|
1st August 1936, Page: 24, Column: 2 North Gawber InquiryOn Thursday, 12th September, 1935, an explosion occurred in the Nos. 3 and 4 South Districts, North Gawber (Lidgett) Mine, Yorkshire, nineteen persons losing their lives and five others being injured. An inquiry into the causes and circumstances of the explosion was conducted by Sir Henry Walker, C.B.E., LL.D. and the Mines Department has issued the Report (Cmd. 5214, 9d. net, H.M. Stationery Office) in which it is explained that the explosion was confined to parts of the Nos. 3 and 4 South Districts, which were reached at a distance of some 1,600 yards from the shafts by way of the main haulage plane, which is also the main intake airway. The Lidgett Seam in these districts is about 2' 6" thick and dips 1 in 11 to the north-east. It is a gassy seam and firedamp soon collects if the ventilation is interrupted. The coal, undercut by electrically-driven machines during the afternoon shift, was brought down by shots fired during the night shift and filled on to electrically-driven conveyors during the day shift. The total number of men employed underground was 200 on the day shift, 120 on the afternoon shift and 80 on the night shift, the output per day being some 650 tons, which was raised between the hours of 6 a.m. and 3 p.m. Shots were fired in the coal during the night shift by the deputies and shot-firers. If further shots were required in the coal during the day shift, they were fired by a shot-firer. Shots in the ripping of the levels were fired by the deputies during the afternoon shift. Cause of Explosion. The Report describes the events immediately prior to the explosion, the rescue attempts, and essential points in the investigation, concluding with the cause of the explosion. Among the witnesses who were asked their opinion as to the cause of the explosion, Mr. Cowan, Junior Electrical Inspector, said that, in spite of his detailed examinations of the electric plant, he found nothing to which the explosion could be attributed; and Mr. Horsley (Chief Electrical Inspector) said he was satisfied the explosion was not due to electricity. Mr. Cook, Senior Inspector, gave it as his opinion that firedamp in breaks communicating with the old settling gate had been ignited by the shot fired in the No. 4 South Top Airway Gate, and that this gas had burned for some time and later exploded. He referred to two somewhat similar reported cases, namely, one at Rothwell Haigh Fanny Pit and the other at Dodworth Colliery. In the former case, a shot-firer, having fired a shot in a ripping and having made an examination and being satisfied that everything was all right, had actually left the place when he was brought back by another man who was working on the face to the left of the gate and bad seen firedamp burning in the waste. The shot-firer withdrew the men from the district, and half an hour later with a deputy examined the waste and found the firedamp still burning. A further examination was made some thirty minutes later when the flame was found to be out. Mr. Cook examined this waste the same morning and found a cavity which he was able to get into and examine, but he could neither find any trace of firedamp having been burning in it, nor any sign of burning on the timber set at the edge of the cavity. In the Dodworth case, a deputy fired three shots in a ripping and, everything appearing to be in order, left the place. Some three hours later, three men who were completing the packs in the gate in which the shots had been fired heard a loud noise and saw a flash come from the face. These men went outbye and told the deputy, who examined the ripping, but found no firedamp. He instructed a ripper to set a prop to the ripping edge and, whilst this was being done, a second flash, accompanied by noise, occurred. No sign of burning was left and no further explosions occurred. Mr. Cook also referred to a further similar case which had occurred within the previous three weeks, namely at St. John's Colliery, where at 2-30 a.m. on 10th October, five minutes after the firing of the second of two shots in a ripping, the shot-firer saw flame emerge from a break which the shots had exposed. The occurrence was at once reported to the manager and he, with the under-manager, visited the place, but saw nothing further, but at 10-45 a.m. another flash of flame emerged from the break. Mr. Cook inspected the place the same day, but, whilst he was present, there was no sign of flame. He visited the place on the following day and a third time on the 12th October, in company with Mr. Humphrys, but, apart from finding that firedamp was coming from the break, there was nothing out of the ordinary to be seen. But 96 hours after the first occurrence loud rumblings in the roof were heard, and were followed by two further flashes of flame from the break. To show that flame will travel long distances in a break, Mr. Cook referred to an occurrence at Crigglestone Colliery on 4th November, 1930. Two men who were working in a gate 61 yards from where a ripping shot was fired, were burned. Firedamp in the break had been ignited by the shot; men working in intermediate gates did not see flame and were not injured. Mr. Humphrys, Divisional Inspector, said in his opinion the explosion occurred between the top of No. 4 South face and the bottom of the second outbye slit from the face off No. 3 South Level, and was due to the firing of the shot in the No. 4 South Top Airway Gate. He also drew attention to the explosions at Rothwell Haigh, Dodworth and St. John's Collieries, and added that there were grounds for thinking that firedamp continued to burn for more than a fortnight in Birley East Colliery in 1924, and that the existence of that burning was not known for a week. Having inspected the area covered by the explosion, and having heard and considered the evidence, Sir Henry Walker is of opinion that the shot fired by Friend Clayton in the No. 4 South Top Airway Gate was the originating cause of the explosion. That opinion is not capable of proof, but is based on experience and not on speculation. There can be no doubt that this shot should not have been fired. The conditions surrounding the No. 4 South Top Airway Gate were such that the ripping in that gate would be more difficult to keep up than to take down. Three shots had been fired in this ripping in six months, and it is significant that two of them had been fired within seven days of the explosion by the same man — Friend Clayton — who had only been employed on the day shift, when the ripping was done, for a fortnight. In Sir Henry's opinion, to fire a shot so close to an abandoned unventilated road — the settling gate — was extremely foolish and not the action of a thoughtful pitman. It is only fair to add that Clayton's judgment was no poorer than that of the manager and under-manager, who both said there was nothing to indicate to their minds that it would be risky to fire such a shot.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||