1st August 1936, Page: 20, Column: 2
Miners' Nystagmus
Views of Sheffield Doctor
In a letter to the BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL referring to a
report of the British Medical Association on Miners' Nystagmus,
Dr. Herbert Caiger of Sheffield says that broadly the two factors
present are the ophthalmic and the nervous. On the one hand
there are the abnormal oscillations of the eye, and on the other
the symptoms associated with them, of which dizziness is conspicuous
as a cause of disablement, in the course of his letter
the Doctor says :—
"Under present conditions of inadequate illumination most
miners present this symptom (oscillation) after thirty or more
years in the pit... The oscillations most he regarded as pathological
when they persist after the conditions necessitating them —
that is, low illumination and the attempt to fix an object — are
no longer present...
"Looking at the constantly oscillating eyes of a miner, an
ordinary experienced observer might naturally suppose that two
things would follow — namely, impairment of vision and dizziness.
in fact, in the majority of cases they are absent. . . Disability
only results when the normal inhibitory action of the nervous
system breaks down.
"The causes leading to such a breakdown are various, but have
this in common — that they directly or indirectly impair the
action of the inhibitory mechanism. Among them may be
mentioned toxic factors, such as an acute attack of tonsillitis or
influenza. (In connection with toxic absorption, it is interesting
to note that among miners it is well known that excessive drinking
or smoking is apt to be followed by a temporary exacerbation
of the disease.) An accident in or out of the pit, or psychological
causes, such as domestic bereavement, worry, or financial anxiety,
may turn the balance.
"The man's own mental attitude to the symptom of oscillation
is of great importance in this regard. He may have had oscillations
for years and have remained quite unconscious of their
presence, owing to the efficient action of the inhibitory mechanism.
Then an injudicious friend calls his attention to them ; fear is
aroused, and inhibition breaks down. Fears of blindness or loss
of health, of permanent loss of work, of inability to support his
family, are only too apt to follow so long as these cases are dealt
with as they are at present. And so a vicious circle is formed,
aggravating still more the depression of the nervous mechanism.
Industrial fear is a potent influence militating against cure.
"The radical prevention and core of miners' nystagmus is
simple enough in theory in view of these considerations. Give
efficient illumination in the pits, and there will he no oscillations,
no fresh cases will arise, and existing cases will improve. Do
everything possible to maintain at its highest capacity the miner's
nervous system; get rid of industrial fear, and the groundless
fear of blindness which still exists. Modern improvements in
pit lamps and lighting have brought the first measure within
the hounds of practical possibilities, and some progress is being
made here towards prevention. But the other measure which
is absolutely essential for cure in many of these cases — the provision
of suitable occupation — is still very tardy of accomplishment...
"The present method of dealing with these cases only too often
aggravates the depressed nervous condition.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Caiger, Herbert, Dr. | | | |