|
14th March 1936, Page: 277, Column: 1 Accident Risks And RepairsA paper on "Accident Risks and Repairs," by Mr. S. Walton-Brown, M.Sc., was submitted for discussion at the meeting on 29th February of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers, in which it was stated that the development of the use of protective equipment at a colliery raised two problems : (1) Which parts of the body were most liable to damage; (2) Which were the most dangerous occupations. The data were derived from one colliery and based on a period of three years' duration. Elsewhere, it was pointed out, results may show variation. There were no nystagmus cases. Examined on a percentage basis, the only parts affected by injuries of over six months' duration were the body and the legs. Although 32.74 per cent. of the accidents affected hands, all these recovered in less than five months despite the fact that they formed 45.46 per cent. of the accidents over one month and 38.7 per cent. of the accidents over two months. The table also shows that 63.43 per cent. of injured persons recover in less than a month, and that only 1.02 per cent. of the accidents extend over six months. As revealed in the second table injuries to hands were the most frequent, representing 32.74 per cent. of the accidents. Leg injuries equal 23.79 per cent., and body 16.11, whilst foot injuries figure out to 10.74 and arms to 8.18 per cent. The remainder were head, face, eyes, and other injuries. The Author showed that 14.29 per cent. of the accidents to officials affected the head; 14.28 per cent. the body; 14.29 per cent. the arms; 28.57 per cent, the legs; and 28.57 per cent. the feet. Officials therefore run greater than the average percentage risk in the case of the head, arms, legs and feet, and less in all other parts. The grade percentages of accident risks were: officials, 1.79; fillers, 32.22; putters, 23.27; lads, 13.30; machinemen, 10.23; stonemen, 1.28; shifters, 5.38; miscellaneous underground, 1.79 mechanics, 2.56; and screeners, 8.18 per cent. The fillers (who do all the face-work) represent the largest proportion, putters figuring second. The liability to accident in various occupations relative to the average frequency taken as unity worked out thus: officials, 0.44; fillers, 0.95; putters, 2.87 ; lads, 1.16; machinemen, 2.03; stonemen, 0.94; shifters, 0.78; miscellaneous underground, 0.32 ; mechanics, 0.22; and screeners, 0.71. It will be seen that on the unity basis the putters (2.87) have the greatest liability to accident, but no such accident extended over four months' duration, and Mr. Walton-Brown said they give the use of cap-lamps the credit for this. The men most liable to serious accident are the fillers, machinemen, and miscellaneous underground workers, the last being due probably to the test period of three years being too brief. Taking unity (1) as the liability to accident, the figures show that the risk of an accident of over six months' duration is 0.009. The conclusion drawn by Mr. Walton-Brown from the tables and details submitted is that protective equipment as it now exists is more likely to be of value by the prevention of minor, rather than of major, accidents in the case under review. Hands and legs seem to be the most promising source of an improvement. Gloves to shield the hands are now available, but in the case of legs something fresh is required. Leg safety can not be met by the ordinary football shin-guard. The design required for putters would appear to take the form of the steel reinforced leather guards worn by army drivers, and in the case of face workers, something like the heavy pads worn by cricketers. Such leg-guards or pads must give definite and complete protection to the ankle and leg up to above the knee, and must be able to resist pressure or heavy weights whether applied from the front or from the side. The types of leg accident to be watched are :— (1) The sliding of heavy pieces of band stone from the sides or the packs, whether pulled over by the worker intentionally or not. (2) The breaking of large pieces of stone when being lifted by hand. (3) Falls of roof. (4) Tools or other material being caused to spring against the leg by heavy weights sliding or falling thereon. (5) Jam between tubs. The Author said they had not yet solved this leg problem to their satisfaction, but there do seem to be great possibilities in adequate leg protection. Hard hats are now used throughout, but the tables did not indicate the possibility of great accident economy in this respect. Hard hats were not employed during tbe test period recorded in the tables. Fracture Clinics Advocated. In the second portion of the paper, dealing with accident repairs, Mr. Walton-Brown suggested that every precaution should be taken to ensure that those who are incapacitated effect not only a complete recovery but also a recovery at the earliest possible moment. While there is a financial side to this problem there is also a much greater human side in the attempt to reduce the period of disability and the number of unnecessary deformities. There seemed to him to be a definite case for specialisation in the treatment of fractures, taking the form of Mining Fracture Clinics to deal with every case of fracture, large or small, and also cases involving joints and tendons. The proportion of fractures to total injuries in mines was 1.5 per cent. At the first glance this does not seem a very large figure, but when one remembers that many of the accidents in mines are very slight and involve little cost, one realises that fractures must represent a very much larger proportion of the total cost and total incapacity-duration periods than the mere percentage figure indicates. It is the opinion of the Author, from his own knowledge, that there seems to be opportunity for improvement not oniy in the reduction of permanent cases but also in the treatment of minor fracture cases. He concluded by saying that "the present system of recording the rate of accidents relative to man-shifts worked or persons employed or tonnage produced does not afford a complete picture of mine injuries, and this will be still more obvious if first-class fracture clinics are organised as, although by their means disability period figures may be greatly reduced, the initial accident incidence figures might still remain the same.
|
|||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||