1st August 1936, Page: 17, Column: 1
Protective Clothing For Rescue Brigades
The question of Protective Clothing for Rescue Brigades was
considered by Mr. G. L. Brown, Assoc. H.W. college, in a paper
at Bath before the institution of Mining Engineers, He referred
to experience he had of fighting underground fires to illustrate
the occasional need for sonic equipment that will assist brigades
(1) to penetrate to the seat, of fire and form a working-base for
direct attack without delay; (2) to go farther than is normally
possible into a fire area to extinguish flame or to cool heated
materials; (3) to position monitors for directing water on the
extreme end of a fire or other section of it. About two years ago
he tried asbestos suits, as used by fire brigades, and came to the
conclusion that they were unsuitable for work at underground
fires, as the conditions generally are different from those which
occur at surface fires. More recently, rescue station authorities
have been considering the suitability of modified types of asbestos
suits, of which samples have been tried in a hot chamber at the
Mansfield Rescue Station and comparison made with other kinds
of clothing.
From experience in attacking fires behind seals with breathing
apparatus, and the men wearing a minimum of clothing, it appears
that the limit of endurance is half-hour periods doing light work
in temperatures of about 120° dry bulb and 95°F. wet bulb. To
be of practical value, therefore, improved equipment should
permit of brigades operating for at least similar periods in higher
temperatures, say up to 200° dry bull and 110°F. wet bulb.
Working in High Temperatures.
Pointing out that under conditions obtaining at mine fires
special clothing would protect only against intense radiant heat,
Mr. Brown said tests were made in high temperatures to find out
which type of clothing was least uncomfortable and for what
periods members of rescue brigades wearing breathing apparatus
could do light work at various wet- and dry-bulb temperatures,
the conclusions being :—
Clothing of any kind is most uncomfortable to wear once the
body temperature begins to rise, this occurring in 20-go minutes
at wet-bulb temperatures above blood-heat.. If effort is continued
beyond this, a condition of extreme lassitude quickly
occurs.
Asbestos clothing is least suitable, as it soon attains the temperature
of the surrounding hot air and conducts heat readily
to the body and to the inspired air when in contact with metal
air-pipes. When used with a lining of other material the discomfort
is increased due to the extra weight.
Less discomfort occurs when wool flannel covering is used on
the body and apparatus. It is a better and lighter insulator.
Least discomfort occurs when only ordinary trousers and wool
shirt are worn, particularly at wet-bulb temperatures above
blood-heat and dry-bulb temperatures of 120-130°F., but with
the latter at 200°F. it is necessary to add a wool flannel hood and
gloves to prevent scorching of the skin and burning of the face
where metal parts of the apparatus touch it.
From this it is obvious that complete protection of the body
is necessary for brigades to enter extremely hot areas when
attacking fires. They would not be able to advance far under
these conditions, as both rise in body temperature and the temperature
of the inspired air from the apparatus would limit them
to short-distance and short-period work. For the same reasons,
extensive explorations should not be attempted in roadways filled
with extremely hot gases coming from a fire.
An important factor when working in high temperatures with
breathing apparatus, Mr. Brown said, is the condition of the
inspired air. Dr. Haldane has referred to the possibility of
breathing dry air at 230°F. in a similar environment, and
Dr. E. M. Killick has shown that moist air at 135°F. can be breathed
in a cool environment up to 1½ hours without increase in body
temperature. In the tests that had been made it was shown that
the limiting dry- and wet-bulb temperatures are much less than
those mentioned when conditions of environment cause fairly
rapid rise in body temperature.
It is of interest to note, the Author added, that when caustic
soda absorbent is used discomfort is caused by dry throat, due
to breathing air which is too dry in the period possible to use an
apparatus. With soda-lime absorbent, discomfort is caused by
breathing hot moist air which scorches the throat. The latter
feeling is more discomforting than dry throat, and occurs earlier.
At high dry-bulb temperatures the discomfort caused by both
dry and moist inspired air occurs before discomfort due to rise in
body temperature. In practical work this fact, along with
checking of pulse rates, serves to warn brigades of approaching
tendency to heat-stroke. They should then withdraw.
Operations with breathing apparatus should not be conducted
where the external wet-bulb temperature exceeds 98°F., or where
the dry-bulb temperature exceeds 120°F. The former limitation
is necessary to avoid extreme body discomfort, and the latter to
avoid discomfort from breathing dry or moist air caused by the
nature of the absorbent and heating of air in metal pipes and
"coolers." These limitations are for working periods of 20-30
minutes doing light work.
Working in high temperatures is limited to the capabilities
of the breathing apparatus independently of the suitability of
clothing to protect the body against external heat.
In July, 1934, members of rescue brigades and other workmen
were burned by an explosion of gas while they were attacking
an underground fire. Mr. Brown investigated the nature and
extent of their injuries and in his paper gave full particulars
to assist in forming an opinion as to the extent and kind of clothing
needed. Presenting his conclusions he said :—
Because of the positions of the brigade members at the time
of the ignition, and the nature of their burns, I think they were
burned by the hot gases resulting from the explosion rather than
by flame. They were not burned where ordinary clothing properly
covered the body ; the most severe burns were those affecting
the exposed hands and face. Those with more than minimum
clothing (shirt and trousers) were burned less extensively, especially
when fully buttoned about the neck, chest, and arms. From this
it is concluded that the air normally enclosed about the body
was not displaced by burning hot gases, which expanded into the
roadways. If the head and hands had been clothed by woollen
hood and gloves, respectively, it appears certain their burns
would have been greatly minimised, if not altogether prevented.
As their burns were confined mostly to hands, arms, face and
neck, it seems essential that these parts should also be covered,
despite any slight, discomfort, which is not considerable when
working in normal temperatures.
"It is significant to note that there was no burning or scorching
of clothing or apparatus. Those who wore apparatus were also
protected, both back and front, by the leather parts. Light
leather overalls or a boiler suit worn over ordinary trousers and
shirt would, under similar circumstances, form a suitable body
protection providing the whole is fully buttoned up. To complete
the covering, gauntlet gloves should be worn to protect the hands
and prevent hot gases being blown up the sleeves, and ?????
fitting hood. preferably of wool flannel, is required to protect
the face and neck. A strap should be provided on the trousers
at each ankle, but if not, the bottoms should be tucked inside the
socks to prevent the hot gases being blown up the legs. A hard
hat and knee pads give added protection."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Brown, G. L. | | | |