|
24th July 1936, Page: 176, Column: 1 Notes from the Coal FieldsNorth Wales[Local Correspondence.] In view of published statements that are likely to cause misapprehension, an official of Gresford Colliery stated this week that only a slight improvement, and not a "big" one, had been ascertained from the analyses made by the chemical experts at Birmingham University to which air samples from behind the stoppings in Gresford Colliery are forwarded periodically; and, the official added, unless the present rate of improvement was accelerated a very considerable time would elapse before there could be any justification for running the risk of breaking the seals and entering the affected area. On Thursday of last week, Mr. Hartley Shawcross continued his speech on behalf of the owners of the colliery at the inquiry in London into the Gresford pit disaster. He said there were no limits to the fantasy which certain witnesses called by the Mineworkers' Federation were prepared to create. Certain evidence about stone-dusting would be laughable if it were not so disgraceful. That was the evidence on the one side, he added. On the other side there was a great deal of positive evidence that week after week over a long period stone-dusting had been going on in the Gresford mine. Regarding the allegation of shotfiring on a main haulage road, Mr. Shawcross said one might go so far as to say in general, that it was far safer to fire a shot on a haulage road, such as the one which was suggested, than firing shots at the working face. It was in fact an auxiliary haulage road. As to the blocking up of the ventilation opening into 24's district, he said that three of the miners had given conflicting evidence. One said it was closed three weeks before the explosion, another two months, and a third three months before. They might all three have been giving evidence which was false. After the hole had been opened on the Tuesday it had been closed over with sleepers, which were placed there in order to keep the gas in. and then some stones were thrown over the sleepers, "the better to assist that curious process" The gas at Gresford apparently had unusual properties according to the evidence. It travelled downhill, it kept to the floor rather than to the roof. It made the arms of some of the miners turn black, and now it is said it could be kept in a hole under some sleepers, remarked Mr. Shawcross. That was the kind of evidence which was seriously put before the inquiry. It was evidence so conflicting as to be utterly unreliable, so fantastic as to be absolutely untrue. He submitted that the inquiry would probably come to the conclusion without any difficulty that, although the evidence was not unanimous on the matter, on the weight of the evidence air was going into the opening. Mr. Shawcross referred to an alteration of the plan of the mine exhibited on the twentieth day of the inquiry, and said that some of the witnesses called earlier had described conditions existing at a certain place in 14's district when, in fact, there was no such place. He submitted that there were good roads going into 14's district and an ample volume of air was passing. Could the evidence about the gas at the face conceivably be true? He referred again to the inaccuracy in the original plan. Sir Henry Walker explained that the original plan showed that coal had been worked 12 yd. above the return airway in 14's district. After the twentieth day, when the plan was altered, it showed that there was no top side to the return, and therefore men could not have been 12 yd. above the return. On Friday Mr. Shawcross spoke of the evidence of 13 men with regard to stone-dusting just before an inspector's visit in one of the districts as concerted perjury. Mr. Shawcross said that the pit was not very different from another. It was a pit in which there was nothing to suggest the existence of any special dangers or the possibility of any such disaster as took place. But disaster did come, just as it had come before in a pit in which there had been no possibility for just criticism of previous conditions. The parties to the inquiry were entitled to discuss and the public were entitled to know to what extent, if at all, conditions about which complaint was being made had any possible hearing on the cause of the disaster. The owners would have desired to call expert evidence in regard to that matter in order that the public should know the opinions of experts. They might, he said, have had some assistance from the Miners' Federation. They had hoped that after the attack on the conditions they might have been able to say where it all led. They might have been able to assist, by showing what bearing their allegations might have had on the cause of the disaster. But the attack which has been made on the conditions in the pit led nowhere, unless it was in the possible direction of some condemnation of private ownership in the mining industry. But that was not the purpose of this inquiry. Mr. Shawcross said it was certain that before there could have been a sufficient accumulation of gas in an explosive percentage in 14's or 95's districts, the lamps of the men working there would have gone out and the continuation of working would hove become impossible. Work would have been stopped and the alarm would have been given. Work did not stop and the explosion came upon the men unawares. Unfortunately at this stage it was not possible to prove with certainty where the explosion did occur, although one could establish with reasonable certainty certain places where it could have occurred. One theory had been expounded regarding the possibility that there was a sudden outburst of gas from the stonedrift at the clutch. That was one of the possibilities, one of the probabilities, present to the minds of the experts. North Wales on the whole has been fortunately free from heating of that kind, bat there have been instances in the same main seam of coal which ran through the Gresford pit of heating. It was an odd circumstance — and it might be more than a coincidence that many years ago a Mr. Charlton visited the pit and thought that there was a gob stink there. Two days before the disaster there was a smell which might have been that of a gob stink fire. He hoped that the time spent on the inquiry would not be in vain. Unfortunately from the way in which the inquiry developed owing to the attitude of the Miners' Federation, a great deal of time had to be taken up by repelling the attacks made upon the owners. He did not regard them as having constituted any kind of useful purpose to the real objects of the inquiry, but they were attacks and allegations which had to be answered and repelled. Safety in the mines of this country is not to be achieved by an atmosphere of recrimination which developed between the miners and the owners in this inquiry. Safety in the mines can only be achieved by loyal co-operation between the miners themselves on the one hand and the owners on the other. Although it had been part of his duty to criticise and even to attack the conduct of a number of individuals who gave evidence because they had given evidence which was not true, that criticism was directed and that attack was made only against particular individuals. It was not part of his case here to attack in any way the miners as a body of men. The inquiry ended, and Sir Henry and his assessors will now prepare their report. Col. R. W. Williams-Wynn, the Lord-Lieutenant of Denbighshire, presided over the quarterly meeting of the Central Board of the Gresford Colliery Disaster Relief Fund, which was held at Chester last Saturday. A statement of disbursements during the quarter ended June 30, 1936, showed that the number of persons drawing relief totalled 558, including 159 widows, 218 children, 56 fathers and 85 mothers. Four widows remarried during the three months under review, bringing the total of remarriages to 12. The total amount paid to dependants was £5,017, which included £150 for marriage grants and £121 in respect of education of children. Further details of expenditure, together with the auditors' report, were issued subsequently, covering the periods from September 22. 1934, to July 30, 1935 (the date of the trust deed), and from July 31. 1935, to December 31, 1935. The total receipts of the two funds (the Mansion House and the Denbighshire). which have since been amalgamated, amounted to £566,547, and up to July 30 last year the disbursements from the Denbighshire fund were £57,660, and from the Mansion House fund £1,039, leaving a credit balance on that date of £507,847. Allowances and grants to widows and dependants amounted to £19,747, and to the men who became unemployed through the disaster to £36,135. General administration expenses were £1,218. In the second period, namely, the five months ended last December, widows and' dependants received £9,620, sad unemployed £4,422. General administration cost £556. The Mansion House expenditure was £211. On December 31 the fund had a balance of £496,716, of which £426,700' is invested, while the rest is on deposit account, but includes. £30,800 which is earmarked for payment of calls on the holding of 2½ per cent. guaranteed debenture stock. This private secretary to the Lord Mayor of London and Mr. A. W. Hersee, secretary to the Central Board, descended the Gresford pit on Saturday afternoon and inspected the workings under the guidance of the manager, Mr. T. S. Charlton.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||