|
23rd May 1936, Page: 358, Column: 1 Safety In MinesInspectors Offer SuggestionsWhen the Royal Commission on Safety resumed on 4th May with Mr. E. H. Frazer of the Scotland Division giving evidence, references were made to the standards of adequate ventilation in mines, and the Inspector suggested that with weekly air sampling and analysis as an additional safeguard there was no reason why the maximum permissible percentage should not be reduced to 1 per cent. Returning to the suggested reasons for the increase during the last twelve years in the accident rate on the manshift basis in the Scottish mines Mr. Fraser gave it as his opinion that "the packing has much to do with the matter, and it is suggested that this subject should receive more attention. It should be compulsory for a manager to specify how, where, and at what distance apart packs should be built. To neglect propping is an offence, but to neglect packing, a far more serious matter, is no offence. This should be altered." As to the "rush and bustle" which was alleged as one of the reasons for the increased accident rate at the working face, this was not necessarily due to the men being on piece work. A great many of them are not on piece work, but they still have to bustle. it is inevitable if you have eight hours in which to do certain jobs. Mr. Edwards: The rush and bustle is to get coal at the expense of safety? Mr. Fraser: No, it is to get coal and continue to get coal from day to day as safely as possible. The witness, remarking that hard hats had been introduced at some collieries, said it seemed that the men were not altogether in favour of them. Whether or not the men were used to wearing caps underground, it was found that after they got hard hats they would leave these with their clothes at some point in the roadway and go about their work bareheaded. Referring to explosions, Mr. Fraser said the use of naked lights, which accounted for most of the accidents, had been adhered to in the past because of the cost of safety-lamps, because of the knowledge that their introduction meant the adoption of permitted explosives and the employment of authorised shot-firers, and because of the fear that the output per man would suffer. Now that electric cap-lamps were available which would give as much light as naked lights, the last objection had disappeared, but the others remained. It might be laid down, he suggested, that every mine should be worked with safety-lamps, with certain exceptions, and thus put on the owners the burden of proving a mine to be safe for naked lights before adopting them. Discussing the human element, the Inspector said: "Individual carelessness or the lack of safety consciousness is responsible for half the minor accidents and a large proportion of the serious accidents. Inculcating safety sense in miners is one of the most elusive and difficult problems of mining. Miners become accustomed to danger, and meet so much of it, that it becomes too familiar. Safety must become second nature to them if it is to be of service." Safety committees of officials and representatives of workmen had been tried, but rarely survived long. Suggestion boxes for safety hints and competitions for safety suggestions with money prizes for good ideas had been tried, but bad only a short life, though they were useful. Lantern-slide notices, illustrations at the pithead, and cinema films were among the devices used. Success in the movement could only be obtained by continually and consistently keeping the subject of safety before the eyes and in the ears of the workmen. Mr. T. Greenland Davies, the Inspector in Charge of the Northern Division, was the next witness to appear before the Commission, and he said the accident rates in the Division were consistently below and in some cases substantially below those of the country as a whole. "The general conditions are somewhat easier than in some of the other coalfields," he added, "and it also reflects some credit on managements and workmen." Dealing with administrative work he said that the office and executive duties involved prevented him from being in as close touch as he would have liked with the mines and quarries, and with those chiefly responsible for running them. He advocated smaller divisions, say 12 to 14, as they could be conveniently grouped. Should any increase in the staff of the inspectorate be decided upon, this should be effected by the appointment of additional junior inspectors. Each divisional inspector should be responsible for his area and should be linked direct with the Mines Department. The appointment of an under-manager in addition to the manager should be compulsory in the case of any mine employing over 500 persons above and below ground. An official with either a first or second-class certificate of competency should be appointed in writing by the manager to be in charge in the absence of the manager and the under-manager of shifts in which more than 100 persons were employed below ground. Mr. Davies said he was not satisfied that the most suitable men were being attracted for the work of firemen, examiners or deputies. The standard of remuneration should in some cases be raised considerably. Other suggestions made were that statutory duty and responsibility should rest on the controlling authorities and the superintendents of rescue stations to equip, maintain and conduct the stations in accordance with the general regulations. It should also be made compulsory for all persons wbo supplied machinery for use in mines to see that it was properly safeguarded before being put into use. Speaking of ventilation, the Inspector suggested that the systematic sampling of mine air now practised at some mines should be made universal. The air-current in every ventilating district should be sampled at intervals not exceeding one month, and one of the places to be sampled should be the face of the last working place. The samples should be analysed for oxygen, carbon dioxide, and firedamp and the results entered in a book required to be kept at the mine for that purpose and the copies of any adverse sample sent to the divisional inspector. The Coal Mines Act required the use of safety-lamps in any seam in which an explosion in inflammable gas had caused any personal injury within the previous 12 months. "I see no reason to wait for persons to be killed in an explosion before safety-lamps can be insisted upon," said Mr. Davies. "I consider that in any seam the finding of firedamp on the flames of a safety-lamp should be regarded as evidence sufficiently strong to require the use of safety-lamps throughout the seam." He also suggested that the law might be strengthened so as to require the whole of the roof within twenty yards of the working face to be systematically supported, except where it could be shown that the conditions were unsuitable. Although the systematic support of all roadways was not practicable, it should be compulsory to support systematically all places where persons were regularly employed, such as gate-ends or conveyor loaders and junctions. The Commission sat again on Monday, 18th May, to complete the evidence of Mr. Davies and also to hear evidence from Mr. J. Macleod Carey, O.B.E., H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines in charge of the Cardiff and Forest of Dean Division.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||