|
25th April 1934, Page: 330, Column: 1 Safety In MinesSwansea Division ConditionsIn the Swansea Division last year the number of mines at work was 194, of which 90 were small. Approximately the output was 11½ million tons and 48,000 persons were employed. Only about 5 per cent. of the coal was machine-mined. These figures were given by Mr. T. Ashley, the Inspector in Charge of the Division, who further said in his evidence before the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines that since the Swansea division was formed in 1924 the number of mines had decreased by one-third and the number of parsons employed underground by 29 per cent. The output, however, had only decreased by 18 per cent. The changes since 1911 in methods of working and equipment were almost negligible. During the ten years 1925-35 (excluding 1926) there were 622 fatal accidents underground, with 648 deaths. There were 2,398 non-fatal separate accidents and 2,525 persons had been injured. Fatal accidents on the surface numbered 72 and non-fatal 823. The view was expressed by Mr. Ashley that "small mines" on the whole, while not causing much trouble from the accident point of view, entailed more time being spent on them in administrative matters than their size or importance justified. He also thought that divisional inspectors should be free as far as possible to devote their time to the work of inspection rather than to clerical and administrative work. Upon the question of management he stated that the Coal Mines Act held the manager solely responsible for matters over which he had little or no control. The position of under-managers was similar. Better supervision would be obtained if under-managers were appointed where 200 persons or more wore employed underground and if power were given to the Mines Department to require two or more under-managers. Under-managers or overmen might be required by statute to make reports. As to inspections, he suggested that three inspections should be made by firemen on each shift; that the first and last should be reported, and that the size of a fireman's district might be reduced so that he could examine within one and a half hours instead of the two-hour period now laid down. No place in any mine should remain uninspected for more than three hours, instead of the five hours now permitted in mines worked by a succession of shifts. Mr. Ashley holds the view that workmen's inspections serve a very useful purpose; for this reason they should be encouraged, but last year, excluding the "small mines," there were 30 mines where the workmen did not make any inspection. Lord Rockley, the Chairman of the Commission, referring to the figures relating to the inspections by workmen, was at a loss to understand the variation from year to year, and wondered if any means could be suggested for encouraging the inspections. Mr. Ashley was unable fully to explain the variation but said: "It may he a question of payment in some cases. Such payment might come out of the Miners Welfare Fund." The Inspector recognised that a sample of air gave only the amount of gas present at the moment, and also that the amount was constantly changing, but he suggested that systematic sampling of the air of the ventilating current in a mine would be a useful guide to the management as to the state of the ventilation, and would serve as a check to the under-officials. Its use would, he urged, probably be psychological rather than practical. The use of small fans for ventilating places in advance of the general ventilation should be encouraged. Those fans should preferably be driven by compressed air, but if driven electrically the motor and switch-gear should be certified flameproof. With general reference to ventilation, the evidence given was to the effect that in mines where shot-firing was ordinarily carried out shot-firing was stopped when any percentage of firedamp showed on the flame of the lamp, but workmen were not withdrawn unless the gas content reached the 2½ per cent. withdrawal limit. The standard of withdrawal, 2½ per cent., under section 67 of the Coal Mines Act, for safety-lamp mines did not need to be reduced. As a suggestion for a standard under section 29 of the Act, no district should be considered to be adequately ventilated if two or more adjacent working places in it showed 1½ per cent. or upwards in the general body of the air in those places. The same standard might be applied to conveyor faces on which the conveyor was driven by compressed air. A considerable amount of air was wasted by leakage between intake and return airways, and in many instances a good deal of the leakage could be avoided if a minimum distance could be maintained between these airways. With regard to the provision of two main intake airways, Mr. Ashley said that, probably, solely from a ventilation point of view, better results would be obtained if two returns to each ventilating district had to be provided instead of two intakes, but in all new mines two intakes and two returns in each ventilating district might be very beneficial. Exemption from the provision of two main intakes might be allowed to mines equipped to employ fewer than 1,000 persons underground. He agreed with one of the Commissioners that the object of mine legislation from the very beginning was to emphasise and to insist on the maintenance of better atmospheric conditions in mines and that it was one of the fundamental interests of good mining practice to maintain the highest possible standard. Generally speaking, the standard in his Division was quite satisfactory. He suggested that no district should be considered adequately ventilated if two or more adjacent working places in it showed 1½ per cent. or upwards of gas in the general body of the air in those places. In mines where they have electricity and shot-firing he would agree with other witnesses who suggested that more than 1 per cent. of gas would not represent adequate ventilation. He does not think the Inspectors in his Division are too lenient with regard to the presence of gas. Following evidence favourable to the use of protective equipment, and the use of steel arches in mines which would reduce the amount of repair work and keep the roads of uniform size, Mr. Ashley said insufficient clearance between trams and roof and sides was one of the chief causes of accidents. He then dealt with safety classes for boys, which as is known have been less popular in South Wales than in some other districts, attendance at many centres falling far short of the enrolments. "With one of two exceptions very little interest has been taken in this matter by owners and managers and still less by the boys themselves," he said. "One great difficulty is to get the boys together in the evening as so many live in large towns a long distance away from the mine at which they are employed. During the latter months of 1934 owners took more interest in the proposed classes than they had done previously." Dealing with roof and side accidents, Mr. Ashley said the accident rate caused by falls of ground was higher in the Swansea Division than for the country as a whole in the years 1931, 193?, and 1934. The year 1933 was an exception. By far the largest proportion of the fatal and serious non-fatal accidents from falls of roof at the working face occurred close up to the coal face, and these usually occurred while the coal was being got. Closer and more systematic support of the roof was needed. The roof at the loading end of all conveyers, whether gravity or mechanical, should be closely supported either by steel arches or by steel flats. Of the falls at the working face 58 per cent. were falls of roof, and 42 per cent. falls of side. About 22 per cent. were classified as avoidable by ordinary caution. Falls of roof possibly could be guarded against by close support, but falls of side were more difficult to prevent, and many depended on the human factor, especially when getting down the coal in the inclined seams in the Swansea Division. Clod overlying nearly all the seams was a constant source of danger. False slips in the coal often allowed more coal to come down than was expected, causing the collier to be trapped. The provision and use of proper tools, such as pinch bars, when getting down the coal and clod were essential. The Commission met again on Monday, 20th April, for the purpose of completing the hearing of evidence from Mr. Ashley, and also to hear evidence from Mr. E. H. Frazer, O.B.E., M.Sc., the Divisional Inspector of Mines for Scotland.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||