|
17th July 1936, Page: 131, Column: 2 Notes from the Coal FieldsNorth WalesThe Gresford Inquiry[Local Correspondence.] The Gresford Colliery inquiry was continued in London this week. On Tuesday Mr. H. P. Harris, of the National Association of Colliery Managers, referred to the attack made previously by Mr. Hall on Mr. Bonsell, the manager of the colliery. He read a statement which showed that at a meeting of Gresford miners on June 21, a resolution was unanimously carried in which it was stated that the men "resented Mr. Hall's attack on Mr. Bonsell . . . and that Mr. Bonsell had behaved well to the men and had treated them properly." Mr Shawcross, for the owners, opened his remarks by saying that it was the desire of those he represented to refrain from referring to the attacks made upon them until the proper time. After remarking that lies had been told in the evidence adduced by the Mineworkers' Federation, Mr. Shawcross said he would not attempt to whitewash the administration of the pit and would not suggest that there were not matters, perhaps a number of matters, which called for criticism. An attempt had been made by the use of language of unexampled extravagance, by magnification and exaggeration of small points, to give an impression of general conditions in the pit which was wholly false. The attack on the owners and officials was an unjustifiable one based on evidence upon which no judicial tribunal could conceivably act. Referring to the allegations that the doorways in the 20's return airway had been concealed, Mr. Shawcross said that this was an unjustifiable suggestion, indeed, it was a nonsensical suggestion, since there was no reason to attempt to conceal these doorways. Alluding to the "faked figures" episode at the previous hearing, Mr. Shawcross remarked that the question of false figures in the ventilation system was undoubtedly a sensational matter, but it was one which might easily be exaggerated. He appealed for the Commission to see this thing in a proper perspective. He did not want the proper course of the inquiry to be side-tracked. So far they had only heard one side of the matter, and had not heard Mr. Bonsell's explanation. Recalling the evidence, Mr. Shawcross said that Mr. Cuffin, the assistant surveyor, shortly after the disaster recollected that the statistics for July and August had not been entered. Mr. Bonsell then said under the stress and strain of that moment — it was within literally a few hours of the terrible catastrophe, — "Well, put them in (meaning the figures) ; put anything in," and Cuffin did so. Explaining how it was "understandable" for Mr. Bonsell to use words of this kind, Mr. Shawcross said that they had to remember his condition. He was distracted and distraught. No one who had seen him at the end of this inquiry — at the end of his career, a broken man — could not but understand the strain he had undergone. They might perhaps understand and excuse him. Mr. Shawcross said that Mr. Bonsell had acted as a fool, but it was very difficult to think of him as a knave. Alluding to Sir Stafford Cripps' ejaculation, "Send the papers to the Director of Public Prosecutions," Mr. Shawcross said "If this inquiry had been presided over by a judge my learned friend would not have dared to attempt to influence the course to be taken by the Tribunal. It is an easy thing to kick a man when he is down. It is not always useful ; it is not always necessary." Mr. Shawcross then referred to Mr. Hall. He said he would not call Mr. Hall's contribution an address — it was an harangue. He did not confine himself to commenting upon evidence. He expressed his own personal views. Later, Mr. Shawcross said it was the intention of the owners of the colliery to explore as far as they could the affected Dennis area, and this would be done as soon as such work was possible with reasonable safety. The owners were doing everything they could to open up and explore the district, and so far every investigation which it had been possible to make had yielded something of importance and assistance to the owners case. Mr. Shawcross referred to data that had been secured by this investigation, and said that one point which had been cleared up related to the condition of 20's return airway. Even after the time which had elapsed it had been shown that the evidence which had previously been given regarding this airway was demonstratively false. It would be dangerous and foolhardy, according to experts, to invite rescue teams to go into t-he pit and bring the bodies out. When it was reasonably safe to enter the Dennis district it was the owners' intention to do it. Meanwhile, Mr. Hall and those associated with him could continue to play their parts — Mr. Hall the part he had assigned to himself in what he called "this farce." Those who had seen Mr. Hall's photograph and had read his observations in newspapers for which he would receive suitable remuneration, could have their own opinions on the matter. While professing in the daytime to do these heroics he could go home at night and sleep quite comfortably and happily in his bed secure in the knowledge that those upon whom responsibility rested at Gresford pit would not allow him to take unjustifiable risks. Mr. Shawcross complained that from the beginning of the inquiry the Mineworkers' Federation had set out to make a case against the owners, and the method had been one involving unremitting attacks. He deplored, he said, the fact that politics had arisen during the inquiry. It was intolerable that- an inquiry of this kind should be exploited for trade union or political ends. The attack on the private ownership of the pit would lead the public to believe that- there was some trade union attack behind it. Later, Mr. Shawcross said it was -disgraceful to suggest to the public that the firemen had been "got at." It was lamentable that the Welsh Mineworkers' Federation, who instructed Sir Stafford Cripps, had not told him of the habit in the collieries in the Gresford area of Wales to offer firemen continued employment. That was why they found a fireman still in the company's employment after the disaster. Mr. Shawcross also asserted that there was not a scrap of evidence to suggest that the disaster originated in the Dennis district and said the conditions in 14 district were nothing like what the court had been asked to believe. In the entire absence of any evidence suggesting that the disaster originated in 14 or 95, it looked as though an attempt had been made to attribute the source of the disaster to those districts because an explosion originating there might he said to afford more justification than elsewhere for saying that the owners were in some respect to blame. That, he said, was part and parcel of the malicious attack upon the owners. It really mattered very little in an inquiry of this kind who was blamed. If they could say that for some reason or other such and such a place was where the explosion occurred then the owners would gladly accept it whether it involved blame on anyone or not. Mr. Shawcross said it- had been suggested that the desire for out-put was being achieved at the expense of safety conditions in the mine. It illustrated the kind of attack being made on private ownership. If it were true then Parliament or the country should take the matter up. But a judicial inquiry was not the place to investigate the matter. Referring to the general organisation at the colliery. Sir. Shawcross said that Mr. Bonsell had not unnaturally been singled out for a special share of the attack. It was very difficult not to be prejudiced by the evidence of Mr. Cuffin. One ought not to be prejudiced because at the worst that evidence related to his personal conduct after the disaster. What they were concerned with was not what Mr. Bonsell did after the disaster, but to investigate the cause and circumstances of the explosion. Mr. Shawcross criticised Sir Stafford Cripps, who was not present. Sir Stafford, he said, had suggested that Mr. Bonsell should be prosecuted for various breaches of the regulations which he thought had taken place. It seemed quite inappropriate that an advocate appearing before the Commission should make a suggestion of that kind. No doubt the Ministry would be fairly and competently advised as to whether such action should be taken. Mr. Shawcross complained that Sir Stafford had frequently made statements instead of asking questions. It could not be fairly said that Mr. Bonsell was not interested in safety conditions, as had been stated time after time. The best test, he added, was the accident test. At Gresford the accident rate compared very favourably with other collieries. It must give some guide to the general administration of this pit from a safety point of view that during the time Mr. Bonsell was manager the accident rate was exceedingly good compared with other pits in the neighbourhood and the country. Mr. Shawcross said the suggestion behind all the attacks on the firemen was whether perjury had been committed by them, and he asked the Commissioner to discredit this suggestion. Referring to the criticism made against Mr. Bonsell's visits to the Dennis district, Mr. Shawcross said it was easily explained why Mr. Bonsell was not so frequently in this district as elsewhere. The manager was specially concerned with the "slant" where new equipment was being put in. Dealing with the ventilation figures, Mr. Shawcross said it was quite nonsense to regard these figures as unchallengeable facts. Much had been made of the fictitious figures for July and August that had been entered in Mr. Cuffin's little black book. The conclusions which experts had reached in regard to November statistics and previous figures, he declared, was that they could not be right. Mr. Shawcross said the figures for a considerable time past could not he relied upon. He maintained that the fan method of measurement was not accurate, and submitted that the proper method was to add up the intake figures for the various districts of the mine and get the total of the mine as a whole. Quoting a number of intake figures reached by this method, Mr. Shawcross said it would he seen that the intakes for the Dennis district disclosed reasonable constancy. On the whole the averages were maintained right up to the time of the disaster, and it was impossible on these figures to say that there had been any material change in the intake. At the end there was slightly more ventilation going down to the district than before. The increase in the fan revolutions must also have ensured that the Dennis district got a proportionate increase in ventilation. Sir. Shawcross dealt with evidence relating to the ventilation and particularly to the doors in 14's and 20's. The apparent and clear thing regarding ventilation, he said, was that there was a substantially constant supply of air in the Dennis district. An adequate supply of air was also passing through M 4's and M 7's. Mr. Hartley Shawcross continued his speech on Wednesday. Questions concerning the reopening of the pit were put by Mr. Hall and Mr. Smith. Mr. Shawcross, replying, said that if the Mineworkers' Federation, or, if it came to that, the Mines Department, were prepared at this week-end or any other time to take on the responsibility for loss of life and damage to property which might be caused by opening the Gresford pit, it could be opened. Those upon whom the responsibility at present rested would be guided by their experts. So long as the experts' advice was what it is, the offers made by Mr. Hall, whatever headgear he might affect, to go down the pit were mock heroics. Continuing his examination of the evidence on behalf of the owners, Mr. Shawcross submitted that coal dust played no part in the disaster. There were none of the characteristic signs which one expected to find, and which one did find, where coal dust had played a material part in an explosion of that kind. He contended that the Gresford mine, including the Dennis area, was properly stone-dusted. He referred to a sample of dust taken by Sir Henry Walker just after the explosion, the result of which showed 38 per cent. combustible content, which was, on the face of it, a good one. Sir Stafford Cripps, K.C., who appeared for the North Wales Miners' Association, said most definitely that that particular portion of road from which that sample of dust had been obtained had been dusted on the Tuesday before the explosion. The obvious purpose of that statement in regard to that matter u-as to belittle the importance of the favourable result which was obtained. The statement was clearly wrong and entirely unjustified. It now appeared quite clear from the evidence that the particular part of the road from which Sir Henry obtained his sample had not been stone-dusted for a considerable time. Mr. Shawcross then turned to the evidence regarding shotfiring. He contended that never once had a shot in the Gresford colliery "blown out" or "flashed." He also submitted that on no conceivable occasion had any shot been fired in gas at this colliery. Mr. Shawcross said that five people had been alluded to as people who fired an excessive number of shots in the Dennis district. It was perfectly clear in the evidence that all five were working overtime. Regarding the allegation of shotfiring on main haulage roads, Mr. Shawcross said that the only place in which there could be the slightest foundation for the suggestion might have been the main haulage road at the bottom end of 142's deep going into 95's. The importance of the small technical breach of the regulations which might have occurred there had been magnified out of all proportion. The particular regulation was framed at a time when the dangers arising from coal dust created by comparatively fast-moving haulage on main roads were under consideration. It was well recognised to be by all persons concerned with the running of collieries in this country an absolutely obsolete and unworkable regulation, and to be seized upon as a method of attack on the owners of the Gresford Colliery showed the paucity of the material available to those seeking to make an attack on the owners of the pit. Mr. Shawcross said he would concede that there was room for proper criticism at the air split in 109's district. There ought to have been a measurement there as to how the air was being divided at the split. Earlier in the inquiry, he added, it was alleged that- there were quantities of gas in 109's district, not only in a cavity but in the general body of the air along 81's road, and that the district had always been a bad one for gas, that part of the face was fenced off because of the gas, and that the lamps were always going out. Mr. Shawcross characterised these suggestions as "recklessly inaccurate," and said that afterwards it was difficult to see that there was ever a scrap of evidence to that effect. The inquiry adjourned until Thursday.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||