23rd May 1936, Page: 357, Column: 1
Coal Mines Bill, 1936
There is evidence that the passing of the new Coal Mines Bill
will be strongly opposed by the different parties concerned. A
few days ago Mr. Gordon Macdonald, the Member for Ince,
addressing the annual meeting of his party in the Division. said
it had been his job as secretary of the Miners' Group in the House
of Commons to "wade through" the Bill. He assured them that
if that legislation was all that was going to be done for the miners
it would not help them; it made no provision for miners displaced
by amalgamations. The miners were entitled to be treated as
as any other body of workers, and every piece of legislation that
was brought in which would displace workers provided generous
compensation for them. They had appealed, Mr. Macdonald
said, for representation on those bodies which determined the
price of coal. There was no provision whatever for that in the
new legislation. "We shall oppose it," said Mr. Macdonald, "as
sure as I stand here."
The Executive Committee of the Federation of British Industries
has passed a resolution on the subject of the Government's
proposals re the compulsory amalgamation of coal mines. The
Federation, in the resolution, says it regards with serious mis
giving
the application to industrial affairs of the principle of
compulsion exercised without the consent of the majority of the
industry concerned, If, however, the Government adheres to its
decision to apply this principle, the Federation urges that additional
safeguards should be included in the Bill. Such safeguards
should permit of a right of appeal to an impartial tribunal and
should ensure that no scheme becomes operative except after a
positive resolution by both Houses of Parliament, under provisional
order procedure.
At a meeting on the 14th May of members of the Mining
Association of Great Britain a resolution proposed by Sir Adam
Nimmo, vice-president of the association, and seconded by Lord
Gainford strongly condemning the Coal Mines Bill now before
Parliament was unanimously adopted. The resolution ran as
follows :—
This meeting of chairmen and directors of British colliery
companies specially convened to consider the Coal Mines Bill
now before Parliament records its emphatic condemnation of the
principle of the Bill and its strongest opposition to the specific
provisions embodied therein. The Bill gives power to a Government
Department compulsorily to transfer property from its
present ownership without any effective opportunity for appeal
or proper provision for compensation. It sweeps away the safeguards
set up by Parliament in 1980, and by giving to a Government
Department complete control over the property thus transferred
it applies an extreme form of bureaucracy to the coal industry
and establishes a precedent. for its extension to any other industry.
For these reasons the meeting urges upon the Government the
withdrawal of the Bill.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| MacDonald, Gordon | | M.P. | |