Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

20th June 1936, Page: 394, Column: 1

Accidents To Boys

By T. A. Rogers, H.M. Inspector of Mines.

[Note. — At the May meeting of the Associates and Students' Section of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers Mr. Rogers read a paper on "Accidents to Boys: With Special Reference to the Northern Mines Inspection Division." In his notes the term "boy" refers to "a male under the age of 16 years." Tables and figures were submitted showing the accident rates among boys over a period of years. Points are appended which may be of interest to the mining community in other fields.]

The main points which emerge from an examination of the tables and graphs are that the accident rates for boys employed at mines in the counties of Northumberland and Durham are much higher than the rate for boys employed in the country as a whole, and that they exceed greatly the accident rate for persons of nil ages in the Division. It is therefore, clear that the incidence of accidents to boys cannot be regarded with equanimity. Whilst some very sound reasons may perhaps be advanced to account, in part at least, for the rate of accidents to boys being higher in this Division than in any other, the rate should be reduced considerably. In this connection it should be remembered that in this Division young boys are rarely employed at the coal faces, but work at what are generally supposed to be the safest places. Having painted the worst side of the picture, I feel I should, in fairness, recognise the difficulties of the position. In respect of underground accidents the following may be mentioned

1. The large majority of the boys employed are engaged in haulage operations, that is, in admittedly dangerous occupations.

2. In some of the older mines, particularly where pillars are being extracted, the substitution of conveyors or mechanical haulage for horse haulage is not always practicable and, due to roof and floor movements, it is often very difficult to maintain safe clearance between the tubs and the roof and sides of the horse haulage roadways. In other words, the conditions involve the taking of risk in a higher degree than is the case in newer coalfields.

3. Effective supervision of boys is more difficult than is the case where, as in some coalfields, they commence work at the coal face and are, by law, under the sole supervision of a qualified person for at least two years.

Prevention of Haulage Accidents.

It is chiefly in the prevention of haulage accidents that a reduction in the rates of accidents to boys must be sought. The general considerations determining the incidence of haulage accidents and the methods so often advocated for their reduction are well known. Briefly put, these accidents are chiefly due to (1) what is, for want of a better term, called the "human element,' or (2) bad practice or conditions.

Derailment of Tubs. — These potentially dangerous and very annoying evidences of inefficiencies in the haulage arrangements may usually be traced to defective laying or maintenance of track or tubs. The obvious safeguards are straight and properly graded roads of adequate size, laid with heavy section rails, and effective examination and maintenance of track and tubs.

Crushed between Tubs. — Most of these accidents occur in landings or sidings and are due to the collision of tubs which are being coupled or uncoupled, or to persons pushing tubs being caught by following tubs. Much is being done in the direction of training boys in safe methods of handling tubs, but the real remedy is to reduce the amount of this work by a more extended use of automatic tub-controlling devices.

Crushed between Tubs and Obstructions. — I need hardly suggest that the remedy for this type of accident is the provision of safe clearance. It is a remedy not always easy of application, but two main factors now operating to render it less difficult than formerly are the lessening in the number of roads necessary, due to the use of conveyors, and the extension in the use of steel arches. The importance of the provision of safe clearance cannot be over-estimated, particularly on horse haulage roads where limber riding is permitted. In this connection it is interesting to note that it was suggested to the Royal Commission on Mines in 1908, by Mr. Martin, that "a clear space of not less than 12 Inches should be maintained between the side of any tram or load and the timbers or side of the road, and that at any point where spragging of the wheels is required there should be 2 feet clear." With this suggestion I am in agreement, but I would prefer the minimum clearance to be 18 inches and to have it provided above the tub as well as at the sides.

Caught by, or Coming into Contact With, Moving Ropes or Chains. — These accidents occur chiefly by persons being caught in loops of haulage ropes; inadvertently treading on moving haulage ropes; being caught by sockets or being struck by ropes swinging when tightening. Proper training of the boys in the work to be performed, and the elimination of unnecessary travelling on haulage roads would go far in the direction of reducing accidents of this type.

Uncertainty of Ponies. — The numbers of accidents from this cause are declining and will continue to decline with the decreasing use of ponies. On 31st December, 1934, there were 14,284 ponies on the colliery books, compared with 18,488 on 31st December, 1928. Careful training of ponies and of drivers and attention to the state of the floors of pony haulage roads would accelerate the decline in the accident rate.

Accidents Due to the Use of Machinery. — The rapid extension in the use of machinery necessitates increasing attention to the problem of preventing accidents due to this cause. The primary safeguard (i.e., adequate fencing of moving parts) is, of course, a legal requirement, but careful instruction of the boys in the precautions to be taken in connection with machinery is imperative.

Miscellaneous Accidents: Stumbling and Falling. — In spite of the well-known propensity of young boys to run instead of walking soberly, the incidence of accidents due to this cause is surprisingly high. Five (or 13 per cent.) of the haulage accidents were due to boys being crushed by tubs following a fall. Slipping or falling also accounted for 13 (or 25 per cent.) of the underground accidents, 6 (or 27 per cent.) of the surface accidents and 20 (or 27 per cent.) of the total accidents. Five of the injured boys tripped over rails, two over haulage ropes and one over a step block; two others slipped and were caught by machinery. In this connection it seems to me that the importance of proper footwear is not always fully realised.

The Human Factor.

It is usual to publish in the annual reports of the Divisional Inspectors a classification showing for reportable accidents how responsibility for these accidents was apportioned by the Inspectors who investigated them. I have prepared on these lines a percentage classification showing that "avoidable" accidents were probably 63 per cent. in the case of boys and 55.7 per cent. for persons of all ages.

In considering these figures it should be borne in mind that: (1) The classification is not intended to reflect in any blameworthy sense on the workmen or boys. (2) It is by no means an exact one, depending, as it must, on the opinions of the Inspectors who investigated the accidents. (3) The term "unavoidable" means unavoidable only in the present state of law and accepted practice but not necessarily so in an ultimate sense.

I think I have said enough on this point to show that the field of "avoidable" accidents should be a fruitful one in which to labour with a view to effecting improvement.

A material reduction in the incidence of accidents due to this cause can, I think, be expected only when every worker is: (1) Educated, at the beginning of his working life, in safety principles. (2) Trained by competent persons in the work which he is to perform, and (3) Closely supervised whenever he begins work of a different nature.

That the need for these things exists is becoming increasingly realised, but it seems to me that much remains to be done.

Education Urged 100 Years Ago.

The importance, from the point of view of safety, of educating and training the workers was urged nearly a century ago. Following an explosion at the Haswell Colliery in 1844, the Government, in response to an appeal on behalf of the men, sent down Messrs. Lyell and Faraday to enquire into the causes of the accident. They reported "We believe that if the education of miners generally, and especially of those set over them, can be materially raised, it will conduce to the security of the lives of the men and the perfecting of the art of mining more effectively than any system of Parliamentary inspection which could be devised."

At this period, of course, the condition of the mining population as a whole, and particularly, I think, of the children, was miserable in the extreme. To the Royal Commission of 1840-42 one collier stated that he took his child, only three years of age, underground with him, and "it was made to follow him into the workings, there hold a candle, and when exhausted with fatigue was cradled upon the coals until his return home at night." Such cases were, of course, exceptional, but a general rule prevailed of sending children down at the age of seven or eight years.

The Select Committee on Accidents in Coal Mines (in 1853) were interested in the subject of the better education of officials and also of the children of miners. The interest was chiefly in the direction of better general education of children, but it is of interest to note that a witness, Martin Jude, a Newcastle Innkeeper and Secretary of the Miners' Association, who had been a working miner for 34 years, advocated the teaching of mining in the colliery schools, i.e., to the children. He further suggested that this tuition should be continued at a night school.

The penultimate paragraph of the Committee's Fourth Report makes reference to the subject in these terms :—

"In conclusion, your Committee have to observe, that although their report differs from that of the Committee of 1852, as to the mode of carrying out various details, yet it will be seen, on comparing the two, that the conclusions arrived at by each Committee are nearly identical, viz., that improved ventilation, efficient supervision, increased inspection, and the education of all parties engaged in this dangerous branch of commercial enterprise, must be relied on for the decrease of the numerous fatal accidents that occur annually in the coal mines."

North-country Training Schemes.

The importance of technical training is fully recognised in Germany, where the law requires that no person shall be permitted to work underground in a mine under the age of 16 years. whilst between the ages of 14 and 18 every boy is required to undergo at least 8 hours technical training per fortnight during his off duty period.

A scheme for the training of colliery boys in safety principles was inaugurated in the Yorkshire Division in 1931 and was adopted in the Northern Division in the autumn of 1933. To those who are not familiar with the working of the scheme brief particulars may be of interest.

The classes are organised, financed and run by the Education Authorities and have the wholehearted support of colliery companies, officials and workmen. The course, which is not intended to supersede any of the existing Junior Mining Courses, comprises 12 lessons, each of 1½ hours duration and usually held weekly. Instruction is confined to the teaching of safety principles by practical certificated mining officials (chiefly under-managers). At the end of the course an oral examination is held for those boys who have made three-quarters or more of the possible attendances and each successful student is awarded a badge, known as the Durham and Northumberland Mines Safety Badge, with his name engraved on the back. The cost of the badges is defrayed by the Miners' Welfare Fund. In a number of instances special prizes are given by the colliery companies and the workmen's representatives.

Instruction is very simple in character, and the boys take a keen interest and are most enthusiastic. They are taught how to avoid the common dangers that may befall them; the proper way of performing their ordinary work or work which they may be called upon to perform; the use of safety devices ; the principles of the flame and electric safety-lamp; the value of protective equipment; and the ordinary precautions to be taken both on the surface and belowground. Visits are arranged to the collieries where they are shown around the surface plant, including the shops, lamproom, etc., so as to combine practical knowledge with what they have been taught in the classroom. The colliery companies provide the necessary practical equipment, such as flame and electric safety-lamps; miniature tubs; safety devices telephone and signalling circuits, etc., and any further apparatus that may be required.

At the beginning of the present Session (1935-6) it was decided to allow any badge holder who applied, to take the course again. In the event of his success in a second examination he is awarded a certificate to that effect.

The recruitment of boys into the industry for Northumberland and Durham appears to ho somewhere in the region of 4,000 per year. Until the yearly total of boys attending safety classes approaches the total of entrants into the industry, there is room for improvement. In this connection I would appeal to all to encourage the attendance of boys, and to further the scheme by any other means within their power. Enthusiasm often needs fostering, and I think it is true to say that when officials and work. men co-operate wholeheartedly in this direction, there is no difficulty in running safety classes. I look forward to the day when every boy commencing work will pass through the safety class.

Practical Training.

It cannot be too strongly emphasised that the tuition given at the safety classes cannot take the place of practical training at the pit. It is true, I think, that practically all managers and their officials take a good deal of interest in this question of practical training, and that at every colliery training of a sort is given. A lad usually commences work at the surface, and, after a period varying from a few weeks to perhaps more than a year is sent below ground. He probably works first at the shaft, and then as he acquires pit sense is gradually sent to work farther inbye, accompanied for a short period on each new job by a more experienced lad.

This is all very good, but it does not, in my view, go far enough, mainly because the tutors are in many cases little older than their pupils and have themselves, often enough, not been properly taught the safe way of performing the work falling to their lot. In the result the new lad is, I fear, taught any bad habits acquired by his mentor.

At many of the larger collieries in the Division the lads are taught the elements of their work by experienced and carefully chosen workmen or officials at training grounds both above and belowground. At a colliery near Newcastle-upon-Tyne every boy on first commencing work receives practical instruction for one day a week, first on the surface training ground for three months, then on the underground training ground for a similar period.

At one Northumberland colliery new lads are the special care of the safety officer.

Summarising, the points to which attention should be directed with a view to reducing accidents to boys are :—

1. Attendance at Safety Classes either before or immediately after the beginning of employment.

2. Practical training under competent persons.

3. Effective supervision, particularly over probationary periods.

4. See that boys are sent only to work of a suitable nature and that the conditions under which the work is performed give them every chance of avoiding accidents.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Faraday, —      
Jude, Martin      Whos Who Page
Lyell, —      
Martin, —      
Rogers, Thomas Arthur    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print