Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

14th March 1936, Page: 280, Column: 2

Notes On Surveyors' Examination

Central Examiner's Report

The table prepared by the Central Examiner shows that at the November (1935) examination for mine surveyors' certificates 65 candidates were present, and of this number 18 qualified in the written examination. There were only eight passes in the practical examination, therefore the percentage of candidates who qualified was 12.3, as compared with 9.6 in November 1934 and 17.5 in November 1933.

In the report the statement is made that in the written part of the examination the percentage qualifying was up to the average of the last five years, but even so it cannot be said that the work generally accomplished reached the standard which might reasonably have been anticipated from the nature of the papers set. Not one single set of answers of outstanding merit was obtained, the Central Examiner says, and even those candidates who qualified did so, in the majority of instances, with little or nothing to spare. The fact that the marks earned by candidates who failed to qualify in the written examination amounted to only 35 per cent, of the maximum is definite evidence of the disappointing nature of the answers. In this connection there is the further disconcerting fact that a considerable number of candidates who have presented themselves for examination on several occasions show little, if indeed any, improvement since their first appearance. If it be unfair to suggest that this indicates lack of application, the report concludes, it certainly indicates that they are not profiting by past experience.

Comments on Answers.

Below we give the text of the questions set at the examination, each question being followed by the comment of the Examiner on the work generally of the candidates. The comments are in italics. The official pamphlet containing the Question Papers (2s. net) is obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office.

Morning Session.

(1) Compulsory Question. — The plan . . . . shows roadways in two seams, the strata between which are known to be of uniform thickness and inclination. The roadways indicated by dotted lines are in the upper seam, those by solid lines in the lower. It is proposed to drive a cross-measures drift, rising at an inclination of 1 in 3, in the direction indicated by the broken line on the plan — and commencing at the 435 level point in the lower seam — to intersect the upper seam. Calculate as accurately as you can from the details given on the plan (a) the thickness of the strata between the two seams; (b) the length of the proposed cross-measures drift; (c) the direction and rate of full dip of the seams. Thereafter mark on the plan the point where the drift will hole through on the floor of the upper seam. (14)

Answers to this compulsory and by no means difficult question were exceedingly disappointing, only 20 per cent, being correct, or even approximately 80. While a majority were able to ascertain the thickness of strata and the direction and rate of full dip, with fair accuracy, it was obvious from the answers that upwards of one-half of the candidates had no clear idea of how the length of the proposed drift could be accurately determined.

(2) Undernoted are details of a short traverse in a coal seam :—

If the direction of full dip of the seam be from station C to station F., and the rate of full dip be 4½ inches to the yard, calculate the difference in level between station B and station E. (12)

This question was generally attempted. Answers were also disappointing, less than 30 per cent, being correct. Many candidates attempted to solve the question by first of all calculating the co-ordinates of the entire traverse, and thereafter calculating the distance B E — a method lengthy and, in part, unnecessary. Few realised that the solution of the question entailed little more than the calculation of the distance C F, and the gradient of the lines F E and C B

(3) A correlation of surface and underground traverses has to be made by means of two weighted wires hung in a vertical shaft approximately 20 feet in diameter, and you are instructed to carry out the work either by (a) the Weisbach triangle method, or (b) setting up on the exact alignment of the wires. State which of the two methods you would adopt and give your reasons for the choice. In the case of method (a) describe briefly the circumstances in which the angular measurements call for a greater degree of exactitude than the linear measurements, and vice versa. Assuming conditions entirely favourable, at what distance from the nearest wire would you decide, in either case, to set up the theodolite? (10)

A fair number of exceedingly good answers were received, including several from candidates who advocated the alignment method with marked ability. The least satisfactory part of the answers, as a rule, was that dealing with the comparison of exactitude in linear and angular measurement, which was frequently imperfectly understood.

(4) You are asked to construct a template for the purpose of bending rails for an important curve underground. State how you would do so. Calculate the data necessary to enable you to construct a template 12 feet in length for a curve of 60 feet radius. Your calculations should determine the position of the curved side of the template at intervals of approximately one foot. (8)

This question was very rarely attempted, and then invariably with such scanty success as to make it a reasonable inference that candidates had no actual experience of the work asked for. Only one or two had any clear conception of how the offsets to determine the curved side of the template were to be obtained.

(5) The verticality of a colliery chimney, 10 feet in diameter at the base has been slightly affected by draw due to subsidence, and after thorough investigation the undernoted observations were taken with the theodolite to determine the extent thereof. The instrument was set up at a point 167 feet distant from the base of the chimney on a line approximately at right angles to the direction of overhang. Calculate the extent to which the centre line of the chimney is off the vertical. (8)

Surprisingly few candidates attempted this simple question, and of those who did so, only 20 per cent, obtained a correct or approximately correct answer.

Afternoon Session.

(1) Compulsory Question. — The sketch . . . ., which is not drawn to scale, shows the boundaries of a small property which forms part of a colliery leasehold. It is proposed, without alteration of area, to substitute for the crooked boundary line ABCDE a straight line parallel to GF, starting near A on the line AG and terminating on FE produced. From the details given hereunder and on the sketch, calculate the position of the beginning and end of the new boundary line in relation to the points A and E respectively. (14)

Candidates generally met with little success in this compulsory question, only four correct answers being obtained. As a rule they realised that it was necessary, in the first place, to determine the bearing and distance of the line AE, but having done so — either correctly or incorrectly — subsequent procedure found them invariably in a maze.

(2) The plan . . . . shows an area of ground with contour lines at vertical intervals of 10 feet and the end of a haulage way along which mine debris is conveyed thereto for deposit. The debris is being deposited at a level of 140 feet above Ord. Dat., and it is a condition of the mineral lease that it must not extend beyond the boundary fence ABCDE shown on the plan. Show on the plan by a dotted line the position to which the top of the heap may be extended so as to enable the maximum amount of debris to be deposited without encroaching on the property beyond the boundary fence. Assume that the angle of repose of the debris is 1½ horizontal to 1 vertical. (12)

This contour line problem produced a fair number of correct answers, but the fact remains that upwards of 40 per cent, of the candidates who attempted it had no idea whatever of how to obtain the necessary solution.

(3) A haulage roadway AB in a coal seam is intersected at the point B by a downthrow fault of unknown displacement which bears N35°W and hades at 60°. Two boreholes C and D have been put down from the surface in line with AB produced and intersected the seam, and from a special traverse and levelling the undernoted details have been obtained :—

Calculate the length of a dip cross-measures drift to be driven from A, in the same direction as AB, at a gradient of 4½ inches to the yard to intersect the seam on the east side of the fault. Assume the gradient of the seam in the latter area to be as dis closed by the boreholes. (12)

Answers were disappointing, only about 20 per cent, being correct or even approximately so. The lack of success by candidates in tackling tunnelling questions has previously been commented on, and the criticism still holds good.

(4) Undernoted are the results of a round of levelling between four bench marks :—

A check levelling in the reverse direction gave the undernoted results :—

The respective distances between the several B.M.'s are as follow:— A to B, 2.25 miles; B to C, 4 miles; C to D, 1.75 miles; D to A, 3 miles. Calculate the probable value of the level of each Bench Mark, assuming A to be 262.862 feet above Ordnance Datum. (10)

This precise levelling question was almost invariably attempted. Results as a rule were far from satisfactory, and it was obvious that only a few candidates had any idea of the proper and recognised method of obtaining the result asked for.

(5) Calculate the volume of excavation necessary in making the foundation for a building at a colliery where the surface slopes uniformly at 1 in 20 and is to be excavated to give a level bottom 80 feet square, with sides sloping at 1 in 4. Give your answer in cubic yards. (8)

A fair number of good answers were obtained, but also many very poor ones for such a straightforward question.

(6) The boundary of a colliery leasehold extends for a distance of approximately 2,000 feet along the centre line of a comparatively shallow stream, which as a result of considerable subsidence has had its course practically obliterated in marshy land. Owing to considerable shrinkage, the draft plan of the leasehold has become inaccurate, and a new plan is required. Describe the steps you would take to ensure that that part of the leasehold boundary originally defined by the stream would be shown in as nearly as possible its correct position on your new plan. You are to assume that the details of the original survey are not now available. (8)

Answers were fair. Some candidates proposed to ascertain the amount of shrinkage on the original draft plan and thereafter re-plot the stream therefrom on the new draft — a somewhat difficult operation unless the original plan had been graticuled.


Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
31 Aug 1935  Board For Mining Examinations (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Feb 1936  Examination Results (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Mar 1936  Notes On Surveyors' Examination, Central Examiner's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Mar 1936  November (1935) Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Apr 1936  November (1935) Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Apr 1936  November (1935) Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print