Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

18th July 1936, Page: 10, Column: 1

Safety In Coal Mines

Midland and Southern Division

These notes are based on the evidence and statements of witnesses appearing before the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines.

The Midland and Southern Division contains the coalfields of Cannock Chase, South Staffs, and Worcester, Warwickshire, Shropshire, Somerset, Bristol and Kent, in each of which, Mr. E. Rowley the Inspector in Charge informed the Royal Commission, totally different mining conditions obtain. The seams vary in thickness from two feet in Somerset to upwards of twenty feet in South Staffs. and the southern portion of Warwickshire.

As regards the inspectorate, Mr. Rowley has felt for a some time that if clerical assistance was given to senior inspectors it would add to the efficiency of the service. He also thinks that as such the sub-inspector grade should be discontinued. He favours the making of arrangements by which the workmen should take advantage of Section 141 of the Coal Mines Act and make an inspection of the whole of the workings of every mine at least once in every three months.

Allocation of Responsibility.

In his statement relating to organisation and management generally Mr. Rowley expressed his views on statutory responsibility as follows :—

Owner. — As under the present Act, with the inclusion possibly of a clause similar to Section 141 of the Factory and Workshop Act ; no owner should take an active part in the technical management of the mine unless he is the holder of a first class certificate of competency.

Agent. — No person should be appointed to be an agent of a mine (except in the case of a small mine) who is not the holder of a first class certificate of competency. When undertaking any active control of the management, he should be subject to all the responsibilities of the manager.

Manager. — The manager, unless there is an agent over him having equal or better qualifications, should have full authority, as he has full responsibility, to manage his mine to the best of his ability.

Under-manager. — There should be one or more under-managers for every mine where more than 400 persons are employed underground. There should be a separate under-manager in charge on every shift upon which 100 persons or more are employed underground. His duties and responsibilities should be confined to underground matters, with the exception of such control over matters on the surface as directly affect his responsibilities underground, he should not be expected to control or be responsible for, or countersign, reports which are directly the work of the engineer.

Engineer or Enginewright. — The engineer should be a competent person appointed by the manager to superintend the working of all the machinery, and to ensure that the requirements of the law as to machinery are properly carried out. He should hold the same authority and be subject to the same responsibilities as the under-manager in respect of the surface works. At present he has no responsibility under the Act.

Electrician. — He should have the duties and responsibilities as laid down in the present Act and Regulations.

General managers or agents : chief mechanical engineers and electrical engineers. — In the case of large mines or concerns working several mines, general managers or agents should be holders of first class certificates of competency. They should have full control of the undertaking, and should shoulder in every case full responsibility under the law. Chief mechanical and electrical engineers should have full responsibility under the law for all acts and omissions committed by themselves, and should consult the manager as to the work contemplated if it touches any of his responsibilities.

Contractors. — They should be responsible for their own acts and omissions under the law, and be subject with their workmen to the orders and arrangements of the manager, and should have with their workmen the same responsibilities and liabilities whilst on the premises, as if they were employees of the mine.

Mining surveyors. — Outside firms or persons engaged in making the statutory surveys of the mine should be liable for compliance with the law as if they were employed at the mine.

Status of Deputies.

System of examination. — It is suggested by Mr. Rowley that the qualifications required from candidates for the deputy's position should be entirely practical ones, and any examination such candidates might be required to pass should be designed to test their knowledge of the practical matters they will have to deal with in their daily work. The examination should be oral, with the exception of requiring the candidate to write a specimen report in the authorised Firemen's Report Book. It should be conducted by colliery managers who are qualified to test the practical knowledge and suitability of the candidates for the position. A candidate should not be passed unless he is able to detect 1 per cent, of inflammable gas on the flame of a safety-lamp.

It is, in the Inspector's opinion, desirable, especially in view of modern mining with all its problems of mechanisation, that the status of the deputy should be increased. He should be, as his name implies, one who in his district is deputising for the manager. He has a very responsible position, and the remuneration should be such as to attract the best men.

Duties. — The duties of the deputies as defined in the Coal Mines Act. 1911, and General Regulations, should remain as they are, but in order that they might be better carried out, the size of the district assigned to a deputy should be such that he can inspect every part of it in 1½ hours. He should devote the whole of his time to his statutory duties, and should be given no duties in connection with the getting of output, other than perhaps the firing of a limited number of shots. Any spare time which he may have should be devoted to the education of his workmen with a view to effecting a reduction of the accidents due to the human element. The present period of two hours for making the inspection previous to the commencement of work in the shift should be reduced to 1½ hours. Three inspections should be made during each shift, and one report in which should be recorded all the defects observed. The present unsatisfactory position in regard to the inspection of the parts of the mine outbye of the deputies' station, should be remedied by the inclusion of such workings in Section 66 (d) of the Act, and requiring a thorough examination to be made of them at least once in every 24 hours.

Workmen's Inspections.

A table was put in which showed that the workmen in the Division take advantage of the provisions of Section 16 of the Act, and make inspections of the workings, in the Kent coalfield only and to a lesser extent in South Staffs, and Warwickshire. The general failure of the workmen in this respect is regretted by the Inspector, who says it appears to be due partly to apathy, but largely to the question of payment. He is of opinion that the inspection, which would be confined solely to safety matters, would have a beneficial effect upon officials and workmen. In his Division an inspection of the whole of the workings would occupy approximately 500 shifts, and from this information it would be an easy matter to estimate the cost. A complete inspection of the largest mine would probably take from twelve to fifteen shifts. The Inspector does not know of any better welfare work than inspecting in regard to safety, and his recommendation would be that it should be paid for out of the Miners' Welfare Fund, though he does not very much mind who pays so long as the inspection is done.

Concentration and the Safety Problem.

Regarding methods of work and equipment the main change which has taken place may be summed up in the term "concentration," which generally implies the getting of a large output from a comparatively short working face divided into units of suitable length, each of which must produce a definite quantity of coal daily. The increase of electrically operated machinery, coupled with the concentration of output, has produced both disadvantages and advantages from the point of view of safety, which Mr. Rowley summarises as under :—

Disadvantages. — (a) The cycle of operations, coal-cutting, conveyor shifting, brushing, packing and stripping, must be maintained over three shifts. A delay in any one operation affects all the others. This tends at times to more hurry and the taking of greater risks which otherwise would not be taken.

(b) There is no time for a full repairing shift on normal working days, and not always at week-ends.

(c) There is a good deal of noise, and men are more closely packed.

(d) There is less working space at the face, thus tending to restrict the free movement of a man.

(e) The mere presence of moving machinery is an added danger.

(f) The men employed at the face have not the skill of the old-time miner. They are largely merely fillers of coal, and have not the same interest in maintaining the working place in good condition. This state of affairs is likely to get worse rather than better, owing to the difficulty in providing proper training for face workers. In the old days a boy went to work, usually with his father, and naturally he was taught how to keep himself safe — one of the first considerations.

(g) The greater rate of face advance has brought in its train difficult problems of roof control.

(h) Possibilities of accidents arising from electric shock and the ignition of inflammable gas are increased.

(i) Almost as many men are employed on night and afternoon shifts as there are on the day shift, but the supervision by the higher officials is not in proportion.

Advantages. — (a) The length of roadways needing to be maintained has been reduced, and a greater output has to pass over these shorter roads. This has resulted in the roads being kept in better condition, largely by the use of better methods of support, e.g., the steel arch girder.

(b) The better roads have resulted in better ventilation, so reducing the chances of explosions.

(c) The concentration of the working area allows of better supervision by the under-officials.

(d) As falls of ground on a roadway or at the face may affect a large proportion of the output, both roadways and face are more systematically supported, steel being used effectively in the form of girders, straps and props.

(e) Haulage tracks, ropes and plant generally are maintained in better condition.

(f) A staff of qualified tradesmen, engineers, electricians, etc., has to be maintained.

These factors — advantages and disadvantages — would appear to have had little or no effect on the accident rate, as the figures have remained practically stationary. One must conclude, therefore, in the view of Mr. Rowley, that so far they have neutralised each other.

Blasting. — Several changes have occurred in blasting practice in recent years, chief amongst them being: (a) The intrinsically safe single-shot battery ; (b) Non-flame producing methods, such as Cardox, Hydrox and the hydraulic burster; (c) Sand-clay stemming ; (d) Stone-dusting. The effects of these changes, all of which are designed to reduce the possibility of explosions of inflammable gas and coal dust, cannot be estimated.

It is noticeable that, over a period of six years, the amount of explosive used has remained almost stationary, whereas the number of shots fired has increased, i.e., the charge per shot has decreased. The Inspector further observes that it is probably one of the results of intensive mining, where the general practice is to fire shots placed about six feet apart along the whole length of a working unit. The increase in the number of shots fired is an added potential danger, as obviously the greater the number of shots fired the greater is the chance of mishap.

Ventilation Standards.

The number of mines in Mr. Rowley's Division in which safety-lamps are used forms only 27 per cent. approximately, of the whole, and amongst these there are several in which safety-lamps are used as a precautionary measure only. On the other hand, he says it should be noted that the major portion of the mines using naked lights are small mines. It is, however, fair to say that there are no "very gassy" pits in the Division, and that the standard of ventilation on the whole is good. Nevertheless, Mr. Rowley is of the opinion that the provisions of the Act and Regulations relating to ventilation should be clarified and in some aspects strengthened. At the present time the only standard is a qualitative one contained in Sections 29, 32, 60 and 67, and even as regards quality there is no standard of temperature.

In some ways it might be advantageous to have a quantitative standard, but, so far, the difficulties of arriving at a basis for classifying the various types of mines in a manner permitting of such a standard have eluded solution. It is however desirable, Mr. Rowley considers, to improve the qualitative standard in the light of modern methods of mining, which have resulted in men being concentrated on rapidly advancing faces, worked in most cases by electrically operated machinery and giving off increased quantifies of inflammable gas.

He suggests for consideration the addition to Section 29 (3) of the following standard :—

(a) Where naked lights are used, the air shall not contain more than 1 per cent. of inflammable gas, or more than 2 per cent, where safety-lamps are used ; (b) the temperature shall not exceed 84°F., wet bulb.

Questions relating to the use of safety-lamps, electricity and shot-firing must be considered in relation to ventilation, and he put forward the following suggestions :—

(a) That it should not be permissible to use electricity in any working face or in any place in which the air is found normally to contain 1 per cent. or more of inflammable gas, and that the current shall be cut off immediately this figure is reached ; (b) that shot-firing should not be permissible on any working face or in any place in which the general body of the air is found normally to contain 1 per cent. or more of inflammable gas.

To enable these provisions to be carried out systematic sampling would be necessary, and Mr. Rowley suggests that samples of air shall be taken and the results recorded : (a) weekly at the face where safety-lamps are required to be used, if shot-firing is done or electricity is used ; (b) monthly in all other cases.

As a general principle he would like to see all upcast shafts provided with a proper air-lock, and, as regards electrically driven auxiliary fans underground, the motor should always be in the intake.

"Falls" — Suggested Overhaul.

What little improvement there has been in his Division from accidents under the general heading, falls of ground, is disappointing to Mr. Rowley in view of the extent to which steel is now used. As in numbers so the causes of accidents at the working face remain unchanged, and it would appear to him that more drastic steps than have yet been adopted will have to be taken if the desired reduction is to be obtained. With regard to falls of roof at the working face, the great aim should be to keep the roof under which work is being done unbroken. There are, however, so many factors affecting this, that it is only by extended observation and experiment that the method likely to give the best results can be determined.

With a view to effecting a decrease in accidents from falls of roof and side, he suggests :—

(a) At working face. — (1) A complete overhaul of the method of working by the officials of every mine to ascertain whether some modification would effect an improvement in the roof condition. (2) The use of steel props and bars where conditions are suitable. (3) An intensive system of support, leaving a minimum area of roof unsupported, so as to prevent detached pieces of roof falling away, (d) A revision of the Timbering Rides on intensive lines. (3) The systematic support of the coal face where coal-cutting machines are used in seams of upwards of 3½ feet in thickness or when the inclination exceeds 1 in 12 of a face worked to the rise. (6) Intensive support of way-heads. (7) Increased supervision and education of the workmen.

(b) On roadways. — (1) The systematic support, preferably by steel, of all roadways at maximum intervals of six feet. (2) The use of temporary supports at ripping lips. (3) The use of duplicate carrying bars at all junctions.

Haulage Accidents Abnormal.

A table put in by Mr. Rowley shows that the proportion of preventable accidents under haulage is abnormally high, and he would not deem it an over-statement to say that a reduction could and should be brought about. He says the high proportion of boys employed in this kind of work makes it essential that measures shall be devised to correct the results of their natural inexperience and impetuosity. With this end in view the following suggestions are made :—

(a) A definite system of training of boys before and after starting work underground, (b) Better lighting, (c) Larger roads giving increased clearance, especially where coupling and clipping operations are carried out. It is suggested that a minimum clearance between the sides and roof and the tubs, and also between tubs, should be laid down for all haulage roads, (d) The provision and maintenance of better tracks, (e) The pavements of travelling and haulage roads to be made more even. (f) A systematic inspection of tubs, couplings, clips, ropes, chains, etc., by properly qualified persons. Draw bars, couplings and chains should be annealed at stated intervals, (g) The prohibition of persons from travelling with sets of tubs operated by rope haulages. (h) The provision of separate travelling roads in new districts, and elsewhere, if possible, together with main haulages. If separate travelling roads are not provided, the haulage should be stopped for a suitable period at the beginning and end of a shift on any inclined haulage roads which men have to travel.

Explosions Surveyed.

A brief examination of the explosions occurring in his Division over a period of seven years suggested to Mr. Rowley that the following are the conclusions to be drawn :—

(a) The use of certified electrical apparatus in all places where safety-lamps are required to be used is necessary, (b) That better education and discipline of the human element is required, (c) The provision of proper coursing of an adequate ventilating current is essential.

Tackling Avoidable Accident Problem.

An analysis of the reportable accidents in the period already referred to, as given by Mr. Rowley in his statement to the Commission, gives an average percentage of 53 as having been avoidable by ordinary caution. Obviously, he said, this offers a field which, treated in the right manner, ought to produce fruitful results, and he proceeded to discuss the question as follows :—

This treatment should begin as early as possible, i.e., with boys before they enter the pit. Classes might be formed, as they have been done by certain colliery companies, in which the boys are given lectures on safety methods by practical colliery officials. This training should be continued after the boy has started work underground.

The training should be designed : (a) To teach the boys to observe and to think. At the root of many of the accidents caused by carelessness or indiscipline is a failure of the individual to appreciate the results of his own acts, i.e., he does not think; but unless he observes he has no foundations for his thoughts. The boys, therefore, should have their powers of observation developed, and at the same time should be trained to draw the correct inference from what they observe, (b) The order and method of carrying out many operations in a pit can be standardised. The best and safest method of doing a job having been decided, boys should be trained in that method until it becomes automatic, (c) During the period of training the opportunity should be taken of observing the aptitude of individual boys for a particular type of job. So far as is possible they should subsequently be detailed for the kind of work to which they are best suited.

In (b) the standardisation of doing certain jobs in a certain manner is mentioned ; this system might be extended to adult workers. As the result of the experience of the management, aided for preference by a safety committee consisting of representatives of each section of the men, the best way of doing certain work could be decided and standardised. The results could be incorporated in pamphlet form and given to each worker — the observance of the directions being made a condition of employment. From time to time the code so devised could be extended in the light of experience.

Such a scheme would place a good deal of work and responsibility on the officials, but Mr. Rowley says there is no easy road to a reduction in the accident rate. Only by constant vigilance and insistence on safe methods can such a result be obtained. That vigilance and insistence must in the first place, come from the officials, from the highest to the lowest, and by them must be instilled into the men. An official observing an unsafe practice should at once stop it, explain why it is unsafe, and show the safe practice. The Inspector is satisfied that risks are taken chiefly from thoughtlessness, and that if individuals can be induced to think before they take a risk, "What do I stand to gain if it comes off, and what do I stand to lose if it does not come off ?" far fewer needless risks will be run, and far fewer accidents will occur. If individuals repeat unsafe practices after they have been warned, they should be dealt with strictly. By these methods the men will learn what is safe, and at the same time discipline will be taught and maintained.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Rowley, Elijah    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
18 Dec 1935  Safety Of Mine Workers, Royal Commission Personnel (The Yorkshire Post)
04 Jan 1936  Personnel Of Royal Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Feb 1936  Royal Commission Operating (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Feb 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Some Points in Evidence (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Mar 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, The Deputy's Prayer (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 May 1936  Safety In Mines, Inspectors Offer Suggestions (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 May 1936  First Hand Studies (The Science and Art of Mining)
20 Jun 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Reason Given for More Districts (The Science and Art of Mining)
18 Jul 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Midland and Southern Division (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Under-Managers Give Evidence (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Swansea Division (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Recommendations for Scottish Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Northern Division Conditions (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Sep 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, The Cardiff Area (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Sep 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Dividing Divisions into Districts (The Science and Art of Mining)
10 Oct 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, New Conditions Created (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Oct 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Firemen's Associations (The Science and Art of Mining)
07 Nov 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Evidence of Research Stations Director (The Science and Art of Mining)
21 Nov 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Major Hudspeth's Evidence on Researches (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Dec 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Under-managers' Views before Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Dec 1936  The Personal Factor (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Dec 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Colliery Officials' Views (The Science and Art of Mining)
02 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Electricity in Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 Jan 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Electricity in Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Medical Problems Considered (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Feb 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, More About Silicosis (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Feb 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Mar 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Colliery Managers' Statement (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Mar 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 Apr 1937  Mine Haulage Problems, Some Commission Pointers (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Apr 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Mineworkers' Federation (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 May 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Mining Association's Views (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Jun 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Dust Prevention Methods (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Jul 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Dangerous Conditions or Occurrences (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Jul 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Education of Mine Workers (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Aug 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Institution Council (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Aug 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Institution Council (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Dec 1938  Mines Safety Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Dec 1938  Safety Commission's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Safety In Coal Mines, Royal Commission's Recommendations (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Problems For Mining Community (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Jan 1939  Safety In Coal Mines, Royal Commission's Recommendations (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Feb 1939  Development Of Safety Legislation (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Feb 1939  Mines Safety Bill Proposed (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Feb 1939  How Mining Industry Has Changed (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Mar 1939  Colliery Ventilation (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Mar 1939  Support Of Workings (The Science and Art of Mining)
22 Apr 1939  Colliery Explosions And Fires — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 May 1939  Colliery Explosions And Fires — II, Shot-Firing Standards (The Science and Art of Mining)
03 Jun 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Jun 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — II (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — III (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — IV, Safety Organisation at Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — V, Occupational Diseases (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print