying examination to he able to detect lower percentages of firedamp than the 2 per cent. they are now only asked to determine, but in the case of defective sight the smaller percentages, the inspector feels sure, cannot be detected without the aid of spectacles. Shotsmen and firemen are allowed to wear glasses when being examined for the gas test and this should be recorded on their certificates. Firemen are not required to measure the air-current, and there seems no need for this to he included in the examination. The examination should include practical questions on their statutory duties on mine gasses and ventilation, support of roof and sides, the E.C.M.O. and C.M.A. Ventilation and Air Sampling. The following notes on ventilation standards, air sampling, fans inbye, and intake airways are extracted from the Inspector's statement :— Section 67 defining the standard of withdrawal at 2½ per cent. has usually been taken by managements to be the standard of ventilation. In mines where shot-firing is ordinarily carried out shot-firing is stopped when any percentage of firedamp shows on the flame of the lamp, but workmen are not withdrawn unless the gas content reaches the 2½ per cent. withdrawal limit. The standard of withdrawal (2½ per cent.) under Section 67 (2) for safety-lamp mines does not need to be reduced. As a suggestion for a standard under Section 29 (1) no district should be considered to be adequately ventilated if two or more adjacent working places in it show 1½ per cent. or upwards in the general body of the air in those places. The same standard might be applied to conveyor faces on which the conveyor is driven by compressed air. There is a considerable amount of air wasted owing to leakage between intake and return airways, and in many instances a good deal of this leakage could he avoided if a minimum distance could be maintained between these airways. Another point in connection with ventilation is the size of the return airways, which as a rule compares unfavourably with the size of the intake airways. The standard adopted at most of the steam-coal mines is to make the return airways large enough to permit a horse and tram to travel through them, the minimum height in such cases being about five feet. Air sampling. — The systematic sampling of the air of the ventilating current should be a useful guide to the management as to the state of the ventilation, and serves as a check to the under-officials. The amount of firedamp in the general body of the air varies with the amount of coal worked, etc., and the hour of the shift for taking the samples would need to be fixed. A sample only gives the amount of firedamp present at the moment it is taken and the amount constantly changes. Because of this, firemen, shotsmen and persons in charge of electrical machinery would still have to he relied upon, as they are at present, to carry out the provisions of the Act and the E.C.M.O. Inbye fans (Section 31). — Large inbye fans for the main ventilating currents are only used in a few instances. There would appear to be no need to object to their use provided that, where electrically driven, the motor and switchgear are placed in intake air and are certified flameproof. The use of small fans for ventilating places in advance of the general ventilation should be encouraged. These fans preferably should be driven by compressed air, but if driven electrically, the motor and switchgear should be certified flameproof. The use of compressed air solely, such as leakage allowed through a small bore supply pipe, should not be permitted as a means of ventilating a working place. Provision of two main intake airways Section 42 (1)). — The wording of the Section is too indefinite, and should require each road to be kept right up to the face of each ventilating district. The provision of two main intake airways seems to be desirable. The importance of the second airway is not apparent when the workings are near the shaft, but the road would be of great use when the workings have extended, apart from ventilation, either as a separate walking way, or as a man-riding haulage road. Probably, solely from a ventilation point of view, better results would be obtained if two returns to each ventilating district had to he provided instead of two intakes, but in all new large mines both two intakes and two returns in each ventilating district might be very beneficial. Exemption from the provision of two main intakes might be allowed to mines equipped to employ less than 1,000 persons underground. Timbering Systems and Packing. Giving a table showing the accident rate caused by falls of ground, 58 per cent. being due to falls of roof and 42 per cent. to falls of side, the appended statements were made by Mr. Ashley :— Falls of roof at working face. — By far the largest proportion of the fatal and serious non-fatal accidents from falls of roof at the working face occurs close to the coal face, and these usually occur while the coal is actually being got. The prevention of falls of roof at the working face is made more difficult because they seldom occur in any one seam at any one mine except at most infrequent and long intervals. Closer and more systematic support to the roof is needed, and where the coal is worked by a "holt" or "buttock" this can best be effected by the use of flats (bars). With regard to falls at and close to the rippings, a close system of timbering erected when the coal was being got would result in closer support of the roof under the ripping. Except with very close timbering distances it is necessary that further supports should be set at the road head, and this has had the special attention of the inspectors for some years. Any system of support must allow sufficient room for the collier to work. To give the least amount of obstruction with the greatest roof support flats parallel to the face should he set under the ripping edge with flats at right angles to the face set over the "roadside" props. The roof at the loading end of all conveyers, whether gravity or mechanical, should be closely supported either by steel arches or by steel flats. Falls of side at working face. — Coal in the Swansea Division is not holed or undercut by hand; the coal is worked off the slips which run obliquely through the seam. Sprags usually are only required and set when working on the "face" slip. Nearly all the seams are overlain by a clod up to 12 inches or more thick, which usually comes with the coal; the clod is a constant source of danger. Efforts are made to take some piece of overhanging clod down; these are not successful and the clod is left, when shortly after it will fall. False slips in the coal often allow more coal to come than was expected, causing the collier to be trapped. The provision and use of proper tools such as pinch bars when getting down 'coal and clod is essential. Packing. — The majority of the faces in the thinner seams is carried on road packs only supplemented in some instances, where gravity conveyors are used, by occasional cogs built either of the clod that so often lies over the seams or of wood. It has not been found that accidents are more frequent in these faces than others. In a few mechanical conveyor faces packing is given a lot of attention and continuous packs are built at regular intervals along the face. The nature of the roof on these faces gives good material for packs. Conditions generally are improved by systematic packing, and large falls are prevented and heavy weighting avoided, which probably would result if the gob was left vacant. Within recent years, the introduction of mechanical haulage near the face at two mines has enabled rubbish to be sent inbye which previously, with horse haulage, it was not possible to do on account of the gradient. The extra packing has improved the working conditions and prevented large falls along the face. The trains are man-hauled along each level stall road. Falls on roadways. — Conditions vary so greatly, and so much depends on the experience of the workmen when repairing or enlarging roads, that it does not seem possible to suggest any useful safety rules. All "timber" to be removed should be withdrawn by means of a sylvester and the smallest amount of roof should be exposed before setting the new supports. Here, protective equipment, especially hard hats and boots, would be of great service. The universal use of steel arches would reduce the amount of repair work needed and would obviate many accidents from falls on roads to persons otherwise working or passing. Causes of Haulage Accidents. In the Swansea Division the accidents due to haulage are above the average for the country, and as explained by Mr. Ashley they are caused chiefly by :— The derailment and the rerailment of the large trams. The high gradients of the seams tend to increase the injury arising from any unexpected movement of the tram. The method of direct haulage by mechanical means from near the coal face in seams of high inclination worked to the dip necessitates the employment of riders, amongst whom there are many accidents. Improperly shackled trams causing runaways. The provision of safety shackles is constantly being urged by the inspectors and all replacements are of this type. Greater clearance between trams and roof and sides. The use of steel arches keeps roads of uniform size. The large size of the tram precludes boys and youths being employed in the haulage operations, except in driving small haulage engines. Tunnelling on roads (Section 43). — Although the custom in the Swansea Division is to stop the mechanical haulages a certain time before the end of the shift and persons are not allowed to travel on these roads until the haulage is stopped, many accidents arise from illegally riding and walking on roads. The only remedy is stricter discipline. Riding men. — The Swansea Division is perhaps unique in the number of persons ridden to and from their work on underground roads. There are 47 main slants at 39 mines on which the men are ridden in and out. The inclinations of the slants vary from about six to fifteen inches to the yard, and in a few instances the inclinations are even higher. With few exceptions, special carriages are provided and the number of men ridden at one time varies from 48 to 100. It is the custom to examine the ropes and carriages once at least in every 24 hours and to report on them as if they came under Section 66 (winding machinery). It would seem to the Inspector that provision should be made for this examination in any new legislation. Explosions. Electricity. — The standard adopted in the Swansea Division has been to install flameproof electrical plant at and near the coal face in safety-lamp mines, and this requirement has met with the approval of owners and managements generally. All electrical plant, including signalling bells and telephones, which is to be used within the area next to the coal face as prescribed in the General Regulations (Lighting), of June 1st, 1934, should he certified flameproof. Shot-firing. — There is a large amount of shot-firing in the coal face in the anthracite mines. Shot-firing in the steam-coal measures is limited to a comparatively few ripping shots which are not fired during coal-getting shifts. At certain steam-coal mines it is the practice to stop all shot-firing if the barometer reads below a certain figure. Generally, ripping shots should he fired only between shifts. Mr. Ashley would like to see sand and clay stemming universally adopted. Up to the present little interest has been taken in it. Precautions against fire. — It is most desirable to have proper organisation for fighting fires both on the surface and underground. Safety Instruction for Boys. Mr. Ashley in his statement made reference to the human element., and concluded with some general comments on efforts to instruct boys in safety methods, as below :— As regards avoidable accidents underground, haulage accidents stand out far above the other classes of accidents as being due to the personal factor. Seventy-one per cent. of the accidents caused by haulage occurred during haulage operations. Keenness to get on with the job doubtless played a large part in many accidents classified as "avoidable," but many were due to thoughtless action, such as :— Standing on the narrow side of the road. Following too close behind trains and journeys. Standing outside instead of inside refuge holes. Crossing in front of slowly moving trains. Using insufficient sprags. Failure to securely shackle trains. Safety classes for boys. — In the Swansea Division safety classes for boys cannot be looked to for prevention of the "personal factor" accidents under the above classes of accidents. Except for a few boys driving haulage engines, all haulage hands in the Division are men. Boys entering the mines, after a short time on the screens, go direct to the coal face, under the charge of a collier, where they fill coal and assist the collier generally, and the chief causes of accidents to young men under 20 years of age are falls of roof and sides at the working face. Safety classes for boys were commenced in the Swansea Division in 1933 through local committees; they were continued under the auspices of the education committees of the various county councils. The attendances fell far short of the enrolments. With one or two exceptions, very little interest has been taken in this matter by owners and managers, and still less by the boys themselves. One great difficulty is to get the boys together in the evening, as so many live in large towns a long distance away from the mine at which they are employed. Owners during the latter months of 1934 took more interest in the proposed classes than they had done previously. An examination of the 15 fatal and 70 serious non-fatal accidents to young persons under 20 years of age during the three years 1933-1935 show that, if they had attended safety classes, 27 per cent. might perhaps have avoided the accidents that overtook them. Falls being the main cause of accidents to young persons, it is not easy to draw up a scheme of training in a class which would help to guard them against such accidents. Each boy is in charge of an experienced collier, who is responsible for the working of the stall.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||